Usefulness of circular plane
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Who uses circular planes, like the Stanley/Record 20/020, and how useful do you find them?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Usefulness of circular plane
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Who uses circular planes, like the Stanley/Record 20/020, and how useful do you find them?
Re: Usefulness of circular plane
ThomD
>DO you mean the adjustible ones? I have a 113, and modern record with a Hock blade in it some such.
One thing about them is they don't really bend into a circle the ones I have appear to have a constant thickness sole plate. When you bend that it is parabolic, greatest rate of change around the blade, which is not as useful an arangement as it might be. I do find them occasionally useful, but more a general shaping tool than one that dictates a shape, as would a jointer etc...
There is a story in one of Krenovs books about a table he made that consisted of two curved planks joined together. He could have pattern routed it, but he built planes and had a very hard time making the joint. This plane would be a better thing for roughing out the router pattern than planing the two halves for the joint.
I'd be interested in one that used some method (pattent pending) to allow the sole to take a pure curve, be it a tapered sole plate or other mechanical device.
Re: Usefulness of circular plane
Moses Yoder
>I am building a sideboard with gently curved legs and arches on the bottom of the face frame and end panels. My #113 was used a lot on these parts. The #20 is a better plane that the #113. I used to keep the iron square like a smoothing plane but while shaping the hickory legs I put a curve on the iron like a jack plane and it worked better.
Re: Usefulness of circular plane
Dean Lapinel
>Moses,
"The #20 is a better plane that the #113."
Would you mind expanding on this comment? It's not that I disagree, it's more that I respect your thoughts.
Re: Usefulness of circular plane
ThomD
>113s are too nice to use. The adjuster on the Record is real stout, the end controls are tougher than on the 113, just seems like a better using plane. People sometimes answer boatbuilding relative to these planes, but they aren't all that tough. The big issue is what can you do with one of these that you can't with a spokeshave. Not much, but the base can be adjusted to bottom at a given curve.
They have their place...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>If your doing a lot curved work. I have a Stanley 20 and a 113.
The 20 is heavier than the 113 for what it's worth. The 113 can be bent into a tighter radii than the 20.
They do a good job of smoothing curves cut on the band saw or any other saw for that matter. The adjustments for both planes work well.
Some will say the 113 is flawed because the front knob controls the radii of the sole and it can be changed when planing. As long as the locking screw is tightened I've never experienced this phenomenon.
Of course you can always use a spindle sander... Ahhhhhhhh!
Re: Usefulness of circular plane
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Bill
While I mostly use spokeshaves for curves, the Record #020 I have gets pulled out for those occasions when the curve needs to be faired.
Such as in this head- and tailboard ..
I find that the #020 can work extreemely well - as long as you keep an eye on grain direction!
Regards from Perth
Derek
Thanks, all
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I got skunked on the one on which I was bidding, though it seems slightly over $100 is a going rate. Maybe later, if I find spokeshaves aren't enough.