Re: Laid Steel Tools
ThomD
>I would agree to the point that steel is a lot more important than how you get it, however...
"I think today many people attribute some type of superior performance to laminated tools just because they are laminated which I don't think is true."
It is certainly true that in the past folks attributed these characteristics to lam steel. If you take the Japanese sword, an implement sufficiently valuable that is was no problem testing it on live subject, think of our contemporary nuke program of 40s and 50s. While it would have been more expensive in steel to go all steel, lam way clearly a choice. They certainly could have had all steel if required. They attribute many characterictics to the combination from more resiliance, to a self-cleaning character on the stones.
If you think of the relatively fewer options avaible in material tech, and if you accept that lam steel may have differences from solid steel or iron. Think of it as an application of the law of mixtures, wherin a product takes on the characteristics of it's components in proportion to their presence. It would have been odd if they hadn't gamed lamination, or found useful combinations. In fact it goes beyond that: they had special preferences of which iron for which steel and with what stones.
"I think a solid steel tool can be made to perform as well as a laminated tool...
It is interesting to note that while this is possible it is rarely done. We have a progress based bias, if it is done in a certain way today, it is probably better, there has to be a superior reason for it. In fact while maybe a super tool is waiting out there to be made out of solid steel, if anything is true, people are cheaper about their manufacturing today than ever before, so our aesthtic and economics are all wrapped up in stuff that travels together. The same understanding that offshored all our toolmaking to asia, and dropped the boom on South Bend, and replaced it with stuff in china where tool holders the size of your wrist snap off in a cut, can't actually be trusted to know what is or isn't better, or certainly know what it is worth. It's like Solomon offered the diputing mothers half of the babies each, they went for it, then used multilevel marketing to see to it that every one else cut up their babies too.
"if you think about it the piece that is actually doing the work, the cutting edge, is made out of the same material in both a laminated and non laminated tool."
So even if the edge is the same stuff it doesn't mean it will work the same. I will mention two ideas:
- The edge can be made harder while retaining overall resiliance in the tool. So same material in the edge, but different heat treatment is possible for greater edge holding.
- Japanese concept where the iron cleans the stone, and thereby allows the same, though harder, tool to polish up better. Sharpness is a how not just a what.
"I have seen more then a few edge tools that were marked proudly "Solid Steel" to promote the fact that they were not laminated."
That is just marketing, the fact that some tools might have been novel in solid steel, or certainly better in solid steel in other cases, does not preclude the reverse also being true. In fact we have plenty of modern tools where something like carbide is a longer wearing edge material, but we would not think of making the whole tool out of carbide both for economic and functional reasons.
"As a working blacksmith I have made 100s of laminated edge tools,[mostly axes] that were forge welded out of iron and steel cuttingb its so you would think I would be the first to promote how they are better....But I don't. I made them that way only because it was historicaly accurate and how they were supposed to be made."
That may tell us more about you than tools in general. Maybe you simply value historical accuraccy more than something else. I'm not that way. I did an experiment where I made 4 jack planes in different modes, one of them was made with a tapered Japanese blade and no wedge. I'm interested in that kind of thing, but someone might come along finding them 100 years from now, and say I did it for cheapness, because I just happened to have a Japanese blade around and didn't know how else to use it. Everyone overlays their own preferences. For instance, I have a bias for there being "good" reasons, and looking hard to explain someone's stated motivations before dimissing them.
"..While I don't really think thereare any advantages to a laminated tool I do think there are disadvantages."
Well for one thing they survive humid environments real well. For another, you could call this economics but the iron and steel system does not require drop hammers the size of the statue of liberty because the easy fabrication is a huge advantage.
"Can't begin to tell you how many old tools that I have seen that have had bad welds and not to mention being sharpened up past the steel cutting bit."
Right, but those things tend to happen between then and now. I think my F-150 is pretty OK, if currently vastly overpriced. But people in the future may find them less driveable a few hundred years from now.
"Have also seen tools that I think the steel was burnt when welding it into the wrought iron....with solid steel tools you have none of this to worry about.....Todd"
Well first off, if so, it isn't a necesarry concequence of building this way, only if the guy doing it wasn't up to it. If anything though, it is harder to avoid that kind of stuff today. We have stuff like Stainless foil, heat treating ovens with argon gas pumped into them. We need foundries or stamping mills to do this work from solid steel in modern conditions. Steel burns. Using all steel doesn't exactly solve that problem, any more than the danger of blasting caps is reduced by setting them off in stick of dynamite!