Re: Hard and fast rule?
ThomD
>It's common on modern furniture for the exposed dovetails to be on the sides. Particularly wall hung cabinets where the main loads may be in the vertical orientation. Depends how the cabinet is hung though. When I do it the top cabinet panel would be sitting on the sides, and the bottom panel would be hanging. The French cleat would probably spread the top panel if it could. So maybe the idea would be a pins on top and dovetails on the bottom. I've done some ugly things, but I'm not going there.
I did build a freestanding shelf one time with five fixed shelves and the top panel dovetailed. TO be a good boy I put the dovetail on the top and the pin on the sides, but really the piece would have been better if the tails were visible. Rather than the pins.
Where any of that is concerned, bad things would be happening if the joint where loose enough for the locking to mater. Glue is still the main thing at least during the lifetime of the builder and owner.
As far a weight resting on the piece from above, I would prefer to see that carried by the sides in which case it isn't likely to mater which way the joint is cut (though I agree with the reasons given).
Frank Lloyd Wright used to structure his houses so the walls took the loads as is done with 2x4 homes, except his structure was to make the wall from vertically placed 1" boards. The roof, or second story loads were carried by a curtain of 1" boards! His walls were clad with more 1" boards arrange horizontally with gaps between them. This created that distinctive horizontal look, and added shear strength, insulation, and kept the "posts" in column. But the vertical loads were carried by the 1" boards. If you grosse up the 1" boards they provide more area of support than already overstructure 2x4 walls. I think case sides should be ample!!