Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

#71 or #71 1/2 ?

Posts

#71 or #71 1/2 ?

#1

#71 or #71 1/2 ?

steve mackay

>Been eyeballing these little devils on the Bay but there seem to be a few different shapes (models, types ?). B&G tells me the parts to look for but is there any advantage or desirability to one "type" or another ? They look like another tool that, if I had one around, would probably get a fair amount of use. Opinions ?

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#2

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

Tom MacGregor

>I have a 71 open throat with the "shoe" and all three blades, but pre-fence. I mostly use it to even the depth of grooves & dados with the V cutter, and could probably get by with a simple closed-throat 71-1/2. The V cutters are still available from Stanley.

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#3

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ? *LINK*

Bob Demers

>If you actually intend to use a router plane, I would reccommend instead that you get the LN or LV router plane, They are way better than the originals.

I personally used a Sargent No 62 and a Stanley 271. If you want to get an older Stanley, check out the type studies on it.

Bob


Stanley router plane study

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#4

I have one of each

Neal in San Jose

>And they are very fun and useful planes. I slightly prefer the closed throat simply because it has more support in front of the blade. I've found the foot thingey fiddly, but can make it work. I use them for cleaning out dados, cleaning out sliding dovetails, making tenons, even screwed it to a wide board and used it to clean out the recessed part of a pie crust table top once (that did take a while!). Use a chisel, saw, whatever, to establish sides, etc, and waste as much as you can, then use the 71/71 1/2 to accurately finish up. Great fun and very accurate. I also have a couple in the 271 size range, but don't use them very much. Maybe if I did inlay or stringing.....

I haven't had the opportunity to try one of the LV or LN current editions, but they look like they address most, if not all of the shortcomings. Setting the depth of cut takes a while to figure out, and parts availability can be problematic with the Stanleys, but I haven't been annoyed enough to "upgrade". Try it, you'll like it!

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#5

Like Neal, I have both*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I haven't had much time in the shop, so use is limited, but I agree that the 71-1/2 is probably the better buy. I think it's significant both that Stanley kept making them after introducing the 71 and that Lee Valley, which thinks about functionality and design a lot, modeled its router plane on the 71-1/2 more so than the 71.

Lee Valley's catalog says its cutters fit the Stanley router planes, by the way.

*well, I have three - but I didn't pay much for them, really, so having more than one is OK. At least that's usually my excuse.

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#6

The best combination plane? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Steve

There is nothing wrong with the vintage Stanley router planes. I have owned both the #71 (closed-throat) and the #71 1/2 (open-throat). Of the two I prefer the closed throat as it just feels tauter and less finicky.

I have both the modern descendents on my workbench at this time, the LV (closed-throat), which is my own, and the LN (open-throat), which is on loan from Lie-Nielsen. They are both definite upgrades on the vintage models, especially in the area of depth setting and adjustments.

Some would vote for the #45 or #55 as a favourite combination plane. My vote goes to the router plane. I find it quite incredible that so little is actually written about these planes. I am preparing an article and part of this has been to see what else has been written, and I just cannot find magazine articles that are dedicated to the use of the router plane. I did a sort-of article in this vein when reviewing the LV router plane (link below), but there is precious little on the whole. If anyone has references, please, please let me know!

Why would I consider the router plane to be one of the more valuable planes in the woodshop? Simple, what else aids in creating sliding dovetails, stopped and through dados, can cut through- but especially stopped drawer grooves, butterfly inserts, inlay, rebates. Anything else?

I simply cannot fathom a workshop - power or hand - without a router plane.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Veritas Router Plane

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#7

Older router planes

Bob Demers

>First off, stay away from current Stanley 71 production, the vintages ones are way better.

I you intent to go the 'antique' road, there are others to consider besides the Stanley 71 and 71 1/2. There was a myriad of clones from various manufacturers, EG.: Ohio, Keen Kutter (made by Ohio) Millers Falls, Winchester, Marples, Record etc. Some of these can be had for cheaper than the original Stanley and are just as good.

While most are virtual copy of the Stanley design, the Sargent's 61 and 62 are note quite. The used a different cutter adjustement system, making their cutters and replacements, pretty hard to find.

My own 62 has its lonely cutter almost worn off by repeated ham fisted grinding, sigh...

If anyone has one to spare, ill be most grateful

Pic is not from mine, darn if i can reduced it in size enough to post it!

Bob, who should get his butt off to work


img

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#8

OT: Photo resize

Tom MacGregor

>Google "jpeg resampler" for a freeware program to resize images to whatever resolution you want. I've found it very easy to use.

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#9

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

Paul in NJ

>Steve,

I have the open throat model (71-1/2?) because that is the first one I came across at the flea market ($10). I put on a 3/8 thick wooden sub-base so now it has a closed throat. In my shop, I only use it for leveling to a precise depth for hardware, sliding dovetails, and such after roughing out with a chisel. I always use it freehand without a fence. In my mind, it is a specialized tool. While you can use it to do other operations like dadoes, rabbets, and tennons, other tools are really more effective. The LN and LV versions are nice but I would never use the fence or the extra precision. I would use the savings toward a different tool. The Stanley will do all that is required for me.

Paul Dzioba

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#10

Like Neal and Bill, I have both too...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Also the 271. You really need 1 of each Steve. 8^)

But, start out with a 71 1/2 for the reason others have stated.

Re: #71 or #71 1/2 ?

#11

Thanks all . . .

steve mackay

>I'll have to start paying attention to the auctions.