Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

router plane

Posts

router plane

#1

router plane

McKay

>I know that I saw a review for lie nielson router plane vrs. veritas. Can anyone point me in the correct direction? Thank

Re: router plane

#2

Re: router plane

paul womack

>Putting the words "veritas nielsen router comparison" into google led me to

http://blogs.popularwoodworking.com/editorsblog/LieNielsen+Large+Router+Plane.aspx

BugBear

Re: router plane

#3

There have been some threads here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>as I recall. Can't, though, recall how far back.

Re: router plane

#4

Re: router plane  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>There is a thread on WoodNet at this time .. Link below

Mike Wenzloff's posts his views.

I added a piece of my own. Here is a copy ....

I have all the LV and LN router planes in my workshop at this time. They form a part of an article I am writing for a magazine (this is not to be a review of the planes).



I have used the LV router planes for some time now (see my website for reviews), and my introduction to the LN versions has been quite recent.

This is going to be a very brief comparison - I might do a more detailed one later.

First off, I thought that the LN large router plane is great and it was very satisfying to use. At the end of the day it is not as user-friendly as the LV, but without a direct comparison this would not necessarily be obvious.

The LN is comfortable in use. I like the grips, but I can't say that they are better or worse than the angled grips of the LV. They are different. The LV afford a low centre of gravity. One will prefer one and another the other.

I liked the depth stop of the LN. I MUCH preferred it over the one on the LV. In fact I plan to build one like it for my LV router! I have never come to master the split rings of the LV - just can't get them tight enough with finger pressure to resist movement. The LN uses a thumbscrew and it is a simple measure to tighten it down.

I'm afraid that that is where the pros of the LN over the LV end. In all other areas the LV bests the LN:

The LN comes with one blade and then uses a converter for the blades from the #271. The bloody things keep falling out of the converter. It is so annoying!

Further, to change a blade it is necessary to remove the blade adjuster screw (at the top). It is as though one must dismantle the plane each time you want to change a blade. The LV, by contrast, has a spring-loaded blade holder, and it takes a couple of seconds to remove/replace the blade.

The fences are quite different. The LN uses a slightly modified version of the Stanley. It is essentially the same - crude and limited in range. The LV is a precision instrument by comparison, with a wide range and easy adjustment.

Retuning to the practical side, as long as the original blade is used, the LN is a pleasure in action. I really liked using it ... as long as I did not have to replace the blade. If I were to choose one of these planes for my workshop, at this time there is no doubt that it would be the LV.

The LN needs a set of dedicated blades like the LV. The LV needs the LN's depth adjuster.

Regards from Perth

Derek

http://www.inthewoodshop.com


WoodNet Thread