Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

"Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

Posts

"Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#1

"Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Having never done a task as this, I have been experimenting to see what works. Fortunately, by pre-shaping the staves I only need to remove 1/32 of material, at most. This oak does not yield its fibers easily.

The plane I made for another task and it worked to clip any high spots. The gain on this oak was not reliable for planing, but I avoided unfixable tears. The red devil scraper is a wonderful tool. I learned how quick it levels oak while helping an "old timer" install floors. By skewing it I could attack glue globs even though it is straight and the piece is curved. The Sandvick scraper was too thick to accommodate the curve, the Lee Valley too thin. But the LN was "just right". My thumbs are sore. I am using leather gloves now to lessen burning thumbs. The curved bottom sander was Will Newtons's idea. The scraper is faster so I have not used the sander yet.

I will finish sand with the sander. I don't like dealing with scraped surfaces for finishing.


img

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#2

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

MikeW

>Hi Bill,

Been reading the coopered lid posts with interest. I also have done some coopered lids. The shaped sanding block is a near must. For planing, I use one of a couple pattern maker's planes with radiused bottoms, depending on the scale of the lid.

I also have lightly radiused some scrapers so I don't need to bend them much in order to "match" the radius of the work. I use scrapers about 5" long, so they don't bend as easily anyway.

The small one:


And the junior jack-sized one. A craftsman-made plane:


Though I have not bothered with pre-shaping the face curves of the staves in the past to lessen the amount to plane, I may well try it on the next one (whenever I get to do some woodwork again).

Thanks again for the posts!

Take care, Mike

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#3

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

James Watriss

>grind a radius into a harder scraper on a grinder?

if you can make one plane, you can make another... make a radiused scraping plane...

Or, make a radiused sanding block, with a tote, and just sand the F%*# out of it.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#4

thanks for the suggestions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I like the idea of the radius scraper plane. It would make my thumbs less painful from scraping with the card scraper.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#5

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

I made a travisher cabinet scraper with a 90 degree blade, radius end and 45 degree bevel. Held with a couple of wedges, it works great. I will snap a picture and post it tomorrow, but it is a simple tool. It is a cabinet scraper with a radiused bottom, I use it after my travisher spokeshave.

Stephen

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#6

Re: thanks for the suggestions

James Watriss

>I agree, but it does become a question of returns... how much time spent on the plane, how much time saved on the work... it may be a lot easier to make a radiused sanding block... even if it is a lot less sexy.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#7

next time

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I got it finished with card scraper (man are my wrists sore) and sanding block. If I do another I will make a serious radiused scraper like a floor scraper and have at it. If it was a floor and I was using a floor scraper, it would have been but a few minute job to level it. I can peel oak off a floor with a floor scraper about as fast as one can plane and there is no risk of tearing up a piece of grain- not a remote possibility with this quartered material.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#8

I recall a year or two ago

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>someone here picked up a coffin smoother on deBay and made it into a radius plane by planing the sole, doing a little repair on the mouth, and grinding the iron to fit. Would save some steps.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#9

Not to shill for Rob Lee or anything *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>But he may have solved your problem. Lee Valley sells a chairmaker's scraper for which you can buy a convex blade, see link.

Not that spending more money is always the answer...


Might this work?

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#10

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing 

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>


img

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#11

Would this work?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have in mind a plan to build a few coopered doors. My plan has been to use a Record #020 across the grain, rather than attempting to smooth a curve by planing with the grain.



I am quite confident that the Record will create a fair curve, and that the surface will respond to smoothing with a curved cabinet scraper that is now run with the grain.

This strategy could be used on both sides. One advantage is that it avoids having to deal with pockets of reversing grain, something that a woodie with a widish mouth would not do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#12

too late... !

paul womack

>This applies to all laminated items (e.g. table tops, bench tops)

When selecting and arranging your pieces, whilst checking colour, grain pattern and matching, which face to have up or down, don't forgot.

Make sure (if possible) all the pieces have the grain running the same way. Otherwise planing gets REALLY interesting.

If a single piece has reversals, just tale a majority vote.

I end up marking chalk arrows on both faces of each piece :-)

It's easy to lose track when making all the other (important) selection and arranegment decisions.

BugBear

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#13

Re: smoothing plane...

paul womack

>It would be very difficult to make a curve bottomed smoothing plane with a tight mouth...

... but fairly easy to make it high pitch to compensate (w.r.t. tearout).

BugBear

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#15

actually not

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I thought of the grain thing but I wanted to book match the staves which guarantees grain reversals.

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#16

The bottom line

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If one uses the technique described by Will Neptune for easily removing the bulk of the "excess" wood before assembly then a scraper ( like Stephen showed or similar) and sanding block will quickly smooth the surface. Planing is unnecessary. I was amazed how fair the curve became. I can barely feel any irregularities.

Now to attach it to the lid frame......

Re: "Weapons" for curved lid smoothing

#17

Re: design decision...fair enough

paul womack

>