Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

Posts

Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#1

Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I guess my real question is, what determines the value of a saw of this kind? What should we use as guide lines and or criteria?

I realize it's a subjective question, but perhaps with thoughts from different perspectives we can all better evaluate something of this kind whether it be a saw or other famous old collectible tool.

About a year ago, I saw a Panther Head saw in much worse condition than this sell on eBay for nearly $800.

Recently one on eBay with a reserve got bid up to $1288 and didn't reach the reserve. That saw was/is in excellent condition, in fact I did the retore on it and I still have it in my possession. It's the same saw that Todd Hughes posted below that will end in less than an hour from now. The saw is owned by a friend of mine. I posted it the first time it was listed several weeks ago.

Marv


Panther Head saw on eBay

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#2

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

ThomD

>It's market forces. That can be anything from a newbie bidding war, to more reasonable projections of future value, or learned valuations.

I know nothing about the saw market, but it would be a big negative to me that the tip is missing. That would take me out period, and make me wonder about anyone bidding more than a 1/6 of "value". Unless George Washington snapped it off in a cherry tree.

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#3

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Just my 2 cents.....What's good about this saw is the wood. What's not so good is the blade tip and all the hardware has gone missing. It would be worth quite a bit as a donor saw to someone who already has a panther saw, with everything right but the wood. But you need two such people, to get the bidding off the ground. I suspect this seller may get offline inquiries during/after the auction, and may be able to negotiate something.

Wiley

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#4

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

Paul Kierstead

>Well, if someone is willing to pay $600, that means it is worth it, but I doubt it will sell. It is not about the condition, it is about the completeness; this is not a saw, it is a saw tote and part of a blade. The missing hardware, especially the medallion, pretty much kills it IMO. The tip of the blade takes the final icing off the cake.

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#5

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

Todd Hughes

>I think there is a pretty good chance that this $600 panther will sell. You have to understand its not so much what it is worth now in this condition but what it will be worth when "restored"

Really not to much needs to be done, regular saws by this maker are far from rare or vaualble so getting the correct medalion not much of a problim , neither would be triming the blade back...or maybe for that matter replacing the blade all together maybe with the blade from the medalion donar saw. If this was done it would be very hard to hide because if the handle was removed it would be apparent. Guess some super glue on the nuts would take care of that though.If blade trimmed back could be harder to tell.

...Imagine when this saw gets sold next time it will look nothing like it does now.

Seller could have done a better job presenting the saw...why no photo of the blade taken from the side so you can see what it looks like instead of that weird angled shots...Hard to tell if it is sharpened up or not.

Aint there only supposed to be somthing like 4 1/2 of these panther saws in the world ? [grin]...Todd

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#6

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

Todd Hughes

>"Recently one on eBay with a reserve got bid up to $1288 and didn't reach the reserve.....It's the same saw that Todd Hughes posted below that will end in less than an hour from now. The saw is owned by a friend of mine. I posted it the first time it was listed several weeks ago"

Im a slow head I guess but I sort of miss the ebay strategy of listing a saw with an opening bid of $2,500 that had previously only been bid up to $1,288 and then when it doesn't get a bid at $2,500 to relist it the following week with an opening bid of $3,500. Now that no one wanted it at $1,500, $2,500 or $3,500 is it going to be relisted at $4,500?

Maybe falls under if you don't put the bait in the water you don't catch no fish theory, eh? .....Todd

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#7

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Todd,

Perhaps the thinking is, not every potential buyer will be on eBay looking at the auction the first or second time it's listed. Just by chance, which is a lot of what eBay is about, someone with more money than they know what to do with will come along and think it's cheap at half the price. It's impossible to predetermine what everyone will do at any given time. I guess the seller thought it worth the listing fees to throw it out there one more time.

I have communicated with Margaret Woodrough, a direct descendant of James R. Woodrough, the guy who signed the patent on the Panther Head handle. She is interested in buying the saw if her next grandchild to be born in July is a boy. She has already bought another Panther Head for a grandson who is now 3 years old. Not sure at this point what she thinks it's worth to her but perhaps the present owner of the saw will find out in July.

I'm constantly amazed at what some people will buy and how much they are willing to pay.

Marv

Re: Is this saw on Ebay worth $600? *LINK*

#8

A $600 canvas...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The Panther stalking the farm, I can picture it now brown cow...