Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Posts

Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#1

Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hello,

I would like to be able to do basic examination of blade steel. For example, to carry out the standard ASTM test for grain size in steels, by polishing and etching the steel (with Nital), and counting the grains at 100X magnification. Would also like to observe whether carbides are present.

Question: I'm trying to figure out what equipment I will need, starting with the microscope. Are there any special microscope features which are important in carrying out the grain size test? Obviously, you need 100X magnification. But for example, is glare off the polished sample a problem, and what needs to be done about that? Also, what dilution of the etchant Nital would be a good place to start?

Any of your thoughts and experiences would be very useful, as I am starting with no hands-on experience.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#2

Scientific Testing.

Todd Hughes

>Sorry can't answear your question....but for some reason it did make me think of the time I was at a show selling knives and axes I made and a guy comes up and asked me "whats the Rockwell hardness of this knife". I took my hat off hit myself upside of the head with the side of the blade and told him "somwhere between really hard and f***ing hard".....My friends that were there Still bust on me about it and will ask me to test thier knives for them.....Todd

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#3

What you need... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...is a metallurical compound microscope, inverted objectives are nice, and with both darkfield/brightfield capabilities, horizontal and vertical polarization, yellow/green/blue brightfield rotatable filter head and an iris. You'll need a and XY mechanical stage and a trinocular camera port is a must. Above all, however -- really good optics that won't tire the eyes and a nice eyepiece reticle. The cheapest, by far, that fills all these requirements is the Omano OMM300T at just under two thousand dollars. From there you can go with the Meiji at four to five thousand, then Olympus on up to Zeiss (don't even think about it).

Anyway, if you do decide to go this route, I can highly recommend Microsope.com and Omano. Mike's very helpful and knowledgeable and made my Omano purchase as easy as can be. I own Olympus (the Omano is a dead-on clone* -- Omano does lenses for Olympus and other top makers). Rather than buy a second zoom-boom Olympus I saved a ton and bought an Omano. It's very hard to tell the difference optically. Yes, the Olympus is heavier and sturdier, built to take abuse, but yours won't subjected to the beating that students can give these instruments.

*Mine is the OM99 body: http://www.microscope.com/omano-lindsay-engravers-stereo-microscope-p-244.html


OMM300T

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#4

Another great resource is LabX *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>LabX is an online marketplace for pre-owned scientific equipment. They list lots of microscopes and microscopy accessories, including metallurgicals, sometimes at bargain prices.

I bought my Bausch & Lomb SK articulated stand which retailed for 2,700 USD for 150 USD with a stereo zoom pod thrown in for free. I also bought the superb 15x ultra widefield eyepieces for 75 dollars; one tenth their usual price.

Yeah, give LabX a try.


Microscopes on LabX

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#5

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Wiley,

[You said]

I would like to be able to do basic examination of blade steel. For example, to carry out the standard ASTM test for grain size in steels, by polishing and etching the steel (with Nital), and counting the grains at 100X magnification. Would also like to observe whether carbides are present.

Would you mind explaining what your end goal is and why?

Are you striving for absolute sharpness?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#6

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi Marv,

I would like to know what my sharpening looks like at high magnification. It would be interesting (and maybe a little humbling, who knows?). However, that is not what this request is about.

I've become curious about the properties of high-carbon steel. Especially the plain vanilla varieties--like vintage blade steel, O1, W1, and Japanese white and blue paper steel. Depending on heat treatment and forging methods, some examples of these steels exhibit an unusual combination of high hardness, high edge retention, and high durability in use. Different examples also sharpen differently.

There is one past study I am aware of, which sought to relate edge retention to metallurgical properties like Rc hardness, grain size, carbide presence and distribution*. I would like to attempt a similar (simple) metallurgical examination of specific blades, to see under the scope the end result of different kinds of forging and heat treatment, and to see if there is a relationship between what you can see under the scope versus how the steels perform, how they dull, and how they sharpen. Maybe I just end up where Todd Hughes said, hitting the blade against my punkin head. But right now, I want to see.

Bottom line: It's curiosity. There's no end point, just another vision quest.

I need help on the technical aspects of doing this stuff, because I have zero metallurgical training.

Wiley

*The study is, 'Testing Wood Chisels', by Bill Stankus, Fine Woodworking magazine, March 1985, Issue 51, pp. 44-48. Also found in the Fine Woodworking paperback entitled 'Bench Tools', pp. 80-84.

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#7

Re: Scientific Testing.

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Good story, Todd. That's probably where I'll end up too.

My favorite story of yours dates from Badger Pond--it was the one where you acquired the lady's piano for its ivory (with your ax hidden behind your back), and the piano hollered like a mastodon when you went after the ivory in the parking lot. Someone still has that post on a Badger Pond CD somewhere.

Wiley

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#8

Re: Another great resource is LabX

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>David,

Thanks so much. You're an endless fountain of knowledge. Can you splain (as Ricky Ricardo used to say) what it is about a metallurgical scope that makes it different and better for examining steel?

Wiley

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#9

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

I think I know the spark for your interest in this issue, and I think that maybe I might be to blame for this.

Any way, I won't be of much help technically, but I've been trying to gather information about carbon steels in tools as well, and found two things that you might be interested in, if you haven't found them already.

The first is a posting from knifefourms.com, with information on carbon steels used in Japanese knives:

http://www.knifeforums.com/forums/showtopic.php?tid/815917/pid/

http://www.knifeforums.com/forums/printpost.php?tid/815917/

The second is information from an industrial supplier of steel, especially the first two links on this page:

http://www.crucibleservice.com/eselector/general/generaltitle.html

Hope this helps!

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#10

Okay, Lucy... I 'splen it to you... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Metallurgical microscopes can pass light through the objective, illuminate the specimen directly then pass the reflected light back through the objective, through the primary ocular paths to the eyepieces, and of course, the eyes. This is known as epi-illumination.

Why inverted? Take a look at the link below and you'll see that it can handle large specimens. In uprights, there's not much space between the sample and the objective turret. But because you're looking upward through the aperture with epi-illumination in the inverted design, there's complete alignment of the light source with the optical viewing path and much easier specimen handling (positioning, etc., with the XY controls. Add the trinocular path and digital camera and you'll get large crisp images to disk or monitor with reticle overlay. Not so hard to count crystals if you go that route.

Also, because most modern metallographs combine darkfield-brightfield illumination, fluorescence, polarizing & color filters and even phase contrast capabilities, you'll see the surface terrain in such relief that features become starkly recognizable. It's like flying through otherwordly mountain ranges. And it's addictive -- it's own slippery slope.

The most important thing you can do is visit the solid state labs at a university or testing lab, find someone there with a little time to show you around and answer questions. Take a peek through one of these 'scopes and you'll catch on pretty quickly.

Steel? I don't know steel. Well, not that much. I'm a Bronze Age kind o' guy where metallography's concerned (and you should see what they're doing in archeometallurgy these days), so I can't help you much on Iron Age pursuits, and I'm a low-power stereo junkie (7X-45X) with a fiberoptic illuminator jones that's just as bad.

I've got my big B&L with the 60+ lbs. SK multi-axis boom stand in the shop (great for sharpening), one at the jeweler's bench and the other where I do micro-machining, and so on. Lately, I've been using the jeweler's scope for soldering tiny electronic parts for the minimalist 'gainclone' stereo amplifier I'm building. It just doesn't get better'n this.


Inverted Olympus GX-Series

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#11

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Wiley,

I can't really add to David's comments on the microscopes. They're thorough.

I'd start out with a 5% picral or nital etch.

The intermediate stage is the polishing stage. For this, you'll need a few 1/2" plate glass offcuts, a collection of wet and dry going down to 2000#, some lapping cloths, one for each grade of diamond dust (yes, you need to go down to 0.25 micron for effective microscopy.) Oh - and an endless supply of patience as you need to count the number of strokes on each piece of wet and dry until the scratches from the previous stage disappear, then perform 50% of that number in extra polishing strokes to get rid of the work hardening/damage induced by that grit of the paper. Proceed to the next grit.

60#/80#/120#/170-180#/240#/360#/480#/800#/1000#/1500#/2000#/5 (?)micron diamond/3 micron diamond/2micron/1.5 micron/1 micron/0.5micron/0.25micron.

There are shortcuts that I've seen used in the field (taking carbon replicas of field machinery metallurgy,) but the last samples that I prepared were in the early 1990's.

Did I mention endless patience?

Cheers,

Andrew

Struers is a good supplier of metallurgical paraphernalia and know-how. A google search should bring up a local supplier.

The other variable that you'll need to consider in your study is pearlite lamellae spacing - influenced by cooling rate.

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#12

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks Wiley,

An interesting endeavour to say the least. Will you be keeping us informed as you progress?

It would be interesting to see what happens with different brands of chisels and plane irons with a measured amount of actual use right after you have examined your best method of sharpening. I know you are exploring way beyond these basics, but, perhaps this could be a bonus from your analysis.

Back in the early 70,s I was working with the casting of various epoxies in the field of high voltage. Certain epoxies have a very high degree of insulating qualities. Adhesion to metal and other materials was a major concern. To examine the level of adhesion we were getting we used an electron microscope, magnifying 1000x or more. It was a long time ago and I have forgotten most of the new language I had to learn in order to understand even a small amount of what I was in to.

It's a whole different world when you venture down into the valleys and crevices of a polished surface. Very fansinating. I can easily understand the possible addiction aspects of such a study that you are involved in.

Good luck and don't get lost in all those nooks and crannies.

Marv

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#13

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Bob Demers

>Wiley wrote

Quote I've become curious about the properties of high-carbon steel. Especially the plain vanilla varieties--like vintage blade steel, O1, W1, and Japanese white and blue paper steel. Depending on heat treatment and forging methods, some examples of these steels exhibit an unusual combination of high hardness, high edge retention, and high durability in use. Different examples also sharpen differently. Unquote

I have long wondered about that myself. In my tools coll..er arsenal, I have a wide range of antique steel blades, even old (age unknown)Japanese tools, new fangled O2, cryo etc and never cease to be amazed by the various properties of all these steels. There seems to be three related properties: Hardness (edge retention), ease of sharpening and rust resistance. But only two of the three seems to be acheivable together in any given steel.

With today's metalurgical and scientific know how, one would think that it would be easy to make an excellent blade consistantly....

Well apparently not. Go figure! Just how on earth, did the 19th century people managed to produced excellent blades?? Mind you, even among respected brands, EG Disston, Buck's and etc, there were variation in quality, Buck's especialy seems to have been a crap shot for a while.

These opinions of mine are purely based on my own experiences sharpening and cutting wood with them, no real scientific method or knowledge..

Bob, tool magnet and sharpener of rusty implement

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#14

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Hiya Bob, any snow left up there? :-)

You forgot one important property, toughness. A hard steel is not of much use if it is brittle. Cheaper Japanese blades and chisels are often hard but the edge chips out fairly easily (which is one factor that has put off many users). Quality Japanese tools are both hard and tough (and expensive!).

DC

Started the air conditioning for the first time

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#15

the importance of other attributes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>An edge can fail because it chips, bends or crumbles, or wears away. Hence, the most important properties for us are toughness, hardness and abrasion resistance. The edge of a tough steel will not chip. The edge of a hard steel will not bend or crumble in use. An abrasion resistant steel will stay sharp longer.

Any given steel, together with its heat treat history, is a compromise of these attributes. Different people and manufacturers have different notions as to the best compromise and the best compromise depends on the details of how the edge will be used. It is, " easy to make an excellent blade consistently.... " as evidenced by the many quality blades available to us- Hock, LV, LN to name a few. I don't see any evidence that better edged woodworking tools were made in days of old.

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#16

Re: the importance of other attributes

Bob Demers

>Quote the most important properties for us are toughness, hardness and abrasion resistance. Unquote

Well in my oversimplification, what I called 'hardness (edge retention)' was pretty well a combination of these.

Yes, I know, not quite the same to all of us, and hardness must be balanced against brittleness yadi yada, but to me my simple equation is a balance (more like compromise) between Hardness (brittleness, toughness, abrasion resistance etc) and ease of sharpening and rust resistance.

For example high carbon steel can be easily sharpen to a sharp edge, can be harden decently, but rust like hell in a hurry

Add Chromiun vanadium, and you increase rust resistance, but it does not hold as sharp an edge.

O2 steel, hold an edge much longer than regular carbon steel but is a PITA to sharpen by hand

etc..That's what I meant in my simplified 3 compromise properties, and one of the three always seems to be mutually exclusive. You can have 2 of the 3 but at the compromise of the third.

'Our' favorite kitchen knife is a 1930 NOS Sabatier 'L'enfer' knife from LV. Sharpen easily and take an incredible edge (I got many cuts to proved it :-D but its a real pain to keep clean, it discolor and rust in a flash. Still, we have managed to keep it white, not dark steel. Truly love that knife. Our regular stainless kitchen knife do not suffer from that discolorisation (oxidation, rust, whatever)but cannot hold such a fine edge.

Similarly, some of my favorite tools started as rusty and pitted steel, which I managed to salvaged. No idea how hard the edge is, but all I know is that they take and keep a fine edge. For the record, being a trained woodcarver, I stop and strop my edge often when I work, on a piece of leather with LV green stuff. Great stuff!

And of the many secrets to getting and keeping an edge sharp longer...

Bob

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#17

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Bob Demers

>Hi Denis

No snow here...except if you go thru the park. There was a snow storm as recently as last week in it, really wrought havoc on people with summer tires :-)

I still got my winter tires on the car, i got an appointment to replace them with new summer ones next friday...Just in time to replace them again by winter ones soon :-)

Bob, waging hand to hand combat with dandelions on his lawn

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#18

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Thank you, Andrew! That is very helpful indeed. I had wondered as to exactly what the verb 'polish' means in preparing metal samples, because of course as you polish through the grits, you're abrading the very lattice structure you plan to look at. Well, you have explained what's involved. Bummer, dude. That's a lot of work per sample.

Yeah, you did mention patience!

Wiley

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#19

I don't know....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I still got thing for those Shrunken Heads...

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#20

Good 'splening to me...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Ummmm...Ahhhh...Ohhhh...Yea...I get it

I think...

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#21

Re: I don't know....

timleo

>shooting elephants in heaven cracks me up every time I see Todd's posts

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#22

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Tom Bier

>It's been over 20 years since I did any metallography, but I think I can recommend a couple things.

"Engineer to Win" by Carroll Smith was written for racecar builders so they could biold stuff that wouldn't fall apart. The first several chapters cover most of what I learned in my materials science minor - it is the best materials primer I've seen.

Counting grains while staring through the microscope will not be fun - take a digital picture, zoom it to a convenient scale, and then count grains.

The best illumination sources used to be the dimmable halogen source with a fiber optic pipe to a ring light. I've been impressed by the cheap LED ring lights with just a dimmer switch; there are nicer ones with side lighting that are still very affordable.

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#23

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Tom and all,

I want to thank you and (once again) all the other folks who lent their advice and cautions to my request for metallurgical help. As it turns out, an extraordinarily well-qualified metallurgist is providing some specific and highly detailed assistance right now, and it looks like this project may actually get off the ground.

Perhaps all of your suggestions will be repaid with some interesting data, in time, in terms of photomicrographs. This will take a while, but it looks like a 'go' as of right now. Course, when the beautiful planning vision gives way to the dirty reality of actually doing something, we'll know more. I'll provide updates.

Wiley

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#24

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

Larry Williams

>If you want that Stones iron for testing, let me know.

Re: Calling metallurgists, bladesmiths.....

#25

Noob asks a question....

Edward in Vancouver

>If it wasn't for woodworking, I wouldn't be at all concerned about sharpening or knowing of metal in general. My regular trade is that of a Chef and while I can get a decent edge on my knives and keep it ( for the past 25 years), I never really made a big deal out of it. While I'm not the kind of guy to get all deep ragged breathing and sweaty palms looking over Japanese Knife magazines and spouting off magical metal formulaes, I would like to educate myself a bit about metals.

My first source of info is always the library. Can anyone suggest me a few books made for an absolute beginer regarding metals?