Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

Posts

Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

#1

Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

James Watriss

>I finally broke down the other day and ordered one of them newfangled L-N progressive pitch DT saws, despite the warning on the Schwartz blog that it was a love it or leave it kind of thing.

Well, I tried it on a scrap of wood tonight (3/4" thick, I'll try it on thinner stuf tomorrow) and it was love at first sight. But I think I figured out why.

I'm a recent convert to the whole push saw thing, I've been using Japanese saws for a while now, and of all of them, I was really used to using the Ryoba to cut dovetails. Why? It was easier at first to find a pretty good Ryoba than a half decent Rip Dozuki. I know, a thin floppy saw doesn't sound like it'd be much good for straight cuts, but I really love using them that way. (I'm sure I'll get some complaints about that)

Being used to the Ryoba means being used to a progressive tooth pitch on rip cuts, and I was used to being able to get up a little steam and really hog through the wood. It was something I really missed on the Gramercy saw, which I picked up over Xmas. I've been on a DT saw binge, it seems.

I'm pretty glad to have both, though. I think the Variable pitch is going to work much better on thicker stuff, like bigger drawers, and carcases, while the finer-toothed Gramercy will be best for things like small drawer sides... so I don't think there's any redundancy there.

Of course, I say that with 2 really good DT saws, 2 rip cut Dozukis, and a couple of really nice Ryobas, all sitting in the same drawer, and a 14" and 18" bandsaw in the shop...

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

#2

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>What rip dozukis do you have?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

#3

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

James Watriss

>I picked up the Lee valley version, and I have one from Mitsukawa that I got when I was taking a class from John Reed Fox.

The mitsukawa is truly something to work with, even without a progressive pitch took setup.

The Lee Valley ir really not bad, compared to making rip cuts with any of the piles of X-cut dozukis I've had. But I paid less for my Ultra Fine Takumi Ryoba from Woodcraft, and I enjoy it more. I think all the work with floppy pull saws has me wondering if a back saw is really so necessary in that configuration.

Well, that, and a Ryoba makes that really cool "schwingggg" sound when you let it drag a little on your bench...

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

#4

Re: Really liking the Progressive pitch DT saw...

Tony Zaffuto

>Please post your impression of the saw on thinner material. I work mainly with 1/2" stock ( hair bigger sometimes, sometime a hair smaller). I need another saw like a hole in the head, but, what the hey!

T.Z.