Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

Posts

Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#1

Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

I have a No. 8 plough iron marked "Cox & Luckman", then "Warranted Cast Steel" below that, and above it all a billy goat's head and the word Trade Mark around the goat's head.

Question: When might have this blade been made? Also, where in the UK?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#2

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

Peter Evans

>Birmingham. Goat's head mark registered in 1877. Firm folded in 1914, but mark probably used by successors, until at latest 1931. Common maker, quality declined after 1900.

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#3

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Peter,

Thank you very much! This is helping me make a decision on a small matter.

One other, if I might, if you have any information as to possible dates. This is also a plough iron, marked 'W. Butcher', 'Sheffield' on the next line under, and the logo 'W _ R' above it all, where there is a crown between the W and the R. The iron is not marked as to number, though it is a No. 5.

Thank you very much,

Wiley

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#4

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Peter Evans

>Wiley, William & Sam Butcher, Eyre Lane Sheffield. Started around 1824 and finished sometime after 1919 (by this date they were W&S Butcher Ltd).

Manufacturers of steel, files, edge tools & joiners' tools, saws, razors & cutlery

Registered trademark below.


img

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#5

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Don McConnell

>Hi Wiley,

Among the speculations about the various W. BUTCHER marks is the thought that the W * R mark stood for "William Rex" and was used during the reign of King William IV (1830 - 1837). If correct, this would significantly narrow the time range during which your plough plane iron would have been manufactured. I think this is a reasonable assumption, but do not know if it has been verified.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#6

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Peter Evans

>Interesting contribution as usual Don. The mark does not appear in Goodman, but they are mainly showing plane marks, not iron marks.

If the mark is a reference to WIV, would it not have been used by a number of makers to signify loyalty or some such?

I assume you are familiar with the Woodhead work on trademarks (if link does not appear below it is www.sha.org/research_resources/documents/Trademarks%20on%20Base-Metal%20Tableware.pdf )

Cheers Peter

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#7

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Don McConnell

>Peter et al,

I don't recall, off hand, seeing other maker's marks with the "W*R" embellishment, but will see what I can find this evening. The presumption is that this embellishment was a short-hand means of indicating that the company officially enjoyed the patronage of the royal household.

In the meantime, I'm including a small image of one of six marks illustrated in an 1879 advertisement by Thomas Turner & Co., another Sheffield firm. The relevancy, of course, being that 1879 was during the reign of Queen Victoria.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


img

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#8

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Don McConnell

>Hi Peter,

I don't recall, off hand, seeing other maker's marks with the "W*R" embellishment, but will see what I can find this evening. However, the presumption is that this embellishment was a short-hand means of indicating that the company officially enjoyed the patronage of the royal household.

In the meantime, I'm including a small image of one of six marks illustrated in an 1879 advertisement by Thomas Turner & Co., another Sheffield firm. The relevancy, of course, being that 1879 was during the reign of Queen Victoria.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


img

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#9

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thank you very, very much, Peter and Don. Based on what you both have said, it seems the W. Butcher iron may be the better representative of an older British example. Funny thing about these Butcher irons--I've got several sets of plough plane irons, but none are as heavy at the business end as these Butchers. Out of 6 or 7 ploughs, British and American, I haven't yet seen a plough plane/wedge combination that comes close to a fit. They're very studly blades.

Wiley

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns

#10

Re: Dates for Cox & Luckman arns--One more please

Peter Evans

>Wiley, you are right, the irons (I have a box full, roughly 150) are not the same across makers. I do have a nice S BOOTH & Co plough with 8 Ibbotson irons that came from the same tool box and fit well. Judging from the tool box, late 19th century. The problem is finding a plough with its original blades. I have another with mixed makers that also fit; the irons are either the same maker as the plane or stamped with the initials of a previous owner, so were probalby always with the plane.

Cheers Peter