Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

trunk dovetail layout question

Posts

trunk dovetail layout question

#1

trunk dovetail layout question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Because I don't have occasion to do it often, and it needs to be done right the first time, I lay out the dovetail pattern to scale on paper to develop spacing, size and other decisions. I did this for the trunk as I would a drawer, starting with a half pin on the board with tails. I think it looks strange.

I have several dozen trunk pictures in books and none clear enough to see this detail. I can see that trunks have tails on the front of the trunk, but I can't tell if the pattern starts with a half pin or a half tail.

So, what is the convention for a trunk? There likely will be no molding to cover either the top or bottom of the front board so this detail will show.

Re: trunk dovetail layout question

#2

Re: trunk dovetail layout question

ThomD

>I don't know the convention either. I would be inclined to lay out a "2/3rd" pin which is the pin minus the surplus bevel since it doesn't lock into anything on the outbound side. Seems like the kind of thing that would have had some kind of metal straping on it.

I did a quick scan through the Toolbox Book. Not trunks, The traditional ones use 2/3rd tails. They also have skirts so there is a second set of joints holding the corners together. The exploded diagram shows both sets of joints terminating in a half tail. There are various kinds of metal straps also indicated.

Re: trunk dovetail layout question

#3

Re: trunk dovetail layout question

James Watriss

>Most of the trunks I see will have SOMETHING supporting the edges and corners. If there's no skirt, no extra molding, then there are brass corners, or something similar.

I think for durability's sake, I agree that a 2/3 pin sounds a little beefier. But one way or another, traveling trunks were reinforced in some kinda way, since they got bounced around a fair amount.

Re: trunk dovetail layout question

#4

stay at home trunk

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This is a toy chest trunk. Its the domed thing I have been fretting over for weeks. I finally found two pictures of trunks showing dovetails. The one on the left page, the front board ended at the top with a tail and the one on the right page ended with a pin.

So I consulted my resident expert period furniture maker and his trunks ended with a pin (like a drawer construction) but he pulled out his favored reference book and the trunk described ended with a tail.

I liked the looks of the continuum provided by the tail option.

In most trunks the lid lip hides the top pin or tail so it matters not. This trunk has no lip, so this option does alter the appearance.