English Stanley Bench Plane Question
Tom MacGregor
>Does anyone know how long Stanley bench planes have been made in England, and whether or not they match the flow chart types?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
English Stanley Bench Plane Question
Tom MacGregor
>Does anyone know how long Stanley bench planes have been made in England, and whether or not they match the flow chart types?
Re: English Stanley Bench Plane Question *LINK*
Bob Demers
>Stanley bench planes and al, have been made in the UK for quite a while, but generally as far as the type studies are concerned, it would only applies to the US made ones.
By the mid 70s, more and more Stanley tools production begin shifting to the UK. Here in Canada, Stanley tools were made at Roxton Pond, Qc until about 1984 when Stanley stopped production and closed the plant. By the early 80s practically all Stanley tools were manufactured outside N.A, mostly in the UK, why? I do not know!
The bench plane type study stop at Type 20 1962-67, there were a few more years of plane production in the US by then, but for the most part as far as collectors are concerned, there are too recent, and as far as users are concerned...the quality went down low enough to pass.
I used to think that it was silly to snob the UK production, but if you have put your hands on the same tool of earlier vintage made in US or Canada and more recent made in UK, you will quickly notice a difference in casting quality and finishing.
And for the record (pun intended) similar findings hold true when comparing early vintage Record tools (such as Stay Set) with the recent crop.
Bob, anxiously awaiting tomorrow hockey game :-D
Stanley tools in Roxton Pond Qc
Re: English Stanley Bench Plane Question
paul womack
>I used to think that it was silly to snob the UK production,
Well, it sort-of is. It's not the UK manufacture that's the problem. It's the priorities set by Stanley at the time; low price production was the goal.
It just correlates all-too-well with country of origin :-(
BugBear
Could not agree more
Bob Demers
>Paul
You are most certainly correct. My biggest beef with the recent Stanley UK production is the rough castings, they are using coarser sand grains, or a different metal?
The irony in all this is that the UK has a long and proud history of manufacturing high quality hand tools. Thankfully, some current production is keeping and raising the bar higher. One as only to think of Ashley Isle, Clifton and etc, to be reminded of that long and proud tradition.
I'de be curious to know, what on earth was Stanley thinking by shifting manufacturing to the UK and setting lower production cost objectives. Seems counter productive to me
Bob, her majesty loyal subject :-)
Re: Could not agree more
Tom MacGregor
>I had a chance a few years ago to talk to a guy that had been fairly high on the chain at Stanley, and asked him about the low quality planes. He told me their market research indicated that 90% of their bench planes were purchased as gifts and never used by the recipients; they would take a loss making a better plane because not enough people would pay the price.
The crowning touch was the brand new #5 size Stanley plane I saw at the hardware store last week labled on the box in nice big letters, "Block Plane". Just like ebay - the definition of a block plane is one that a)is made of a block of wood. b)is used on a block of wood. or c) was once in the same room as a block of wood.
Wich brings to mind . . .
steve mackay
>the other buzz word (besides the "P" word) on the bay. "SIGNED". By the maker ? By the last owner ? Since most tools are not "hand made" one at a time, who "signed" that Disston #8 or Stanley #4 ?
To be fair...
wilbur
>"The irony in all this is that the UK has a long and proud history of manufacturing high quality hand tools. Thankfully, some current production is keeping and raising the bar higher. One as only to think of Ashley Iles, Clifton and etc, to be reminded of that long and proud tradition."
Maybe that's why Stanley went the cheap route. Given the other UK based manufacturers, the high quality hand tool marketplace was already crowded, so they headed to the bottom end of the market.
I'm not saying that was the right or best thing to do, I just understand that mode of thinking.
Sprinkle these liberally throughout this post: :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@)
Horse goes in front of cart
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>My sense is that Stanley's production quality went down some years before most of the makers cited here (and others) started operations - though I believe Ashley Iles or the family thereof were in production for a long time. Clifton, though, if I recall correctly, was started by some Marples/Record workers who thought Record was lowballing the market and wanted to maintain the high quality of the old Record tools. And, of course, Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley started up after the major manufacturers stopped making high quality tools.
So, I suspect the quality makers were reacting to a hole in the market left by the loss of quality by the major makers, rather than the other way around. But we should be clear: it's a niche market nowadays. Just compare the number of posts here to the posts on the main board, for instance. When I occasionally post a power-tool-related question there, I tend to check back on the same schedule I use here - and find that I have to scroll way, way down to find responses - whereas here, a conversation may stay near the top of the thread list for a couple of days.
I've been intrigued to find that my carpenter son has a few hand tools that he uses regularly, but most burns electrons - when you have a contract to meet, it's hard not to do so; although he is intrigued by the hand tools, and experiments with them in his own shop. My other son is unlikely ever to do much with hand tools, because he sees tools much as I see refrigerators: something that should run well and not require any thought whatsoever.
I don't recall who 'twas - I want to say Isaac Asimov, but am not sure - who said that a technology does not become romantic until it is obsolete. Part of the frustration of watching what Stanley and others did with hand tools is realizing that they had decided they were selling obsolete tools and thus did not need to make them functional - merely romantic. A good many professional carpenters have written about seeking out old planes, even though they primarily burn electrons, for those occasions when a hand tool is the right technology.
Off topic: We're currently recovering from (and missing) a visit with my wife's niece Kathy, great-niece Shannon, and great-great-niece Cierra, the last of whom is 18 months old. A terrific week, catching up with the first two and meeting the last one (they live in Memphis, so we don't get to see them often) - I'm exhausted, but what fun!