Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Adam Cherubini's Saws

Posts

Adam Cherubini's Saws

#1

Adam Cherubini's Saws

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>Hey Adam, I was looking at your blog the other night and saw your get together you had earlier this year in your shop to discuss your saws. You mentioned you were originally reluctant to make them, but you have made a kit of saws for yourself. Because of your postings here and your regular column in PW I am aware of much you have said about what you want from your saws but I think others and myself would be interested in knowing what saws you have made and why you felt compelled to make them rather than use or modify saws that can be had from retailers and the used markets. Sorry if this is rehashing old stuff.

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#2

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Adam Cherubini

>Pat,

I started making saws several years ago because I couldn't buy what I wanted. Specifically, I wanted longer back saws with thinner blades and I wanted long saws with rectangular blades.

I had this theory that these things mattered. I made a set of kenyon saws 3 or 4 years ago. Before that, I had worked with antique saws like everybody else. I had over 100 different saws, all sharpened and set differently. I also made many framed saws. I also tried working with japanese saws. I think my theory was correct, though. You can make little changes to a saw and get more performance out of it.

I'm currently working on a new set of saws that are a bit earlier in style than the Seaton chest saws. I'm incorporating all I've learned from making and using the kenyon saws. These new saws are a lot more like what they are currently using in Williamsburg. IF I'm happy with them, I may offer them for sale. You'll have to watch my blog or personal website. I probably won't make many of these and I probably won't advertise.

Did I answer your questions?

Adam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#3

Adam...where can we see some of your saws?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#4

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>Adam, you answered my question in general. But it's the details that I'm wanting to hear more about. I've decided to start making and refining my own tools. As I've said previously, I have so many tools and yet I'm not happy with my mix. I'm afraid that I'll have to make a lot more tool mistakes but it would be nice to profit from someone else's experience for some of it. It sounds like you prefer thinner blades on your longer back saws than is generally available. I have a couple of 16" Disstons that I'm not pleased with the handles or the ppi. I don't have an opinion about their steel guage. Most of my saws would benefit from handle changes. Oh well, the process is the fun.

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Moses Yoder

>If you have a saw that you are not happy with this is the place to start learning. Modify it to your tastes. It is very easy to make a handle for a saw and file the saw the way you want it. Pete Taran has an article on saw sharpening here in the articles section that covers evertyhing on sharpening that you would need to know. I know you can learn quite a bit from reading about other people's experiences but nothing beats hands on experience; just do it. If you can modify a saw to cut the way you want it to the next step is to make your own, which you will already know how to do.

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#6

Give me a few weeks

Adam Cherubini

>Pat,

I'll have very specific information on adamcherubini.com in a couple weeks or sooner.

Adam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#7

Re: Give me a few weeks

Ron In Sterling CT

>

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#8

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws *LINK*

Adam Cherubini

>I finished my saws. The link below leads to my website where I have listed the back saws. The long saws are coming soon. I don't have paypal up and running yet. If you want a saw, email me, and we'll settle up later. I'm not going to make many of these. I don't make money making them. So if they are of interest act soon.

If you aren't interested in buying a saw from me, you may find the website interesting. Be sure to check out the blog entry on the main page (www.adamcherubini.com)

Adam


img

Tools for Sale

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#9

Re: long-lost striking knife

paul womack

>I notice that there's a striking knife for sale; the "lost secret".

I continue to differ on "lost"

post+photo in woodcentral archive

BugBear

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#10

Re: long-lost striking knife

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>The lost "secret" in that case was how tools help each other and work together. The mystery isn't the knife or even what it does, but how tools cooperate in a period tool shop.

I find modern tools don't and even sometimes compete with each other. The hollow chisel mortiser wants what it wants. It doesn't care what you want. And in order to get a square mortise, you need the opposite face to be parallel to the face you want the mortise in. This isn't always a given in formal chairs, for example. So like a Prima Donna, we must do something special for it to do it's job.

Adam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#11

Re: long-lost striking knife

paul womack

>The mystery isn't the knife

OK.

Here's an ugly modern version:

modern scribe

I think Derek Cohen's converted spade bit idea is probably the best way to acquire a decent striking knife, if they're not common locally

BugBear

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#12

This one?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>After Adam published his article in PW, and following some discussion here, I had this idea to make a striking knife from a spade bit. This one looks like it was a 1" bit.



I used it for a while. To be frank, it was not pleasant - uncomfortable to hold, constantly in danger for my life, and the knife cutting angle was too vertical for sufficient downforce in hardwood. I returned to using a separate marking knife and awl.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#13

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Pedder Broockmann

>Hi Adam,

they're beautiful. But I wonder if the back won't wobble in the slot?

kind regards

Pedder

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#14

spine wobble and experimental archeology

Adam Cherubini

>The only folks using saws like these at the moment, besides myself, are the craftsmen in Colonial Williamsburg. I've had some experience with these sorts of things before (essentially accurate tool reproductions), and you're right, there are sometimes unexpected consequences.

So far so good. I've detected no wobble or looseness. Everything seems as tight as any other saw. Frankly, I was concerned about a saw plate this big and this thin. That's also unique. So far I like it.

For me, all of the fun of tool making is getting to use something that's out of the ordinary. Hand tool woodworking in general is like that, no? So you're right, we don't really know what these saws have to teach us yet.

I haven't yet seen any glaring design flaws so far. I wouldn't be selling them if I did. But yeah, I wonder if in a year's time, when more people have them, if folks will come back to me and say "I wish this feature was different". I guess as a merchant, I should be concerned about that. As somebody who's just thrilled to learn more about traditional woodcraft, I think this will be a fabulous learning opportunity. As more people have the sorts of tools Williamsburg has, I think we'll learn more as a community.

Adam

------WebKitFormBoundaryLPQ+XgMzJq7Awz9F


img

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#15

A Celebration of the Old.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Adam

Firstly, I want to congratulate you on the thought and workmanship that you have put into these saws. They look the real deal and I have little doubt that they will function beautifully. Whether everyone will appreciate their aesthetic, well that is another matter. I think that they are striking.

What I want to emphasize is that these saws are more than just an opportunity to add a tool to the workshop. You made them for yourself as part of your research into 18th century woodworking, driven by curiosity and a quest for knowledge. I know that I can feel your excitement as the data gathers and builds into a picture, uncovering the unexpected. These saws represent the opportunity of others to join you in this pursuit, and in a celebration of the old.

I share with you the anxieties of a small scale tool maker. I do not build tools for profit. I build something for myself, and then make extra to share it with others. Often there is little way to determine the long term durability of the tool. We have to trust to our logic and belief in the materials and our workmanship. I still stress over this area nonetheless, but remind myself that most "customers" are really cyber friends who wish to share in the experience.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#16

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Adam, these saws look a treat; but not being a western saw user, I haven't a clue as to how they'd be different. Care to explain?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#17

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Adam Cherubini

>Pam,

I've got no sales pitch for you. I was making these for myself and was wondering if other period interpreters or museums would want saws from this period. I basically used the same sources Williamsburg did when they made theirs. I made a few changes based on my experience using saws these many years and reinterpreted some of the technical and esthetic features.

I guess I should write a webpage about all this. It's kind of a good story. I called Charles Hummel for example. I visited the Dominy shop because it looks to me as though they have a White saw or at least a saw from this period.

If you are asking me as a woodworking author if these saws are a significant addition to the hand tool woodworking world, I'd have to say no. But they are available, I'm offering them for sale, they are reasonably accurate to the period in which Thomas Chippendale worked, and they function well. They are a good "set" for someone who wants to do the sort of work I do. The shapes and filings are set up well for period casework and chairs.

My only regret is that I wish they were cheaper so more people could afford them. Maybe if I could just injection mold those handles........hmmmm.

Adam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#18

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I wasn't looking for a sales pitch, simply giving you an opportunity to describe their performance vis a vis contemporary well made saws, such as Mike W's. Or, why did you decide to make them? There must be some reason. If it's only "because I wanted to and could," then OK, no need for further discussion. But since I think you're a pretty smart and thoughtful man, I assumed there were some performance gains to be realized in some design feature(s).

Pam

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#19

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws *LINK*

Adam Cherubini

>To be fair, I don't have any contemporary saws except my own. I've been making my own saws since 2002. I completed my set of Kenyon saws in 05 and made a few for friends.

On paper, there may be some advantages to these earlier style saws. The proof is going to be in the using. As soon as I can, I want to get a full set into the the office at Popular Woodworking. I'd like to know what Bob Lang, and Glen Huey and "The Schwarz" think. I wonder if my editor, Megan Fitzpatrick, will prefer my 16" tenon saw to Chris ' 19" monster. Hopefully she will use my 20" panel saw to saw off the legs of one of the workbenches there. I regularly work in high heels and I can't recommend it.


img

Megan's high heels

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

#20

Re: Adam Cherubini's Saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Those are not high heels! Having worn those foot busters for quite a few years, until I unilaterally became a "comfortable shoes woman" 100 years ago, it's hard to forget the pain.

Thanks for the reference to Megan's blog.

Pam