Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Meditations on 18thC lathes

Posts

Meditations on 18thC lathes

#1

Meditations on 18thC lathes

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Hey everyone, it has been awhile I posted. I recently returned from my exile to Australia and I am setting up shop again. As I am convalescing again (long story) I am having a good time reading.

I am now serious about building a lathe and I have studied different incarnations of 18thC lathes. I would like to start a discussion on this subject if you don't mind.

Joseph Moxon made a good case for the wheel lathe in 1683 by commenting the continuous motion of the wheel as far superior to the pole. Even Da Vinci drew a treadle lathe (1483) and of course John Jacob Holtzapffel in 1881 commented the advantages of momentum, equal revolutions, etc.

Now, I have looked into Roubo's volumes on Ebonists who were highly specialized woodworkers in marquetry, inlays, veneers, turning and all sorts of smaller works in 18thC France. An ebonist shop would have a spring pole lathe. However, the design here is quite different than the spring poles I have seen from Saint Roy and in medieval fairs. These spring poles don't look like they have a lot of power but I don't know really. Roubo's lathe itself is very familiar in design. It is strong and heavy like we should expect. I wish I could post the plate. The pole is a different matter. Roubo described all "Menuiserie" shops (boutiques) as having 12 feet ceilings because the stock's ordinary length when it enters the shop had ordinarily 12 feet. The spring pole had between 7 and 8 feet long by 2 and half inches in diameter. (The French inch

is 1.066" and the French foot is actually 12.44). The pole is fixed to a short and stout frame itself fixed solidly to the ceiling. The pole is perpendicular to the work.

Now, this in the 1760s and 1770s in France. This lathe must have had a lot of power designed this way and I am wondering if it's worth a try. I have a 9 foot ceiling in the basement but I fear I would knock myself out with a pole this long. I am concerned about authenticity and I am wondering about wheels and poles. A ceiling mounted pole makes sense to me so far.

On another note, in one of Roy's book there is a plate of a lathe with a bow instead of a pole. The plate is signed by Roubo but is not in his five volumes. Sadly, Saint Roy does not give the reference of where this plate is coming from. Roy explains that Hulot, a neighbor of Roubo, explained that with a low ceiling, the pole could be dangerous so a bow was used instead. I believe Roy is refering to the book by Hulot P�re, 1775, L'art du tourneur m�canicien, "The art of the mechanick turner". In the classical French language of the 18th C, M�canique referred to the arts requiring work of the hands. This book is still available but at 117 Euros, I think I will pass.

It looks like a lot of work to build something like this anyway. I am undecided and I fear this is beyond my skills. My biggest concern and what is staying my hands is that a beginner Menuisier in the 18thC would learn on an existing lathe and not be required to build his own. However, this is the sad fate of the modern traditional beginner Menuisier.

Sorry if this post was almost too academic. Anyone could offer thoughts on the subject?

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#2

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Welcome back from Oz! I hope your convalescence goes quickly and completely, and that you can be back in the shop making shavings soon.

If you're going to fasten a spring pole to your ceiling joists, I recommend that the framework to which the pole is fastened span two or more ceiling joists, and that you block between the joists where the framework fastens with (preferably dry) 2x stock - unless you live in a timber-framed house, and maybe even then. The lumber in stick-built houses is a lot lighter than traditional timber frames, and not intended to take the sort of twisting moment you're proposing to apply. You want to avoid turning your ceiling joists (floor joists of the floor above, of course) on their sides, and heavy blocking over several joists, with the frame spanning two or more, ought to absorb the force (though I'm no engineer). If in doubt, overdo it.

Somewhere, I saw an early 20th-century design for a spring pole lathe that used a truck tire inner tube as a spring, installed so it stretched - kind of like a rubber coil spring. I have no idea whether the big highway rigs still use inner tubes, but this might be a way, however inauthentic, to provide the tension while you experiment with the lathe layout itself. Or a big coil spring, if you can find one of the right pull.

Mind, I'm not recommending that as a permanent arrangement ("and that up there is a reproduction of the inner tube from a late 18th century tumbril - Marie Antoinette is said to have commented on how much more comfortable the pneumatic-tired tumbrils were, as they wheeled her toward the guillotine") - just for experimental purposes.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#3

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

ThomD

>As far as the spring arrangement is concerned a more recent appearance on Underhill's show was reserved for a nifty design that uses two sticks under the ways. One, I think, is continuous and bends upward secured from both ends, and the other is secured at only one end though it is twined to the first by a sliding fitting that allows flexibility and range of motion to be adjusted. A string leads to a crosspiece above the lathe that reciprocates, and the overall intention is to have a lot less stuff moving above the lathe.

I make bows and it isn't easy, it's a whole other set of skills. Anyone can do it of course. Normally a good bow out of wood can't be left strung, and I imagine, without experience, that a design that is drawn only to the extent that a spool is spun on a string might require a little draw weight. There are fiberglass kids, and camp bows and there are other easy to assemble options in wood and other materials. I just wouldn't assume it is a complete nothing to sort out unless you have good instrutions. A typical un-bent bow would probably require 8 inches of height at a minimum. And it seems to be mounted where your head would normally go.

I would like to build just about any lathe type. But for turning, a real motorized lathe is best. I just picked up two DC variable speed motors for 25 each with controlers, that would be a whole lot more useful, and possibly even cheaper (particularly at US prices).

Next I would probably try out the Star lathe, updated recently in one of the wood mags, I think by someone replacing their pole lathe. After that I would do a wheel driven lathe. Don't worry about the wheel, they work better if made other than a wooden spoked style. MDF (yuck) being outstanding, and a premium option on some spinning wheels.

I would probably only use a pole lathe for the fun factor, or to actually work in the woods somewhere.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#4

Pole lathe

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I built a pole lathe similar to Roubo's illustration in 1981. I used a 13 foot pole which tapered in diameter from about 2 1/4 to 1 3/4. Although I had used a flywheel treadle and an electric lathe previously, it took me only a day or so before I was doing finer work with the pole lathe. The ceiling does not have to be high, but you need joists or rafters or some place to wedge the pole (some have the pole in loft above. If you have a beam in the basement that supports joists, you can have the pole rest on the beam between rafters and have the end hit a board secured between two rafters. It does not need to be tied down- it just sits there.

I tried Roy's portable lathe last year; it is just a toy. You are right in thinking that the pole and lathe have to be more robust.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#5

Pole lathe power

Adam Cherubini

>The power of a pole lathe doesn't come from the pole- it comes from the friction between the workpiece and the cord and your own foot. In fact, you could say that a stout pole only reduces power, as your foot must over come it.

I think when making a pole lathe, the pole is the least important component. The string seems to be the most troublesome part.

And don't believe Warren. It's not hard to use a spring pole lathe, but it's not similar to continuous turning. If you push too hard when roughing, for example, you will wear your centers oval and have a terrible time. And you can get catches on the back stroke. Certainly your tools must be better quality and sharper and your technique finer as well.

Adam

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Moses Yoder

>The only advantage of the pole lathe over a wheel lathe is that the pole lathe is easier and less expensive to make. I guess that is two advantages. I think the question is whether the lathe will be used a lot, or just for playing with. If you plan on using it a lot I would suggest building a wheel powered lathe and engineering it to the N'th degree. I have seen some wheel powered lathes that looked pretty but really weren't very functional. But for occasional turning I would build a simple pole lathe and have fun with it.

The strength of the pole would determine how well the string grips the work. A heavier pole would mean more force applied to the string thus a better grip on the work. You would need to find the right combination of type of string and strength of pole. A string that has good gripping properties would mean that the pole would not have to be as heavy, requiring less work to turn. Another option would be to use some type of rubber wheel to wrap the string around with a standard lathe chuck attached to the rubber wheel and the work mounted between centers the same as an electric lathe. All of this talk on pole lathes makes me want to build one. I always thought I would build a wheel powered lathe but a simpler pole lathe might be something I would actually accomplish in this lifetime.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#7

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Thank you everyone for your insights.

I was sure the reason for a long and strong pole was that it would provide more tension and grip the work much better than the small pole lathes I have seen in St-Roy's books.

However, Adam, you did turn on your modified electric lathe powered with your foot and it seemed to work very well so I tend to agree with you.

I also think that Moxon and Holtzapffel's case for the wheel is hard to ignore. The spring pole is more accessible though. This is not going to be easy. I will need to make a decision for my turning needs. I don't want to go with an electric lathe as I am growing more and more confident in my shop using my old tools and I am serious about experimenting 250 years old work.

For those of you who built one, any advice on how to get started and what to be mindful of? I have all of Saint-Roy's books but if you will excuse my ignorance, I have not found them very useful. They are great and I loved reading them but I am not going to build a lathe pole out of the very few information given in there. I have tried to make a wooden tap using Roy's instructions... It was a failure almost immediately. Then again, my skills are limited as a beginner Menuisier.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#8

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>When you plane wood on a workbench, the bench contributes no power at all. But if the bench is too light, it severely limits the amount of power you can use. The pole on a lathe contributes no power, but its firmness is what you are working against so like a sturdy bench it is important. In practice, we adjust the tension to suit the stuff to be turned.

When Peter Follansbee turned on stage at Williamsburg he had a heavy pole and the joiners at Williamsburg made a heavy framework to anchor the pole. Peter was enough concerned enough about it that he brought a backup system in case the stuff Williamsburg constructed was insufficient. I have done demonstrations in enough compromising situations to know of the inefficiency of not enough tension and firmness. I don't think you will find someone with a good amount of experience with a pole and a bungee cord who prefers the bungee.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#9

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Michael Recchione

>Can't you de-couple the drive component from the pole stiffness? Adam is right when he says the stiffness of the pole works against you. To deliver the most power to the cutting stroke, you'd want the least possible pole force working against you. But, in a traditional springpole lathe, the pole has to oppose the force of the pedal in order to draw the string taught around the shaft (where the "shaft" may be the workpiece itself) so it doesn't slip. But what about if the string were affixed to the shaft, then wrapped around it a few times? Then you wouldn't care about the pole pulling the string taught - the string couldn't slip no matter how weak the return force was. You could even think of it as two strings - one going up to the pole, and the other down to the treadle. Then you'd be able to get away with using a return mechanism that is just strong enough to return the work and lift the treadle.

Just a thought.

- Mike in Nutley, who is just putting the finishing touches on his new shop space, after almost a year an a half of having no shop. Man, is my "to do" list ever long!

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#10

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Kevin Adams

>Bjenk--

There are various good sources for building and using pole lathes out there. You might check this site for starters:

http://www.bodgers.org.uk/

In addition, Mike Abbott has a couple of books out there both showing the construction of a pole lathe. If you're interested, his site is:

http://www.living-wood.co.uk/

Quite a few folks that use the pole lathe indoors (like me) use a simple bungee cord for the drive rather than a pole. The best recommendation I got from someone before building my lathe was to just keep it simple!

Good luck.

Kevin

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#11

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Dave Bozell

>I built a flywheel lathe several years ago that St. Roy wrote about in American Woodworking in October, 2000. I made it a little taller and a little wider, and also mounted the flywheel on the right instead of the left. (I'm apparently "right-footed" as well as "right-handed".) I found it easier to use while seated on a drafting stool, rather than standing. It has been a wonderful lathe to learn on, and a good lathe to take out for demonstrations. The immediate feedback to the power source (my right leg) has minimized damage to whatever I was working on, and I haven't thrown a lathe tool across the room yet.

While this lathe may not be historically accurate, it was easy enough to build and quite functional. I have already used it to build Windsor chairs, numerous tables, and a turned post bed.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#12

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Rick Schuman

>I have a spring pole lathe out in my back yard which I have been using for about 2 years. The lathe requires an area about 25 feet long and about 8 feet wide, certainly not a compact design. I also have an electric, but I have no place to set it up what with the need for power and shelter and all.

Recently, I was part of a wood seminar where I demonstrated my pole lath, followed by a fellow with a flywheel lathe and a another fellow with items he had produced on his Oneway at home.

In about twenty minutes I talked about how the lathe worked, showed the audience some books, my maul and fro and how thfy were used, and had a finished chair leg to pass around.

The fly-wheel lathe which was based on a design from Roy Underhill's 2nd book (handsome but but too low to the ground unless you are 4 feet tall) never really got going, too many moving parts that did not move well together. I think part of the flywheel mechanism unscrewed from the treadle crank just about the time some serious wood cutting was going to happen. Most, if not all, the turned examples associated with this demonstration were done on an electric.

The Oneway items (pens, magnifying glasses, and letter openers)were nice, but the lathe was too big to be brought to the site.

Anyway, if its not raining or snowing hard, i really enjoy standing at the edge of the woods and fighting off mosquitos and/or frost bite to make turned wood stuff. I am also developing attachments for a saw and a horizontal drill/bowl and chalice lathe/stool seat lather. I think I'll call it POLESMITH.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#13

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Thanks Rick. I am growing more confident to attempt in building one.

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#14

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Rick Schuman

>Check this out

http://forwoodnesssake.blogspot.com/

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#15

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Rick, I'm impressed!

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#16

I'd like to see a picture your lathe

David Miller from Iowa

>

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#17

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

James Watriss

>I read over everyone's advice, and all of this sounds very cool.

One thing that comes to mind, and I can't remember where I read this, or heard it...

Keeping it simple seems to be the order of the day, not just because it's easier, but because of the historical precedent. From what I remember (and again, I can't remember where this comes from) many of the old lathes were built on site in the woods, because the bodgers would be turning the wood as it came off of the tree. Because the integrity of the chairs was in part due to the strength of the joint produced when the green legs shrank around the dried rungs, the fresher the wood was when it was turned, the better. So the poles weren't always attached to rafters... because there weren't always rafters to secure to.

Maybe they tied to small trees instead... the pole doesn't NEED to be vertically above the lathe. As long as the lathe is secured properly to the ground, it's possible to have the tension move out in any direction that is tangent to the axis of rotation... which is any direction at all. If you had a loft in your garage, I imagine you could drill a hole in the floor, drop the rope through, and tie it to a rock of whatever size seemed adequate to your needs. I think vertically (up or down) is probably preferable, so the rope wouldn't fly back and lash the turner if it broke, and horizontal forces might make steadying the lathe more challenging. But it does make the idea of tying to a tree more plausible.

I think, if it were me, I'd do a little more research... and maybe build one that was either outside, or could be moved outside. What could be better than going out, chopping wood, and turning it on the spot, on a nice autumn afternoon?

Re: Meditations on 18thC lathes

#18

Why TIE it to a tree? Why not a tree itself?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you picked the right species and the right size, you might be able to use a sapling or a branch directly.