Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

Posts

A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#1

A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

wilbur

>I wish the subject title line was longer, because I was going to call this thread "Who needs a 400 lb workbench when you have a scrap piece of 1x4?", which I think is a funnier title, but it won't fit.

I've been spending this weekend trying to get a leg up on my Roubo bench project, much like the excellent one that Corey posted. The workbench I have been making do with is a Sears version of a Workmate, which does fine as a clamping device, but it moves all over the place when I'm trying to plane something. I was really beginning to appreciate a saying I heard once about how "you need a workbench to build a workbench."

But then I had an "Aha!" moment. Recently I came into possession of a board of poplar 3 1/4" thick, 8 3/4" wide, and 6 1/2 feet long. It was rough cut, with a lot of dirt and bird poop on it. I also had been reading Scott Landis' workbench book, and in the chapter on Japanese woodworking workshops, there is some discussion on trestle beam workbenches.

I planed the beam down so that the surface was level. Then I put it on some sawhorses, and put a board of 3/4" pine on the back side of it to serve as a place to hold tools.

Here's what it looks like:

Trestle beam workbench

Trestle beam workbench

So how can this set up be at all stable? Here's where the 1x4 comes in. I nailed the 1x4 scrap to one of the sawhorses, and set it up so that it butts up against the wall of my workshop. On the underside of the poplar beam I installed two screws so that the heads protruded above the surface by a little bit, and arranged the beam so that the screws rested against the cross beam of the sawhorse.

Trestle beam workbench

I installed another two screws so that the heads were above the top surface of the beam, and placed a thin scrap of cherry across them to make a planing stop.

Trestle beam workbench

With Japanese planes, which work on the pull stroke, everything locks into place under planing pressure. The plane pulls on the workpiece, which butts into the cherry planing stop, which butts up against the screws. The beam butts up against the sawhorse with the two screws on the underside, and the sawhorse runs into the wall thanks to the 1x4 scrap. Nothing, and I mean NOTHING moves.

Trestle beam workbench

I would imagine that a similar setup could be done for western planes, if you made a mirror image of this setup. If you're a lefty, you could use this setup as is.

Sawing can be done with Japanese saws, which cut on the pull stroke, because the pull stroke clamps the workpiece to the bench top, again locking everything in place.

Crosscutting:

Trestle beam workbench

Cutting dovetails (my 5 year old boy took this photo!):

Trestle beam workbench

By the way, if you ever wanted a good demonstration of the kind of surface that a Japanese plane can leave on wood, check out the light round thing on the side of the beam. That's the reflection of my saw where the handle meets the blade. There's no finish and no sanding here. I just planed down the roughness on the side of the beam with my Japanese plane, which isn't anything special. I bought it used on eBay.

Chiseling tasks work just fine. I generally try to direct chisel cuts so that I am pushing or chopping down into the bench anyway, and I can use the planing stop to brace the workpiece against. I can always resort to clamping the workpiece to the poplar beam if I have to.

I'm still going to make the Roubo, since I actually do use western planes from time to time, I can't see functioning without a vise, and I don't think that this setup is going to hold a face vise very easily. The ability to use holdfasts would also be nice, although I think I could drill some holdfast holes into the beam. The other workbench task that seems problematic with this setup is doing rough planing across the face of the board or on a diagonal for initial leveling with a jack plane or jointer plane, but at least I have my workbench to make a workbench now.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#2

very smart!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I like the way you used what was on hand to make a very stable and handy work surface! I'm really impressed with your ingenuity!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#3

Specially like the legs :-))

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Wilbur,

I always appreciate it when someone thinks outside the box.

Marv

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#4

very clever, Wilbur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have the permanently mounted version of that, I think - my benchtop rests on and is screwed to a cleat lagged to the studs, in addition to resting atop a plywood cubbyhole box. It's pretty solid.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#5

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb be

Raney

>very resourceful, Wilbur! I imagine this will also be a great 'test platform' for refining the design of your Ruobo... I'm very interested to see how you eventually configure it for your preference for eastern tools. Of course now that you have this, your motivation for working on the Ruobo may diminish quite a bit

Nice job!

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#6

Re: Old as the hills

ThomD

>I used to do that when I worked on my dad's bench. It was sorta English in basic concept, with a top of 3/4" ply. it walked all over our painted concrete floor. I use to clamp a 2x4 to brace it against the wall. I've used that trick many times since.

Another example is the japanese planing beam. it is long enough to just brace one end against the wall. Odate had a version that used a the beam siting on a stump at the wall end, and the front end was supported by a "horse" that was nailed up like a triangular picture frame with lots of overlap in the ends. I once had to plane up some sail battens which were longer than my existing bench, so I just turned a nice 2x6 on edge and had an instant bench, braced against the wall on one end and broken T-horse at the other. The japanese style hangs the workpiece from a nail sometimes, so it can be kept well up the beam and away from the wall.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#7

I know this wasn't particularly original

wilbur

>I've seen pictures of Toshio Odate's planing beam, both in Landis' workbench book and in his own book on Japanese woodworking tools. That's where I got this idea from. In fact, for a while I wondered if I could get away with a planing beam alone.

The main reason I posted this is it seems that when it comes to workbench stability, we immediately go to having as massive a bench as possible, so that the weight will hold it in place. I just thought it would be useful to show another way to go about making sure your workbench won't move. This setup is completely solid, even though it's made with suboptimal components for a workbench: poplar top, a pine board, and legs made with those instant sawhorses from the Borg where you buy a sheet metal dohickey that you insert 2x4s into and nail them in.

This technique isn't limited to Japanese planes, either. I tried using some western planes on this bench, although I had to use them left handed, and it still remains completely solid.

One thing is for sure: it beats the pants off of my Sears Workmate-style table.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#8

In defense of Workmates.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>I hate Workmates. They're such a cheap insubstantial wobbly POS.

But I also love 'em. Like for example, I have this one that stands off to the side in the backyard, kinda hidden. Just stays there. When the particle board top curled up and died from the rain, I replaced it with 3 redwood 2x6's--now they have many coats of oil from wet-sanding oil into a panel; shellac from many shellac adventures; glue from many glue adventures; numerous coats of rustoleum spray paint from spraying the iron legs and backsplat of a bench; and some bird droppings. It's ready for anything. The vise on this thing still kinda works--I say 'kinda works' because it works in the same wimpy way it always did, which is exactly good enough to hold something still to be painted, or small sticks to be crosscut--and no better.

Where ya gonna change out the string on your string trimmer? Or sharpen that tool that's got a mattock on one end and an ax on the other (what is that thing called, anyway?)? Or file the lawnmower blade? Or spray paint something so it doesn't matter where the paint goes? Or paint a gate, and not worry about stray drops falling? Workmate is the right height so all this stuff gets done without an aching back. You can kinda clamp with it, and on it, and to it.

One of the feet of mine has about rusted off, so it's like a three-legged dog, but then you know, three-legged dogs get around pretty good--they're not worried about it.

Anyway, I'm fixing to buy another one, and throw this one out, cause it's about done. After carefully removing and saving those silly bolt-with-conical-nut things they use to hold the top on. Those have got to be good for something.

Wiley

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#9

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb be

BobStrawn

>In some ways a scrap piece of 1X4 is better. It is less likely to get covered with junk so you can't even get at the table surface. ;)

Bob

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#10

Re: I know this wasn't particularly original

ThomD

>I think the response shows people appreciate your post. I'm just in training for a decade or two from now when I can fill the curmudgeonly role of pointing out how it was all known when I was a kid. Increasingly important, if no less anoying, now that the patent office is handing out patents for stuff that was invented when Jesus was in the boy scouts.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#11

You were a Boy Scout weren't you...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Nifty fix to solve your problem. Wouldn't work for me, it would go right through the sheetrock. :^(

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#12

Re: In defense of Workmates.....

John in Calgary

>A Pulaski? See the Lee Valley link below.

http://www.leevalley.com/garden/page.aspx?c=2&p=45651&cat=2,45794&ap=1

My dad had one that we used for trenching in the brush in the corner of our lot that dropped into the ravine next to our house.

John

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#13

Thank you!

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Yep, it's a Pulaski, except mine is a smaller model. They're really handy tools for digging stuff up.

Speaking of digging stuff up, one other favorite tool is a great big 6' or 7' iron pry bar I came across at Home Depot one day. About 1-1/2" in diameter. You can sharpen one end, and the other end is mushroomed for pushing on. Must weigh 15 or 20 lb. And it doesn't require any clearance in the hole for swinging like an ax or mattock--you can stab it straight down into a posthole digger size hole, sever a thick root, and horse out whatever is in the ground above. Doesn't take much digging to get it into action. I grind a new edge on it every once in a while--using the Workmate!

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#14

Re: I have one of those digging irons, too

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>They're really useful for a whole bunch of things, even in suburbia.

Re: A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

#15

Re: Thank you!

Paul M.

>Hi Wiley,

I've gotten a lot of use out of my digging bar. The dirt in my area is about 50% granite by volume (round river rocks about 6" across) glued together by a hardened clay substance that may indeed have trace amounts of dirt as well in it somewhere. Every small hole is quite a workout, even with a major tool like that one.

For the footing of the retaining wall I've been putting in, the digging bar was woefully inadequate. I now own a cheap jack-hammer that was needed to excavate this stuff for the trench. I envy people who have some real dirt in their yards!