Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

still more on grinder speed

Posts

still more on grinder speed

#1

still more on grinder speed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This note is for anyone teetering on the edge of trying a grinder for speedy sharpening but still fearful of burning edges.

I picked up a Swan chisel some time ago that was not very rusted, a rarity for around these parts-both Swan and rust. I decided to put it into service which required getting shallow pits from the back and major bevel restoration to reestablish a proper single angle and make the edge square to the shaft. A lot of metal removal was required.

I have a 3 phase grinder operating from a variable frequency drive which results in infinitely variable speed from barely moving to 3600 rpm. I find these old steels burn easily so I would normally slow the grinder to about 1/3 max. speed. However, today I absent mindedly left the speed at 3600 rpm and went to town on the bevel-never straight into the wheel but sliding the tool back and forth with light touches. In short order the bevel was restored and the new grind went to the edge. It took about 5 minute to complete. The tool was barely warm and no evidence of burning at the edge. A few strokes on a fine fixed diamond plate straightened the edge and 5 stokes on 1 micron loose diamond refined this edge to a high degree of sharpness. So little metal removal is required to refine the hollow ground edge that any abrasive format would have quickly succeeded. It was later that I realized the wheel had been running at full speed.

The point of all this is that with modest experience any grinder will work for sharpening, even 3600 rpm. The wheel , tool rest and technique are what is important for success.

I will not deny that learning to grind at slow speed is easier because it is easier to control metal removal at slow speed.

Re: still more on grinder speed

#2

Re: still more on grinder speed

ThomD

>+1. This whole thing about burning steel is mostly hokum. The risk of doing damage is about the same as the risk of tearing out an edge so badly hand planing you couldn't glue it together. That can happen if you plane against the grain etc... etc... It is essential a warning for those who are completely ignorant. It is like a product liability thing where they don't want to hear your complaints - you have been warned. Back in my rock and ice climbing days, I would hear the same thing about not grinding ice axes or crampon points. Those things worked a lot better sharp, and while the steel wasn't super hard, filing 27 points sharp after each outing was a drag. Same injunction - don't grind. But you have to know that's how they produced them at the factory.

A technique that may help a person ease into grinding is to stop the hollow grinding after the middle 1/2 of the bevel has been ground away. If you have ever had a close call grinding an edge, you will note that the danger is mostly at the very end of the process. At that point the tool may have heated up a little and there is relatively less steel left in the edge to act as a heat sink. If the tool were going to burn this would be the time for it to happen. But if you just remove the middle 1/2 of the bevel, you will greatly reduce the effort required to sharpen by hand, leave more beef in thec utting edge, reduce the chance of burning, reduce the chance of over grinding and loosing useful length.

I would normally only grind chisels that are comodity products. I probably have ground art level tools at some point, and wouldn't be worried about doing it. I'm not showing off - the post heat treat stage in tool and knife making is to grind off the scale so if you stuff as I do, one is down that path with lots of high value blades. However, where woodworking tools are concerned I am more likely to grind a generic O1 blade, than a 350 dollar Japanese chisel. Given that, even if one did burn an edge, I wouldn't really care. I would just grind it blunt past the bad patch and resharpen. Like sharpening a pencil when the lead breaks on the first attempt.

Re: still more on grinder speed

#3

This is the way that trade are trained

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill,

Thanks for the post. This is why I use a grinder that would probably cost USD30 in America (about USD100 here.)

The variable speed isn't essential. Just learn on an old plane blade, by the time you've ground about 1/2" off it, you've usually got the technique down pretty well.

The wider blades are the easier ones to learn on. Grinding a skewer (1/16" chisel) is a pain.

The key thing is, that if the blades are overheating, then the wheel probably needs to be dressed. A blunt/burnished grinding wheel will overheat the steel easily.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: still more on grinder speed

#4

Re: This is the way that trade are trained

ThomD

>I would just add that any time you overfeed it will also overheat.

Re: still more on grinder speed

#5

Re: burning steel hokum?

Adam Cherubini

>"This whole thing about burning steel is mostly hokum."

I don't get you here. Are you saying that the steel isn't actually burning? That blue color is the oxide layer indicating the original temper has been lost at that location. And the damage typically extends beyond that point.

You're right its not burning per se, but the loss of temper isn't hokum. It's a serious grinding inadequacy that may be attributed to equipment or technique. Bluing bad. The need to quench a tool also bad.

Adam

Re: still more on grinder speed

#6

Re: best dresser?

Adam Cherubini

>Bill,

What sort of wheel dresser do you recommend? And has anybody tried the worksharp for flattening backs?

Re: still more on grinder speed

#7

Worksharp

wilbur

>I've tried the WorkSharp for flattening backs on a beater chisel. The chisel got pretty hot -- too hot to touch, and keeping it on the spinning turntable was not the easiest thing in the world. Personally, I'd rather use a coarse diamond plate, or the side of a Tormek wheel, which is also not the easiest thing in the world, but it doesn't get the chisel too hot.

Re: still more on grinder speed

#8

depends on the need

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are three dressing issues.

1. Out of round After mounting, the wheel may not be concentric with shaft. Bushings are often the problem and I make mine. I have not been successful making a wheel round by using a hand held dresser. I use Wolverine.

2. Shaping I like a crowned wheel for plane irons and chisels. I like the dresser that is 7$ from LV. It is a short stick with a pad of diamond grits on the end, about 10 grit. It is too aggressive as received. Dull it up some on a hard gray stone. .

3.Dressing. I like what I use in #2.

4. Hard gray stones for grinding farm implements. I use the kind that is a handle with hard wheels on the end.

Warning, grits fly everywhere when dressing. Do not get good lumber near the site.

Re: still more on grinder speed

#9

I really like Norbide� *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Norbide� hot-pressed boron carbide dressing bars have changed the way I shape bench grinding wheels and dress the myriad abrasive burrs I use in my Foredoms. Although small and not cheap, they quickly leave the sharpest grinding surfaces with the least abrasive attrition, as there is less fracturing of the abrasive particles and matrix material, making them more competitive and economical than one would first expect.

Don't get me wrong -- diamond works fine but is a bit coarse and not quite so durable when applying a sintered edge to small burrs. These little sticks can produce a precise and fair contour on all types of rotary burrs. And using these sticks with a light touch, it's a lot easier to square or round white and pink wheels without making so much free abrasive in the shop. Bill's right... you don't want those crystals anywhere near a lapped tool sole or blade.

If the short (3") bar seems daunting, add a handle. Later, when the stick becomes shorter (I should live so long), a handle would extend its life, as well.

Oh... as for the other (non-Norton) boron carbide dressing bars, don't even bother. There's apparently more to making these sticks than just mooshing some B4C paste together.


Norbide� Stick

Re: still more on grinder speed

#10

Grinding pressure, the trick

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Thom,

Yes, you're right.

In the words of the guy that trained me (but missing a fair few expletives.)

"Forget that you've got to take metal off the thing, just try to shave the grinder wheel with the blade."

Cheers,

Andrew