Adjusting workbench height
wilbur
>For those of you who built a workbench and found the height not to be optimal, is it easier to make the bench shorter by cutting down the legs, or taller by adding spacers?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Adjusting workbench height
wilbur
>For those of you who built a workbench and found the height not to be optimal, is it easier to make the bench shorter by cutting down the legs, or taller by adding spacers?
Wilbur, I gotta say this is an odd question
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>If the height is not optimal, it's either too tall or too short - so which method is easier seems less important than determining in which direction it's wrong, and taking appropriate action.
If I'd built a bench and was concerned that it was too tall, before I cut the legs off, I think I'd build some duckboards at the thickness I thought the bench was too tall, and work on them for a while before getting out the (dog-powered, of course) chainsaw to shorten the legs. Needn't be elaborate - a 2x2, 2x4, whatever, platform, covered with whatever plywood I had in the right size. You'd have to be conscious that you were standing on them...wouldn't want the surprise of not noticing there was a step there as you walked over to get a tool on the far side of the shop.
Blocking up the legs shouldn't be too hard, if you have a safe way to raise up the bench - two teenagers, for instance, or, lacking that, a jack arrangement of some kind.
I know that everyone says a hand tool bench should be low, but I find my back aching at the end of a long day (sometimes even a short day - growing up is a bummer sometimes), and think my next bench will be taller than the current one, maybe as much as 39" for my 6'2" height.
Side note: spent the day driving my son down for a medical procedure in San Francisco, a theoretical hour (50 plus or minus miles) south of here. We left at 5:30 a.m. for a 7:30 appointment, arrived at 7:00, knowing that if we'd left at 6:00, we'd have arrived at 8:00. Coming home - MID-afternoon - no better. There are days that I'm ready to move to the edge of the world, but then I remember there's no doctors or hardwood dealers there.
you can see the edge from here
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>and we don't need hard wood dealers. We have the sawmills.
In two hours I could be more than 100 miles from home; that's at a minimum 30,000 square miles to find a doctor. But we don't have anyone like Nancy to represent our interests in Washington. That could be "missed".
Not so odd
wilbur
>Hopefully his will explain things a bit better. I've been working so far off of a Workmate type bench that seems too low for me, and a board over two sawhorses that seems a bit high. I'm getting ready to build a real workbench (actually, I've been getting ready for the past 9 months, it seems -- at least it's full term by now), and am still not fully decided on the height.
So, I asked this question so that I could have an idea as to which way to err on, so if I was off, I would at least have an easier time of fixing the height issue. It's kind of like the equivalent of how far to saw into the waste.
Re: Not so odd
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>No, it isn't. Not that I've done this, but I think I'd tend to make it a bit tall and trim to fit. That also gives some room for an unlevel floor.
Pam
Re: Not so odd
Frank House
>Wilbur,
I am planning a bench too. The one I got from a friend many years ago is smallish, battered, and due for replacement.
I had to trim the legs because of decay, but I found that a collection of bricks and an ancient car jack give me an adjustable height bench, and I am pleased to be able to use the adjustment from time to time.
I have improvised a couple of small piggy-back sub-benches, of varying height, which stand on it and bring delicate jobs to chest or eye level.
I have no doubt that adjustable height is the way to go, and, with a bit of thought, steadiness need not be compromised.
May you spend more time using than building :),
Frank.
Re: Adjusting workbench height
paul womack
>Easy to make it taller; making the legs shorter has limits, when you hit the lower stretchers...
BugBear
taller
Jack Guzman from Maine
>Wilbur,
Definitely taller.If you err on the short side and go taller later,you will forever need spacers.If you start tall and need to cut it down a bit you won't need to add anything,ever.
My own personal experience= My bench is great for planing but a little low for detail work,so I use a stool when I need to get closer to my work. If it were higher I would need to stand on something to plane.Easily adjustable without loss of stability would be a nice feature.---Jack
Adjustable workbench *LINK*
Paul in NJ
>
http://www.adjustabench.com/about.asp
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Wilbur,
It is going to look better if you make it long and cut off the legs to height when you decide what height works for you. I have two benches in my shop one short one for planing and one tall one for other work. I would never make a bench this short but it is great for the kids to try their hand at using very sharp tools. The other bench has some 5 x 5's under the legs and it works but looks odd.
My personal workbench is tall but that makes little difference as there is so much crap on it I can seldom get to it.
But even a tall bench sometimes need a lift, my patternmaker's vice sticks up 8 inches from the bench top and I have used carving jacks and 'duckboards' (what a great word) to elevate the work.
Are you making a Western style workbench? Is there a Japanese equivalent of a 'Roubo' workbench?
Stephen
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Hank Knight
>Build in some heavy duty, adjustable levelers. I posted this a couple of years ago, so my apologies to those who have seen it. I had these leg caps fabricated at my local machine shop and used them with some heavy machine levelers from MSC Industrial Supply. The levelers are rated at 1,000 Lbs each, they give me about 4" of vertical adjustment for my bench and they are rock solid.
Hank
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Adam Cherubini
>The problem isn't weight. Its shear. Those leveling legs probably aren't designed (and don't look great) for reacting the force of planing or sawing on the bench. Powertools don't create much shear. But hand tools will. You'll (wilbur) have the same problem with blocking up the legs. The force of planing can easily push a bench off of those blocks or over turn them if they are tall.
Basically, the force of planing is a shear applied at the top of the bench. That shear is reacted by friction at the floor. The offset between the floor and the bench top creates a moment that must be reacted by the legs and at all attachments.
I can't recommend blocking up a workbench. Its much better structurally not to have a marginal joint in this area. My advice is to start with the bench at palm height and cut it down from there. The stretcher location (if present) shouldn't be an issue as the most you will likely lower is 2". I would seriously consider making adjustments in 1/2" increments. An 1" change is a big one. I recently lowered all of my benches to about 1" under palm height.
Adam
Re: Wilbur, I gotta say this is an odd question
paul womack
>If the height is not optimal, it's either too tall or too short
Heh. Optimal for sawing, scrub planing, marking out, finish smoothing and DT cutting are all different "optimals" IME.
BugBear (whose bench is too high, with low stretchers)
Some food for thought.... *LINK*
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Wilbur,
The ultimate adjustable work surface would be a mechanical hydraulic all metal structure but with an added wood work surface.
If you google "lift tables" you will find a lot of companies who offer tables of all sizes and configurations.
To purchase one is a bit pricey, but with some mechanical skills you might design and build your own for much less, using a combination wood and metal. Instead of using a hydraulic mechinism, it could be built along the lines of a scissors jack. With lock-downs it could be made stable for anything you would require for working wood.
We tend to get locked into a mindset of traditionalism. Sometimes it's good to step outside of that line of thinking and combine different methods that will often times produce something that accomplishes exactly what we need and perhaps even more simple.
Forums such as we have here with WC affords a brainstorming process to take place among many people with a combined vast amount of expertise and skills that can quickly be very creative.
The secret to success is to not close your mind to new ideas. Pick and choose ideas and techniques that you can apply to your own situation and abilities.
Marv
Lift Tables
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Hank Knight
>Adam, I agree that shear is an issue, but these levelers have 1/2" steel shafts and that's plenty stout. I've been planing on this bench for two years and is doesn't move at all. In fact I can't push it or rock with will all my weight against it. I think of I had the levelers extended all the way out to their 6" maximum, the shear force might be a problem, but I've kept the adjustment mid-way or less on the leveler screws and it's very solid.
Noden Adjust-A-Bench is a great idea *LINK*
Don in Northern Arizona
>
Noden Adjust-A-Bench
Yes, a great idea....but
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>I would need to do some touchy feely and pound on it to see if it sounds and feels hollow and tinie due to all the sheetmetal involved in the construction. Also there needs to be a good solid direct connection between what I'm pounding on and the floor, like when chiseling for example. And is there any sideways motion when planing or sawing? I hate a wiggly table at a restaurant. I always move to another table. I like to test the table for wiggle before I sit down.
Marv
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>The shear strength of a 1/2" threaded bolt or 13 threads per inch can be very sturdy with 4 bolts working together. Even more impressive is the fact that we aren't talking about a 1/2" shaft diameter. The pitch diameter of a 1/2"-13 bolt is only about 3/8" of solid steel. The pitch diameter is measured near the bottom of the thread.
With the application of the four 1/2" bolts that Hank is using we actually aren't experiencing a shearing action. It's more of a flexing or bending action that varies based on the length of extension below the bottom of the leg of the bench. To accomplish less flexing, use stronger metal, like stainless steel for example.
As long as Hank limits the length of extension to no more than about 3 inches, the bench should be just fine. I would have used a 5/8" bolt instead of the 1/2" so more of the bolt could be extended for more height adjustment.
Another method that would be similar would be to use a 1" diameter steel shaft or pipe that has a coil spring up inside the bench leg above the shaft, with the shaft locked in place at the desired height with a perpendicular locking mechanism. The adjustment for height would be much faster. Just release the locking mechanism on each leg and lift the table or push down on it. They would also be self leveling. With all four adjustment shafts locked, there would be no lateral movement.
Marv
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Moses Yoder
>I would agree with the make it taller crowd, but it kind of depends on the design. If you run a horizontal foot at the bottom it would be kind of hard to cut off the bottom. I think it works just as well to have stretchers off the floor (at least 6") and the legs going straight down to the floor. If you are about 6' tall I think 36" is the highest you would want but of course depends on your preference. I think making the bench to be cut down to 32" is about as low as you would want it to be unless you are pretty short. It would be good for you to try out a height before you dedicate it. I like the traditional look of posts connected solidly to the top and going straight down to the floor; something about adjustable feet or posts just doesn't sit right with me.
Re: Yes, a great idea....but
Dan Donaldson
>I have played with one a couple of times at various shows and they are solid. It was not at all obvious that it was adjustable when in use.
Ah - sorry
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I had the impression you'd already built the bench. Sorry.
I think I agree with Pam - build it too high, then fool around with duckboards (even layers of ply) until you find your right working height, then remove the excess height. It seems like it'd be more stable in the end than a bench on blocks.
All speculation on my part, though - my bench sits on a plywood box and a ledger beam on the wall. Not exactly high style.
Japanese Roubo Workbench
wilbur
>I'm going to build a Roubo, but I keep going back and forth over how to best adapt it for Japanese tools.
Option one is to make a left handed Roubo -- essentially a mirror image, which will work well for planes that work on the pull stroke. Problem with that is that the right end of the bench is an ideal spot for sawing with Japanese saws, and with a mirror image Roubo the crochet and leg vise would now be in that spot. Of course, now that I think about it, some low bench horses could help deal with this issue.
Option B is to make a right handed Roubo, and put in another removable planing stop at the front right end for my Japanese planes. Which begs the question about why not just make a trestle beam workbench, but I actually do have some western planes (!) which would benefit from the Roubo workholding parts, and the one sawing task that I still need a vise for is making saw cuts for dovetails. I haven't been able to make good dovetail cuts yet in the kneeling position, mainly because I have problems getting the cut started.
Beta version will soon be available
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Of the new and improved after market, clamp on 'portable saw nib', for just such applications.
It can be attached to any saw of Western pattern.
Also for a slight up-charge, a folded, laminated, sword steel, etched and chopped version for Japanese pull saws is available.
Please indicate the personal pronoun name of your saw so we can get the right match.
Guaranteed to get that saw started in the most difficult timbers, no messing or fussing, easy, anyone can do it.
Stephen
Dude, where's my nib? Make mine
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>in mokume (wood grain) pattern please. I will be needing several, in the 'Evening Calm Over Deseret' series. To be made in the penumbra, when the coyote silhouettes on the far ridge can just be made out through the scope of your .273.
Wiley
Re: Adjusting workbench height
Bob Entwisle in NJ
>Hey Wilbur
Haven't built the bench yet, but I just read in one of the 'Bench Books' (forget which one) That it's easier on a lot of levels to raise the height of a bench, than to cut one down. It has a lot to do with the psychology of having to decide to hack away at the legs on your newly built bench etc. If it's already too short, you just have to add a couple of blocks under the legs to start to raise it up to 'your' correct height. (You can make fancy permanent leg risers for it after you know the correct height) You don't have to make the decision to CUT the new legs shorter.
Something to think about, logic says it�s easier to cut an inch or two off the legs, but the above make sense too.
Bob