Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Type 1; original?

Posts

Type 1; original?

#1

Type 1; original?

Philip Duffy

>When trying to help a neighbor a day or two back the question rose of what constitutes a "Type 1". A pricing book on old tools he had purchased had no explanation. Such a huge difference in price marked my attention as he had a whole box full of very unusual items, including boxwood rulers,etc. So, the question for you experts is; Is Type 1 the original issue year items, or does that designation stay with an item until it is changed by the manufacturer? For the life of me I could not figure out what constituted the difference between Type 1 and newer versions in the items he owns. Perhaps an experienced eye can see the difference in rulers, like they do in Bedrock planes, etc. Views appreciated. Philip

Re: Type 1; original?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Type 1; original?

Moses Yoder

>A "Type 1" of any tool would have to be documented somehow by a recognized authority. Collectors do a lot of research on the manufacturers and then publish books that contain this information. To determine the "type" of any tool you would need to have access to a publication or website that shows the details that determine when the tool was manufactured. For instance, in the back of Walter's "Stanley Tools" is a section on the different types of knobs, trademarks, and frogs that were used throughout the lifetime of the Stanley Tool's company that you can use to determine the time period during which a specific plane was manufactured. You could post pictures of these tools here and probably get some good insight as to what the aproximate value is.

Re: Type 1; original?

#3

Type 1; original?

Philip Duffy

>Thanks, Moses, your ideas are very helpful and I will pass them along. Phil

Re: Type 1; original?

#4

Re: Type 1; original?

Bob Demers

>To add to Mose excellent response:

The designator Type, is from type studies undertaken by collectors and it has nothing to do with the manufacturer per se. You see, while powertools usualy have serial numbers to help date them, hand tools for the vast majority do not, especially antique ones. Type studies are then an attempt at demarking chronologicaly the tool during its manufacture by features and characteristics which underwent changes during its long production life.

Of notes:

- not every tools have type studies, and they are subject to revison from times to times as new specimens are found and studied. Thats why for example you have type 6a, in order not to push back the other type Nos, and to shoe horn in between type 6 and 7

- manufacturer never heard of type study while making these tools so they used whatever parts on hands, slightly confusing type studies.

- catalog illustrations are notoriously misleading since they recycled the illustrations for a long time

- the most famous one, and probably the original one that coined the term, is the Stanley No4 bench plane type study

- type 1 are generaly the most valuable since they were the very first, original model, but be aware that there are exception to that ruele, some later type are worth more because of rarety

Bob

Re: Type 1; original?

#5

Re: Type 1; original?

wayne anderson

>WRT boxwood rules; the type 1 Stanleys are marked "A. Stanley", rather than "Stanley Rule & Level". The rules with type one markings are quite rare. -w