Re: the importance of other attributes
Bob Demers
>Quote the most important properties for us are toughness, hardness and abrasion resistance. Unquote
Well in my oversimplification, what I called 'hardness (edge retention)' was pretty well a combination of these.
Yes, I know, not quite the same to all of us, and hardness must be balanced against brittleness yadi yada, but to me my simple equation is a balance (more like compromise) between Hardness (brittleness, toughness, abrasion resistance etc) and ease of sharpening and rust resistance.
For example high carbon steel can be easily sharpen to a sharp edge, can be harden decently, but rust like hell in a hurry
Add Chromiun vanadium, and you increase rust resistance, but it does not hold as sharp an edge.
O2 steel, hold an edge much longer than regular carbon steel but is a PITA to sharpen by hand
etc..That's what I meant in my simplified 3 compromise properties, and one of the three always seems to be mutually exclusive. You can have 2 of the 3 but at the compromise of the third.
'Our' favorite kitchen knife is a 1930 NOS Sabatier 'L'enfer' knife from LV. Sharpen easily and take an incredible edge (I got many cuts to proved it :-D but its a real pain to keep clean, it discolor and rust in a flash. Still, we have managed to keep it white, not dark steel. Truly love that knife. Our regular stainless kitchen knife do not suffer from that discolorisation (oxidation, rust, whatever)but cannot hold such a fine edge.
Similarly, some of my favorite tools started as rusty and pitted steel, which I managed to salvaged. No idea how hard the edge is, but all I know is that they take and keep a fine edge. For the record, being a trained woodcarver, I stop and strop my edge often when I work, on a piece of leather with LV green stuff. Great stuff!
And of the many secrets to getting and keeping an edge sharp longer...
Bob