Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Question for old tool buffs

Posts

Question for old tool buffs

#1

Question for old tool buffs

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>An acquaintance recently asked me a question, which led to my looking through some old catalog reprints sold by Astragal Press. The catalogs are Hermon Chapin (1859), Greenfield (1872), Sandusky (1877), Sandusky (1925), and Chapin Stephens (1914).

Here's the question I was asked: Were moving filletsters made with screw arm fences?

Well, I didn't know because I had never seen a screw-arm moving filletster offered for sale (course, there's a lot of things I haven't seen!). Sash filletsters, yes, lots of them. But not moving filletsters.

But. Each one of these old catalogs, which collectively cover a span of 65 years, shows slide-arm and screw-arm moving filletsters. Greenfield offered a whole slew of them. Whelan makes mention of them, with specific reference to Greenfield.

Question: Where'd they all go? Does anyone have a screw-arm moving filletster? Maybe they just didn't sell many of them. A quick scrutiny of the catalogs indicates that buying one with a screw-arm fence could increase the cost of the filletster in the ballpark of 50% over a basic model with the fence sliding on screws fixed to the sole.

Wiley

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#2

Re: Question for old tool buffs

Bob Demers

>Wiley

Yes there were Fillister planes with screw arm fences but the vast majority of that type (fence with arms) were adjusted by boxwood wedges rather than wooden nuts on threaded arm.

Also, these 'armed' fillister (if you'll excuse the pun :-) are sometimes confused with plough planes.

The main difference being that plough planes fence will pass under the bottom of the sole while sash fillister fences are set higher and will stop against the side of the stock (Ref: Traditional WW handtools, Graham Blackburn 1998)

Bob

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#3

Moving filletster

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Bob,

Everything you say is exactly right. However, I was actually referring to moving filletsters with slide arms or screw arms. Not sash filletsters.

The five old catalogs I have on hand each offered slide- and screw-arm moving filletsters, but I see nary a one in my online travels. I wuz wondering if they actually sold any, and if so, where'd they all go.

Since a moving filletster doesn't require a large range of fence motion--an inch or little more--the arms on a moving filletster could be pretty short, and so it would be a lot of bother to make such a fancy fence with such a short range of motion. But apparently they did--maybe they were able to make or use 'shorts' from the plough line. Price comparisons in the catalogs indicate that the screw-arm or slide arm fence would cost about $1 more than the bottom fence, which was significant since Greenfield in 1872 (for example) sold a beech model with screw-driven stop, nicker, and boxed shoulder for $2.50. Same model with slide or screw arm fence cost $3.40. Apparently, folks didn't want to pay for it, plus I imagine it would be a bulky plane in use, and wouldn't stow away as easily when not in use.

Anybody seen one of the 'armed' moving filletsters?

Wiley

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#4

how about an 18th C American one?

Larry Williams

>Here an early yellow birch armed moving fillister. We don't have any others but I have seen one other wedge armed moving fillister. It's been a while but it was also an American plane.


img

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#5

bottom view

Larry Williams

>While it's kind of an ugly plane, the fence is nice.


img

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#6

Re: bottom view

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Larry!

Thanks! That's an interesting plane. First place, the wedge is very slick. I like the way the 'head is up off the pillow' like on a Sleeper, even though the rest of it isn't Sleeper-like. Also, the wedge-arm fence leaves the plane pretty compact, compared to if they had used a screw-arm. Third, the fence setting would be fast with the wedge-arm (IMO).

Is that plane marked?

Wiley

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#7

Re: Moving filletster

Bob Demers

>Quote However, I was actually referring to moving filletsters with slide arms or screw arms. Not sash Unquote

OK, now im confused :-)

A rabbet plane with built-in fence and stop is known as a fillister.

There two main classes of fillisters: Standing fillisters (fence and stop are cut into the body, and therefore fixed) and moving fillisters (have an adjustable fence and stop)

The sash fillisters is a member of the moving fillister branch of the rabbet plane family and while both cut a rabbet on the edge of the work, the sash fillister cuts it on the far side of the work where as the moving fillister cuts on the near side. Near and far refering to side close to you while planing at the bench.

That seems to be the concensus in my text books, hence why im confused (i'll readily agree it doesnt take much :->

So all that to say, that: Are we not talking about the same plane?

The sash plane is often miss-id for a plough, and to answer your original question, the screw arm variety are nonetheless pretty rare.

and no, never actually saw one except like you in catalog cuts.

Begging the question you asked: Where they ever made?

Bob

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#8

Re: Question for old tool buffs

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Wiley,

Your question piqued my interest, so I looked in the cataloge reprints that I have and found the same as you, that they all made and sold filletsters with wedge and screw arms. I also looked in Whelan and he discusses them and does not note that they are especially rare. He shows the fence to be similar to the fence on a regular moving fillitster, about a half an inch thick and two inches wide, not as fancy as a fence on a plow or Larry's plane.

I have never seen one at the shows that I have attended, or if I did it didn't register. The only bad thing about you bringing this up is that I'll have to start looking for one to compare it in use to the more typical style.

Jim

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#9

Heres one

Todd Hughes

>Remembered I bought one of these things a few months ago and after digging around in the back of my truck found it in a milk crate. Looks like an early plane made out of Birch with wide champhers, has two old owners names branded on the side like was popular in SE Penn. Has a skew cutter...Thought it was pretty neato and couldnt turn it down for $10.

I think I have a couple more somwhere or other....Todd


img

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#10

Other side 

Todd Hughes

>


img

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#11

Re: Moving filletster

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>"So all that to say, that: Are we not talking about the same plane?"

__________

Bob,

I think we can get on the same page. Yes, the moving filletster (I'm using the olde-tyme American spelling) and the sash filletster are both skew rebate planes. Generally with depth stop, nicker, and fence (though I have seen at least one sash rebate without nicker). In the examples I've seen, the skew is right-leading in both types of filletsters--Whelan says there's some difference of opinion on whether left leading or right leading is better.

As you point out, both the moving filletster and sash filletster have their fence on the left, and fence off the left edge of the board. One key difference being that the moving filletster is rebating the same side of the stick that you're fencing off (the left side); the sash filletster is rebating the far side, but referencing its fence off the near side.

The differences.....Again, as you point out, the fence on a sash filletster butts up against the plane body; while the fence on a moving filletster has to run underneath the plane body in order to isolate a potentially very small cutting width of blade. The portion of the sash filletster blade that is not cutting just hangs off the far edge of the board, but the portion of the moving filletster that is not cutting is hidden under the fence. The fence on a sash filletster needs reach about like a plough, so it can reach across a window sill for example, whereas the fence on a moving filletster needs only to have enough reach to cover and uncover a blade that is maybe 1-3/8" wide.

The nicker, shoulder boxing (if any), and depth stop on a moving filletster are located on the right side of the plane; on a sash filletster they are located on the left side--I believe you called this out as well.

So. When you enumerate the appurtenances of a moving filletster and a sash filletster, it turns out that each has the same ones--fence, depth stop, shoulder boxing, and nicker--but they are different in various ways according to how each type of plane is used.

And yes, I forever see sash filletsters located under 'ploughs' on ebay!

So are we together? I think so.

Wiley

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#12

agree

Bob Demers

>So are we together? I think so.

Wiley

Aye Aye Sir :-)

Bob

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#13

Re: Moving filletster

Mike L, Orange County, CA

>Thanks Wiley and Bob for the clear explanation of these two plane types. What I still don't understand is why is the difference necessary?

Regards,

Mike - who has been tempted to buy sash filletsters simply for their aesthetic appeal

Re: Question for old tool buffs

#14

You bring up an interesting point

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Jim said, "...I'll have to start looking for one to compare it in use to the more typical style."

______

I think it's an interesting question about how they would be in use, particularly comparing the wedge-arm to the standard (I think they call it 'side arm') filletster. Larry's plane looked pretty compact, and now I think about it, I see short screw-arm examples of adjustable plank match planes, and they look pretty practical.

If you have the undersides of the fence screw heads on a regular filletster filed just right (or else if it happens to be a Clark & Williams, meep meep) then the regular filletster works great. On the other hand, the armed moving filletster would put an end to the situation you have when the fence screw(s) dig in on one side as they tighten--they generate an unbelievable amount of force to pull the fence out of whack. I'd love to see C&W make an armed filletster--would be on the list in a heartbeat.

Wiley