Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

new tenon saw

Posts

new tenon saw

#1

new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>Hello everyone. Haven't posted any work here in awhile so thought I'd share a tenon saw I just finished. Please excuse the super wrinkled backdrop. The light tent just rolled out of bed. Uhhh...or I was in a hurry.

The blade is 15" long, 10ppi, rip, with about 3 3/4" of blade at the toe and 4" at the heel. It cuts real well, but of course I didn't think to photograph it cutting until I sat down to write this, and it is all boxed up to ship.

Anyway, just thought I would contribute to the forum. Take care everyone!

Andrew


img

Re: new tenon saw

#2

Re: new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>Forgot to mention, the tote is walnut.


img

Re: new tenon saw

#3

Re: new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>The etch on the back side says "Soli Deo Gloria" per the customer's request. I don't know if you can click on the picture to see it any closer or not. I'm not the most technological guy.


img

Re: new tenon saw

#4

Re: new tenon saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hey Andrew!

Excellent! Just Excellent!

Love the handle design.

Marv

Re: new tenon saw

#5

Looks "beefy" . . .

steve mackay

>What do we call that "extension" of the blade under the tote ? The rounded area. Also can we see a closer detail of the engraving on the brass back ? Whats the design and how was it done ? It really caps the whole thing for me !

Re: new tenon saw

#6

Thanks Marv!

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: new tenon saw

#7

Re: Looks "beefy" . . .

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Steve,

Thanks for the comments and kind remarks. That rounded part at the back, that is essentially just a let in tote where rather than have the blade hug the bottom of the tote, I separated it and brought it back and around. I like that rounded shape at the back, as it gets a little more blade supporting those rear teeth. And I also like the way it looks.

You know, I do have a better shot of the etches themselves but it is a progress shot from when the back was off. I can find that if you like and post that. Won't be able to do that until tomorrow, though, but I'd be happy to do it. Also, these pictures show the detail much better on my computer, so if you wanted I could send them to you via e-mail, in a bigger size than I can display them here. Might be a little better, I don't know--I don't really know why they look smaller in some venues than in others.

These etches came out very clean. The design is scrolling vines, or foliage--just filling up the space with something that pleased my eye. The etching on the blade is my logo.

The process of doing the etching, that is something I wrote an article about over at WK Fine Tools if you want to check it out. That is basically the process I used here. The article is a little dated but is basically how I do it.

Thanks again for your kind remarks Steve.

Andrew

Re: new tenon saw

#8

A work of art!

Jim in VA

>Truly beautiful. The new owner is going to smile with pride every time he picks it up to make a cut. Have you posted somewhere the process of making your saws? I would be most interested.

--Jim

Re: new tenon saw

#9

Re: A work of art!

Andrew Lunn

>Thanks Jim. I really appreciate your kind remarks. No, I haven't posted anywhere how I make my backsaws. I haven't written much of anything in awhile to tell you the truth. There's an article from awhile back about a panel saw I made, my first saw ever--it's at Wk Fine Tools, and I believe it is still in the articles here at WC.

As far as making backsaws goes, the devil is in the details--most of the big stuff is pretty obvious; the rest of it, and the stuff I find the most interesting, is all of the nitty gritty stuff, both in terms of function and appearance. There is always more to learn, and that makes it always new and fun.

Re: new tenon saw

#10

Re: new tenon saw

L. Hanson

>That's a fine looking saw, Andew! Nice sense of style and proportion... I'd be scared to use it, it's so nice!

Keep it up!

Leif

Norse Woodsmith

Re: new tenon saw

#11

Thanks Leif! I appreciate your kind words.

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: new tenon saw

#12

Re: new tenon saw

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Andrew,

Man oh man, you do beautiful work!!! Love that handle!

I know you call it a large tenon saw, but I look at it and think "Carcass Saw". I know it's just a matter of the TPI and what it's filed for (cross cut or rip).

I think Chris S's article in "Woodworking" (one of the best I've read in a while) says the names are "somewhat" interchangeable between sash, tenon and carcass saw. I need to review that to make sure I'm not off base here!

Still, it is almost too beautiful to use. ALMOST! I bet it handles like a dream.

Dominic

Re: new tenon saw

#13

Re: new tenon saw

wayne anderson

>I like it...a lot. Very nice work. Sadly, I think walnut is often overlooked as tool making material. It's good enough for extremely high-end gun stocks, so it must be durable. As the prices of exotic species like ebony continue to rise, perhaps we will see more of the fancy grade walnut used.

Keep up the good work. -wayne

Re: new tenon saw

#14

Re: new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Dominic, thanks a lot for the kind remarks. I appreciate them very much. I have to admit, though, I'm a little confused by your observation about the carcass saw. This saw here has a 15" plate, so it's definitely bigger than a carcass saw; it's probably more like what might have been called a sash saw, or a small tenon saw, kind of between the two if you look at Smith's Key. I call it a tenon saw just because that's what it will be used for--I tend to keep things kind of simple like that. It's kind of just one of those things you have to make a decision about and go with. I really avoided the term "sash saw" mostly because I don't make actual reproductions of old tools, and without that historical provenance or context, I'm not sure the term "sash saw" has quite the same meaning. You could mull it over quite a bit I suppose; in the end I just thought I'd stick with tenon saw.

Re: new tenon saw

#15

Re: new tenon saw

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Andrew,

You wrote:

"I have to admit, though, I'm a little confused by your observation about the carcass saw."

You're not alone. I confuse myself sometimes. :>) Seriously, I'm no expert when it comes to saws. In fact I'm so new that I'm still trying to figure out which side goes against the wood (BTW, it's the one with the teeth). :>)

I was only trying to point out how much it LOOKED like what I think of as a carcass saw (despite it's obvious length).

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: new tenon saw

#16

Re: new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>Thank you very much Wayne. I am a big admirer of your work and appreciate your remarks very much.

I agree, I love walnut. In fact, I think a number of the domestic hardwoods can really hold their own. There are some exotics that I think are really special, like boxwood, with its creamy color and ability to hold such fine details, but most of the time I'm perfectly happy with woods like walnut or cherry. I think they have a lot to offer--lots of hidden potential.

Re: new tenon saw

#17

Re: new tenon saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Andrew,

I think that Mike Wenzloff has the various backsaws pretty well identified on his website. Size of saw plate and thickness and PPI seem to be the deciding factors. Also type of handle, open versus closed. Perhaps Mike will come on and give some of his expert advice on the subject.

The length of your saw gets it just barely into the catagory of a miter saw, though your blade is probably thinner. Some people will buy a large miter saw and shorten it and use it for the larger tenons. It's common to find a large miter saw with 11 or 12PPI.

Marv

Re: new tenon saw

#18

Re: new tenon saw

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Dominic, no problem. I just wanted to respond to your post.

Believe me, if I had a nickel for every time someone misunderstood what I meant... That would be a lot of nickels. :) A lot of nickels. Did I make that clear? A lot of nickels.

Re: new tenon saw

#19

Re: Looks "beefy" . . .

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Steve,

I did not forget your request for some better pictures of the brass etching. Here are a couple of progress shots where you can see it better. Hopefully these reduced size photos will show you enough detail. If you want to see bigger ones just email me and I'll show them to you that way. Thanks a lot for your interest.


img

Re: new tenon saw

#20

Re: Looks "beefy" . . . 

Andrew Lunn

>


img

Re: new tenon saw

#21

Oh yes, oh yes, oh yes, . . .

steve mackay

>Ahhhhhhhhhh ! That is just too cool for school ! Thanks ! A real inspiration for some peices I've been wanting to have " enhanced" !

Re: new tenon saw

#22

Thanks Steve!

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: new tenon saw

#23

Andrew well done but, I'm a bit confused...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I understand the saw blade being etched, the brass back look engraved to me not etched. Am I wrong? Also what does the words on the brass it mean? I'm no Greek scholar so I don't have a clue. Never the less it's a fine piece of work!

Re: new tenon saw

#24

Re: Andrew well done but, I'm a bit confused...

Andrew Lunn

>Thanks Scott. I appreciate the compliment. The brass back is in fact etched, not engraved. If you had side by side an engraving and an etching of the same material you'd be able to see the difference. They'd catch light differently. The etchant I use eats pretty much straight down and creates a fairly flat bottom, whereas with engraving the troughs of the lines would in all likelihood be v-shaped and very shiny, or maybe u-shaped, depending on the graver you used.

The inscription Soli Deo Gloria is Latin for "Glory alone to God."

Thanks for your interest and have a nice weekend.

Re: new tenon saw

#25

Who what of thunk. Thanks Aadrew!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>