Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Axes

Posts

Axes

#1

Axes

Bernard Markunas

>I know the older Kelly Perfect axes have a favorable reputation but does that hold for the ones currently being made? Are the new ones worth buying or is it a situation much like Stanley planes and Disston saws, where something 75 years old is likely to be preferable to something fresh out of the factory? Finding a good old axe would have been easy when I lived in Pennsylvania but that is not the case now that I'm a flatlander here in Illinois. Thanks for your guidance.

Re: Axes

#2

Fit & Finish

David Miller from Iowa

>My take is that the modern axes are serviceable, just the way a modern Disston saw is serviceable. Works fine for general use and the price is right. Having a sharp edge makes all the difference regardless of vintage.

If you were swinging one all day and sharpening it every night then the vintage ones might have an advantage. I really don't chop down trees with an axe anymore - mostly just chop roots when pulling stumps and a cheapo axe is preferable for that.

David

Re: Axes

#3

Re: Axes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't know the answer to your question but I have a general comment. I use an ax a lot for trail clearing and limbing when I am cutting fire wood. I use a mid sized double bitted ax. I can't accurately swing a big one. I find that an ax is like a work shoe ( or baseball bat if you play). Some fit and feel like they are part of me and others are awkward. I would suggest that you try whatever you intend to buy to see if it feels good. I bought a high dollar Sweedish ax by mail and hate it.

I suspect anything made outside Asia will be good steel. A friend bought an Asian ax and a piece broke out of the blade when he was chopping with it.

Re: Axes

#4

My favorite ax...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have replace the head twice and the handle a half a dozen times.

Find a vintage ax, preferrably with a laminated steel bit and poll. American patterns are great for chopping and some hewing, European poll axes are not quite as easy to use.

I use a small hatchet with a round tapered eye and a steel bit in wrought iron, no poll. It looks like a tomahawk, I use if for firewood and riving. It can also be used for rough hewing.

I have a large fantail (dovetail shape) ax, that is new made from Spain that seems to be holding up. It has a great shape and thin blade. I have it mounted on a short handle because I like it for rough shaping wood.

I sold a nice old Cooper's Bench Ax a number of years ago, I regrete selling it now. A friend has a nicer one that he just uses for decoration that was given to him by a good friend, so he won't sell it. I even asked him how good that friend was? I want that ax.

Stephen