We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I've spent a lot of time lately hand cutting tenons and hand chopping mortises. Actually, I'm getting better at it. It just goes to show that brute effort and dumb persistence will ultimately pay off.
My nested end table project will ultimately have more than 60 mortise and tenon joints. More than enough to practice up. This a useful skill to develop and a good basic step toward becoming an accomplished traditional woodworker.
>I found the same thing, namely predrilling a hole make things go faster with better control. However, I make the hole near the far end and I make the hole a bit smaller than the mortise, but to the exact depth. By making the drill hole a bit smaller it does not have to be accurately centered and therefore can be located and drilled quickly. The only purpose of the hole is to provide initial clearance and establish depth.
What advantage do you find for making the drill hole in the middle of the mortise?
>I like your idea of making the hole a little smaller. I like to make it in the middle to insure that by the time I get to each end, I have regularized the chopping channel. I find that the first chops at the hole are a little unstable and I like to have a smooth approach to each end. Also, I like to leave a last small amount to pare off the end, in case I have to lever out any chips off the bottom, and crush the ends a little, so I don't want to start too close to either end. I'm sure these reasons are a matter of personal preference and either method will work.
>Predrilling is an extra step that, in my opinion, is not really necessary. (Note, I am a self taught woodworker with no serious credentials.)
Here is how I believe a mortising chisel works. Place a chisel about a quarter of an inch from the end of a board with the back of the chisel facing the end of the board, and hit it firmly. The bevel of the chisel will drive the chisel toward the end of the board and blow out a piece of wood. In this demonstration, the end of the board provides the necessary clearance, and the bevel of the chisel provides the lateral force necessay to create the chip.
To chop a mortise using this principle, I start by making a couple of vee cuts at the far end of the mortise to provide the initial clearance....about a quarter of an inch deep depending on the wood being used. Then I move the chisel back about a fourth of an inch or so and with the back of the chisel toward the clearance I chop straight down, the bevel provided the lateral force to blow out a chip. I generally hit with just enough force to create a chip about a quarter inch deep. I keep repeating to reach the near end of the mortise. Now, I might go back to where I started and make a new vee cut and continue, or I might just reverse the chisel, make a new vee cut at the near end of the mortise and work back to the far end. Depending on the wood, I need about four of five passes to chop a mortise one inch deep. The vee cuts provide adaquate clearance for the chisel to do its work, and saves the extra step of predrilling.
Much is written about chopping mortises, but usually without adequate detail. I would also be interested in specifics of other approaches.
>I start in the middle of the future mortise with the bevel facing one end or the other and chop, reversing direction as I go, learned this from Jeff Gorman's old site.
Below is a drawing he made to illustrate the process.
>That's one of the right ways to do it, and the way I do it when the proportions allow. Holes can make it go faster, particularly if the mortice is over deep because the drill is about the most effective way we have for sucking stuff out of wood. The technique shown when done on overdeep mortices then gets augmented with bottoming chisels.
When using holes I normally drill them in the center, but it isn't so critical that I need a drill press for it. Mortising all benefits from having the chisel equally supported with wood so that the cutting action is ballanced out.
On really big motices the kind that get drilled and then the sides get pared, I don't find it maters that much if the holes are centered, except that the work will be more uniform (the result probably won't change), in other words one won't have 1/8" of wood in one place and 3/8" in another, get the pressure right on one side and it is right all around. If usually doesn't take less time to do something "right" than to do it wrong. Ho hard is it to get the point of a drill in the right place, vs. having a chip flking off the side of the mortise that well supports the chisel in one place and it too thick or too thin in another. I don't see that as being faster.
>If you pre-drill the mortise (the so-called "carriage makers" method) then use a plain bench chisel to clear the remaining waste by paring the cheeks. A mortise chisel is spectacularly unsuited for clearing the waste in a pre-drilled mortise. It is unparalleled, however, in chopping a mortise from a dead start (i.e. no pre-drilling).
>I find it difficult, if not impossible, to chop out the waste left by drilling. The mortice chisel (mine are OBM) is guided by the mortice, per se, and as it cuts a groove it creates its own jig. Without the sides to guide it, it struggles to stay on track.
I will chop towards a drilled hole. That is different from chopping through a drilled hole.
>If you had a 1/4" mortise and chisel, and drilled some .002" holes in there, you wouldn't have any problem, nor would there be any advantage. At the same time, if you drill holes so large they nearly touch the cheeks, you won't have good control over the mortise chisel action, and you are reduced to paring the sides. So it's a ballance thing. Drill wise, one can often get away with removing "too much" material, and then find the chisel doesn't work in normal mortise mode.
The rule should probably be guided by the process. In timber framing where the square is used as a gage, and it is certainly easy to see what is going on, paring the cheeks works well. On more delicate mortises the chisel's shaping action can be useful and one may have to give up a little excavasion to keep the chisel in play, or drop the holes altogether. On the other hand if you can accurately and quickly pare even your small mortises who is to quarrel with that?
>One of the other factors when hand chopping mortises is the mortise chisel's cross section.
There seems to be two camps when it comes to the cross section - rectangular and trapezoidal. The trapezoidal cross section mortising chisels don't bind if you chop a little too deep. BUT - they permit the sides of the mortise to wander if you're not VERY careful. With a rectangular cross section mortising chisel, if you start straight the chisel keeps the sides straight. And, if the corners are nice and square the SIDES of the bevel also cut wood, producing smoother sides on the mortise. The disadvantage of the rectangular cross section is side friction. Chop too deep and getting the chisel out can require some rocking and tugging. If you tug too hard - and your face is in the escape path, it is possible to nearly knock yourself out when the top of the handle hits your chin. Don't ask me how I know this ; ).
Steve Knight, of Knight Toolworks, use to sell Jim Wilson's mortising chisels. Jim's mortising chisels are rectangular in cross section and the sides of the bevel is SHARP.
Jim stopped making these chisels a while back but I've heard he's making them again. If you're doing a lot of handcut mortises might be worth looking into a Jim Wilson mortising chisel.