Re: New Japanese Planes
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Hi Mark,
Arriving late, but here's a couple of thoughts. Let me pick up with what Pam said. Especially, get Harrelson's DVD. I would emphasize what Pam said about marking the sides of the blade. I've never seen a new Japanese dai/blade combination, where there was enough lateral movement provided by the daimaker. He leaves that to you. Usually, the blade is tight up against the side walls of the abutments (those two slots that hold the blade). In the event your blade is held tightly at the sides so that you have zero lateral adjust, it will take a 1/8" paring chisel, or else a 1/8" thickness plane float to pare back the abutment sidewalls just a bit. 3/16" is a little too fat, in my experience. Cut back no more than 1/32" on each side, and no further than half-way or two-thirds of the way down the abutments--do NOT cut all the way down to the bottom of the throat. Also, if you need to create this lateral play, do as Pam and Howard said and don't cut any material off the top (roof) of the channel. Leave the top of the channel as is, as you received it. The bottom of the channel may require some scraping to get the fit, but the pencil will tell you about that.
One other thing, and this is very typical of blade fitting....As a newcomer, you will probably fit the blade a little too tight. This is what most folks do initially, because intuitively you figure the worse thing is not to have the blade held tight enough. Here's a rule of thumb: If you are mushrooming the top of the blade, that is too tight--do some more spotting and scraping. By the way, note that the dai's bedding is kinda convex toward you--don't flatten it, it's supposed to be that way, to match the curvature of the blade. Trust your pencil marks. What happens if you overdo it, and make it too loose? You're still OK--you then glue a piece of all-cotton bond paper to the dai bed. Each thickness is about 4 thou.
IMPORTANT: Now, what if despite all your efforts, you get the blade in there a little overtight? Notice that there is not much wood below the blade, because the Japanese dai is typically bedded at a low angle, like around 40-42 degrees. What's gonna happen if the blade is tight? Well, the dai will deflect under the hammered-in blade, and a little bump will pop out on the sole, right behind the mouth of the plane. You can't see this bump, but it will wreak havoc with the plane operation. The plane will cut on first one side, then the other side, but rarely in the middle. All kinds of erratic behavior. You extend the blade, and it digs in; you retract the blade and it won't cut except at the edges. It'll make you crazy. The source of the problem is that the blade is too tight, but that is a subtle thing to understand if you're trying to pick up these skills by yourself. If you're getting erratic cutting behavior that you can't figure out, what you can try to get the plane working is to scrape off a couple or three thousandths, right behind the mouth opening. Do it with a scraper plane, going crosswise parallel to the mouth. Put the plane upside down in a vise, where the vise is grasping the blade (only), not the wooden sides of the dai. Just make a couple passes behind the blade opening, from side to side to create some relief behind the mouth. See if that helps things. It won't hurt. The thing to understand about a Japanese smoother is that there are two lines of contact--at the leading edge and at the front of the mouth. The rest of the sole is relieved by a couple of thousandths. So the last thing that touches the work as you make a planing pass is the blade.
This is just calling out typical stuff that goes wrong--it doesn't even begin to tell you everything to do. Get Harrelson's DVD.
Wiley