Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Sharpening Box

Posts

The Sharpening Box

#1

The Sharpening Box

Rusty Miller

>Does anyone here have one of these? It is made by Blum Tool Company. Just wondering what you think of it. I'm thinking of buying one but just wanted some opinions because it is quite expensive.

After watching the video on the website it looks like a really good sharpening jig.

Rusty-Tye, TX

Re: The Sharpening Box

#2

Re: The Sharpening Box

tstock

>Might spend $10 on an Eclipse side clamping honing jig knock-off and the rest on the stones or the Scary Sharp materials of your choosing. There's nothing the 'Sharpening Box' will do that cheaper, better jigs won't.

Re: The Sharpening Box

#3

cheapest, easiest, fastest and good as any....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Let me begin by saying that if someone told me before I tried it that I could, and would prefer, to sharpen free hand I would have blown them off as yet another highly experienced woodworker underestimating the skills of mortals. There are all sorts of woodworking skills that I have been told are "easy", that are more like impossible in my hands. That said should make the following more credible. If one will try it success will follow or you are such a Klutz that working wood with hand tools will be impossible and this is all a moot point anyway.

Every element is important to make the overall process easy.

1. Buy a power grinder and the appropriate wheels and tool rest. All this part has been discussed below in detail the last few weeks.

2. Grind a hollow grind on the tool. Again this technique has been discussed recently.

3. At this point you are a minute from a sharp as you need too be edge. The secret to making the next part easy is the hollow grind. The next part can be done without a hollow grind, but not near as easy as a hollow grind. I can't ( and won't) do it with out a hollow grind.

4. Select any medium coarseness abrasive format. I used a fixed diamond fine stone but it could as easily be 1000 grit sand paper, water stone, etc. Grasp tool in both hands with thumbs under and index fingers pressing on the top right over the bevel. Lower tool to the stone and rock it back and forth pressing the hollow ground bevel against the stone sruface. Your will feel the hollow grind suck against the stone (presuming the stone is flat) when the plane of the bevel mates the plane of the stone. This is a critical thing to be able to feel. Practice it a bit, rocking tool back and forth till you can feel the engagement. Once you got it pull the tool slowly toward you across the stone. By pulling slow you will be able to feel that the bevel remains engaged with the stone surface. Now here is the beautiful part.***** You only need to make a few strokes across the surface to remove the grinder scratches because you are only abrading the first tiny bit of the tool's edge.**** And because you only need to pull a few times your patience will not wear out and you will be able to keep the bevel properly seated on the stone surface each stroke. As soon as you have uniform grind mark across the edge you are done. It could be as few as 5 strokes if the edge from the grinder is straight.

5. Repeat step 4 with the finest grit you want to use. I use 1 micron diamond, but a fine water stone or sandpaper would be fine for most tools. In about 5 strokes you are done.

The reward of cheap, and quick makes learning to sharpen this way worth a bit of practice and the small investment for a proper grinding wheel. I presume everyone has a grinder for other tasks around the farm.

Re: The Sharpening Box

#4

Re: The Sharpening Box

Brian in Ottawa

>What is it? Link available?

Re: The Sharpening Box

#5

Re: The Sharpening Box

Rusty Miller

>blumtoolco.com on left click on sharpening jigs.

Re: The Sharpening Box

#6

Re: The Sharpening Box

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Rusty

I have the Sharpening Box, along with the smaller, fixed version, and two planes, a smoother and a trying plane. I have been using and evaluating them over the past three or so months. A review should be done in about a month.

I don't have too much to offer right now, but I can say that Gary Blum has some really innovative items, and they do work. The quality is first rate.

The Sharpening Box is a fascinating opportunity to (literally) turn the process of honing on its head. It must be said that this is not for everybody - my first inclination is to just freehand a hollowground blade. But over time I have slowly managed to set aside my instinct and tune it in. There is potential here.

One of the ideas I came up with, after playing around with the Sharpening Box, was to use it to develop the first (as far as I am aware) honing guide for router plane blades. Here are some of the pictures I sent to Gary.









Please do not see this as a recommendation for the Sharpening Box - yet. I am still evaluating it. Gary's designs are so original that I have not felt comfortable putting my experiences to paper until I believe that I can say that I have mastered them all. More later.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Sharpening Box

#7

Re: The Sharpening Box

Rusty Miller

>Derek,

Thanks for the reply. Guess I'll hold off a while so I can read your review. I value your reviews especially when spending this much money on a sharpening jig.

Look forward to any comments.

Thanks,

Rusty-Tye,TX

Re: The Sharpening Box

#8

Re: The Sharpening Box

Dean J in MN

>Let me reinforce Bill's post. I think learning how to sharpen without all the jigs, guides, and smoke and mirrors is well worth the time. And as Bill has said, it really isn't that difficult.

I'm not going to discount jigs, they have their place. But, this jig seems to be suited to straight edge tools. Looking in my tool chest I see very few straight edges. Chisels, and joint making planes. That leaves all of my bench planes (camber on the blades), hollows and rounds, complex molding planes, carving gouges, firmer gouges, etc.

The sharpening box isn't going to help me with all those other tools as far as I can tell. What would help is if I was confident in my ability to freehand sharpen. I built that confidence by freehanding the simple straight edges.

I encourage you to give freehand sharpening a try. Hollow grind a simple straight edge tool and follow the excellent advice in Bill's post for honing that edge.

-Dean

Re: The Sharpening Box

#9

Freehand sharpening *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>The best instructions I've found for freehand sharpening are located on Joel's site:


Freehand sharpening

Re: The Sharpening Box

#10

Great idea, Derek.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>