Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

Posts

Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#1

Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

steve mackay

>Got this one back from bead-blasting and am polishing the machined surfaces. The "leading edges" are pretty nicked and beat-up. No chunks missing though. Before I screw up the seating / mateing edges I thought I might take a stone and even them up a bit. Orrrrrrrrrr . . . am I buying myself trouble latter on when I re-assemble and put it into use ? Peobably rookie question but better safe than honked off. Thanks much for any guidance !


img

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#2

Obsession

David Miller from Iowa

>We all seem to obsess over stuff like this. My take is that one needs to look at the overall picture - start with the wood you are using and what you intend to do, then evaluate your technique and your ability to get an edge on the cutter, then see if your plane is getting you there or not.

Given that one has a sharp cutter and decent wood (the latter cannot be over estimated) this frog is fine. Spend your time on the cutter and your technique.

When you want to make the jump to getting a glass finish on curly maple or other "difficult" wood, you may need to upgrade your equipment - the subtleties of your frog in this case are irrelevant.

Use your plane as is until you are sure that it, not you, is the limiting factor and you will know by then specifically what you need next.

Regards, David

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#3

Re: Obsession

Bob Demers on vacation

>Wholeheartily agree with David!! Whats important here is that the frog mate solidly with the plane bed and support the blade, period!

Dont sweat the small stuff, and enjoy your plane, tweak it as you go to maximise its performance as your level of experience with its performance increase.

Bob, on vacation in ontario, looking forward to my visit to LVs Burlington store shorthly. whooooouh :-)

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#4

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

James Watriss

>Here's the deal, you're going about this all wrong.

How the mating surfaces LOOK is not anywhere near as important as how they MATE. Get a whiteboard marker, hit all the mating surfaces, put the frog in place, and rub it around. Any high spots will get rubbed off, and will need to be (very mildly) scraped down.

The thing is, there are high mating surfaces (that hit just below the yoke screw) and there are low mating surfaces (that hit just behind the mouth of the plane) If you hit one set, then what happens is that you'll be keeping them from contacting AT ALL, because they will be limited by the other mating surfaces. It's equivalent to filing down the end of a chair leg. You're going to get one that doesn't touch.

Charlesworth covers this in detail in his first book. He covers how to scrape down high spots (with pictures) and offers good pointers, like using powdered silicon carbide (commonly available in small quantities as shapton flattening compound) to finish grind all surfaces to each other, to maximize contact. I have an old stanley SW that works as well as my Lie Nielsens, and I got it that way by following his article to the letter. No joke. There's plenty of information out there, and I think the Charlesworth article is probably the best one I've seen when it comes to covering the mildly obsessive fundamentals.

I think the others are right that you're obsessing. But I also think that the plane pretty much demands an obsessive mindset if it's to work as well as it could.

First things first. Put the plane down. Don't touch it. Leave it alone.

Next things next. Do your homework.

When it comes to putting everything together, you really have to bear in mind a very important thing. It doesn't matter what you think the mating surfaces should look like. If they're not flat or perfect, or whatever... Once the plane is together, and working well, you'll never see them again. What's important is that you get maximum contact area. A stone is the wrong way to go about that. If you take too much down, you'll get no contact. Reference flat is not relevant. As long as the two contacting surfaces have enough area that's actually contacting, you'll have a highly functional plane. They can be convex to concave, grooved, or just ugly... as long as everything locks up right,

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#5

Sigh...

James Watriss

>OK, just took a look at the picture again. I think I was talking about the wrong side of the frog...

IMO, the side of the frog that you're showing in your picture (the blade supportin side) needs one thing... to be evenly flat, across the whole thing. Get a piece of float glass or a reference plate and some 150 or 180 wet-dry. Flatten the whole face of the frog. Don't take it all the way down to mirror shine, that's not really necessary. A little texture will allow you to adjust the blade more easily than if you have 100% oontact with the blade. And all you really need is for it to be flat, so it supports the blade evenly along the length and width of the contact area.

The very front edges aren't going to affect much, since the next thing the blade will touch (or more likely, not touch, if you have the mouth tightened up) will be the sole, on its way out of the plane. But I think the advice I gave about the underside is still valid. Don't take any mating surfaces away that are already there. Keep what you have. Once the plane is together, you're not going to see it again anyway.

If you're worried about blade support, I think you'll get much more support from one of those heavy duty Hock cap irons than you will from removing parts of your frog. That's been my experience, anyway.

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#6

THATS IT ! ! ! . . .

steve mackay

>exactly where I was going ! Now its all even and pretty. Might as well do it now. Just for fun I also "spotted" the mateing surfaces with grease pencil. But didn't see enough wrong to push my luck goofing with it. Interesting process though. I've seen it done with dies and molds (tooling) but never done it "at home".

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#7

Re: THATS IT ! ! ! . . .

James Watriss

>Awesome. :)

I'm not sure what kind of plane it is (looks war vintage to me) but once everything is in place, and ready to roll, the only other thing I can think of that will really help, is premium blade steel, and a hefty cap iron.

Just make sure you get the right thickness of blade steel... if it's too thick, there's a lot of backlash. Doesn't really hurt performance if everything is tight, but it's more fun if everything feels tight and ready to rick and roll.

I've had a lot of good luck with Hock, both HC and A2. And their cap irons are tip top. (L-N makes good cap irons, too.)

BUT, I've been playing with my gramercy D2 blade lately, and it's not too shabby neither...

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#8

I've splurged on . . .

steve mackay

>one Hock for my "workhorse" #5 1/4 and I really DO notice the difference. Hows the Gramercy price / performance -wise to the Hock ?

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#9

Re: I've splurged on . . .

Victor Parisian

>A 5-1/4 - nice. That's one of my favorite planes. Could be that mine is tuned very nicely. Hadn't even thought of a Hock blade for mine. Lately I've been building Cris Swartz' "Roubo" bench and using the # 8 a lot for jointing yellow pine.

Good luck with your plane.

Victor in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#10

Re: I've splurged on . . .

James Watriss

>Well, the Gramercy isn't made any more, but they do carry Ray Iles D2 plane irons. 1 3/4" runs around $44. (currently out of stock) Hock Cap irons are $24-ish, and the irons are $33.

Not exactly cheap. But if the rest of the plane is in tip top shape, there's very little those irons won't do.

As for me... I do have a 5 1/4, but I use my 3c much more often... it's pretty much my favorite plane. For some Reason, Stanley stamped it "imperfect." Damned if I know why. Fettled and tuned, with a premium iron, I really can't tell much difference between that and a L-N.

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#11

Re: I've splurged on . . .

ThomD

>It's another one of those things where:

A) the majority of people won't move it;

B) it takes longer to adjust than it would take to make three adapted planes out of wood.

C) anything called a frog isn't even pretty enough to fall in love with for old iron type reasons. You could be playing with a metal shaper for goodness sakes!! Even an hand operated one.

Re: Plane frog seating / tolerance . . .

#12

Re: I should have mentioned D)

ThomD

>you will get it just the way you want it when:

i) The roof leak and it gets turned into a solid block of rust;

ii) The sewer backs up...

iii) A workman comes to take out an old oil tank and uses you plane as a plate under his jack, or a a hammer for his cold chisel (probably one of your Ouchiis.

ask me how I know.