Re: Siegley`s No.3 Wood Plane
Bob Demers
>Hi Helen
Don't be shy, being a newbee, we were all once :-)
Ask away, we are all here for that.
The plane sole corrugation was an attempt to solve an overblown non-issue (IMHO) with the metal sole of the plane developping some sort of suction problems with the wood. In my opinion, its more of a marketing gimmick than anything else. True, resinous woods may feel a tad more sticky (no pun intended) but before you really feel that suction problem, you really have to get that wood planed surface very flat...
Historically, I think it has more to do with trying to convince wood planes users to switch over the then new fangled metal planes. A wooden sole does not have the same feel as a metal sole when planing wood, some prefer one over the other.
Quite a few designs were patented to 'overcome this problem (?)'
The corrugated sole, like you have, being the one that became the most successful from a marketing standpoint, not in practicality.
That added machining step, of course came with a small premium, and today, Corrugated soles go for a higher prices on the collectors market. The other most often seen bright idea was to inlay strip of wood into the sole as in the Steers patent of Sep 11, 1883.
In addition there was also a new hybrid class of planes: the transitional. You had the advantage of the new fangled blade adjuster in a wood soled plane. Again, mostly to win over convert.
Personnaly, I had never really felt any advantages to the corrugated soles and prefer my soles flat. Waxing the soles, does a better job of solving that 'non-issue'. The only undisputable advantages of corrugated soles, is the fact that they are faster to lap flat :-D
Bob, the tool historian