Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Question about case construction

Posts

Question about case construction

#1

Question about case construction

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi All,

This is concerning dovetailed construction of a case, such as a chest of drawers, or a slant-front desk.

My question is of the 'duhhh' variety: Why is it that the pins are carried by the sides, and the tails by the top and bottom?

Wiley

Re: Question about case construction

#2

Re: Question about case construction

Dave Mount

>I would think, but don't know as a fact, that it would be because gravity is aiding the joint vertically, so it makes more sense to have the direction susceptible to pulling apart in the orientation where gravity helps keep it together. The mechanical part of the joint is holding the sides in.

Best,

Dave

Re: Question about case construction

#3

Re: Question about case construction

Alex Yeilding

>The forces trying to pull the cabinet apart will be horizontal forces on the sides due to drawers being racked, etc. The tails on the top and bottom "trap" the pins on the sides, and keep them from moving horizontally.

Except for a mover lifting the cabinet by the top board, there is no "normal" action that would pull the top up from the sides or the sides up from the bottom.

Re: Question about case construction

#4

Hard and fast rule?

wilbur

>How hard and fast is the pins on the side/tails on top and bottom rule? I've seen articles and pictures of furniture where it was the reverse.

Re: Question about case construction

#5

Re: Question about case construction

"RJ" Whelan

>Wiley .... the way it was explained to me (by grandpa) is:

The overall amount of wood in the tailboard (at the joint) is far greater than the amount of wood in the pin board; thus the top will be stronger should a heavy weight be placed upon it (such as in a case on case construct).

I don't know if this is the true, historic reason, but the explanation always made sense to me.

rj

Re: Question about case construction

#6

Gravity

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Question about case construction

#7

Re: Hard and fast rule?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wilbur,

I think it is more of a tradition rather than a hard fast rule. On old desks and bureaus (chest of drawers) the dovetails hardly ever showed, the tails were on the bottoms, the pins showed on the sides were frequently covered with moldings. The top pieces are usually smaller and dovetailed half blind so they don't show or if they are through covered with applied moldings. The tops were screwed, nailed or pegged on to the carcase.

Perhaps in more modern furniture this changed and I have no doubt it can be documented the other direction. Most of the force with the exception of moving and furniture is not generally designed to be moved (although it should be), it was racking of pushing and pulling the drawers that causes the greatest stress.

Stephen

Re: Question about case construction

#8

agree

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been studying case construction every chance I get to a museum. What I see is that cases assembled with dovetailed thingies the drawer ride on (what are they called?) have stayed together. When the thingies are M&T into the sides there is usually a gap in the joint. This observation is consistent with the Alex hypothesis that the forces in use tend to try to pull the side from the horizontal things keeping the case together. Hence, tail and pin orientation of top is best arranged to keep the sides from separating from the top just like the things holding the drawers up.

Re: Question about case construction

#9

Yes

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>I find that convincing too, especially in light of your excellent analogy with the drawer blades.

Wiley

Re: Question about case construction

#10

Re: Question about case construction

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Thank you RJ, and Grandpa. That upper case sure could bear down hard on the lower case top. And as Stephen said, gravity is working for the pins if they're on the sides, but working against them if they're in the middle top or bottom. Those points, and the racking argument seem convincing.

Wiley

Re: Question about case construction

#11

Re: Question about case construction

Adam Cherubini

>I think there are two reasons:

1) For proper function of the drawers and to keep the moldings from popping off, you want flat sides. Putting the tails on the sides does a better job of resisting/reacting cupping of the sides. If the top and bottom cup a little, there's rarely much harm done.

2) A lot of times, guys hid their carcase joints with half blinds. Especially on slant top desks that often lack an upper molding.

That's what I think, anyway.

Adam

Re: Question about case construction

#12

Re: Hard and fast rule?

ThomD

>It's common on modern furniture for the exposed dovetails to be on the sides. Particularly wall hung cabinets where the main loads may be in the vertical orientation. Depends how the cabinet is hung though. When I do it the top cabinet panel would be sitting on the sides, and the bottom panel would be hanging. The French cleat would probably spread the top panel if it could. So maybe the idea would be a pins on top and dovetails on the bottom. I've done some ugly things, but I'm not going there.

I did build a freestanding shelf one time with five fixed shelves and the top panel dovetailed. TO be a good boy I put the dovetail on the top and the pin on the sides, but really the piece would have been better if the tails were visible. Rather than the pins.

Where any of that is concerned, bad things would be happening if the joint where loose enough for the locking to mater. Glue is still the main thing at least during the lifetime of the builder and owner.

As far a weight resting on the piece from above, I would prefer to see that carried by the sides in which case it isn't likely to mater which way the joint is cut (though I agree with the reasons given).

Frank Lloyd Wright used to structure his houses so the walls took the loads as is done with 2x4 homes, except his structure was to make the wall from vertically placed 1" boards. The roof, or second story loads were carried by a curtain of 1" boards! His walls were clad with more 1" boards arrange horizontally with gaps between them. This created that distinctive horizontal look, and added shear strength, insulation, and kept the "posts" in column. But the vertical loads were carried by the 1" boards. If you grosse up the 1" boards they provide more area of support than already overstructure 2x4 walls. I think case sides should be ample!!

Re: Question about case construction

#13

Thanks and a clarification

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Thanks for all the examples and counter-examples, Thom!

And your point is well taken that 4/4 solid sides are ample and will not themselves fail.

For clarification, I understood RJ Whelan (and grandpa, to get the attribution right) to be emphasizing the case-on-case situation, where the upper case would be inset and resting on the lower case top. I'm going by the design details given for example, in Jeffrey Greene's book on 18th century construction methods. Following Greene's constructions (as I interpret the drawings), if the lower case top is carrying the pins, then much of the upper case load is trying to shear those pins. And down at the bottom, if the bottom is carrying the pins, then the combined weight of the upper chest and the lower chest is trying to shear those pins where they enter the case sides. Of course, there could be workarounds, but it's a very straightforward and efficient use of materials when done the classic way.

Wiley

Re: Question about case construction

#14

Error correction

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Never mind that about the bottom--that's wrong on my part. The lower case top is the one RJ was speaking about.

Wiley