Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Hand Plane help

Posts

Hand Plane help

#1

Hand Plane help

Will Abbott

>I would like to buy a plane to use for removing jointer marks on the edge of boards.I have a low angle block plane that I keep sharp, but it tends to tear out more often than not. I mostly work with cherry, and always pick the stuff with the most figure. Dose anyone have a suggestion for a better plane to use? Or do I just need more practice with the one I have.

Re: Hand Plane help

#2

Re: Hand Plane help

Tom MacGregor

>A higher cutting angle, a tighter mouth and a lighter depth of cut will reduce tearout. Holding the plane at an angle to the direction of cut (skewing the plane) sometimes helps, and some nasty spots just have to be planed from the opposite direction of the surrounding grain. Although any bevel-up iron can be sharpened to a high cutting angle, I generally keep my low-angle (12-1/2 degree bed) block planes ready for end-grain work.

Re: Hand Plane help

#3

Re: Hand Plane help *LINK*

wayne anderson

>I'm no cabinet maker, but a high-angle plane will sheer off fibers rather than lift them, (as a lower angle will tend to do). Either plane will need to be extremely sharp and set fine to do the trick. Hand scrapers are often used for stubborn areas. And if all else fails, there is sandpaper...

Check out the youtube videos with Chris Schwarz. He discusses this issue. -wayne


http://lumberjocks.com/jocks/kem/blog/4329

Re: Hand Plane help

#4

not an easy task

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am willing to believe that there are woodworkers with the right equipment, experience and patience that can plane cherry and similar woods where there is grain reversals and not get tear-out. However, I have never been successful. And from the torn grain I see in antiques made with domestic woods, the old timers had their problems too.

If you will be gluing these edges your time would be better spent fixing the reason you are getting marks left from the jointer. Properly set up and used, the jointer should yield a smooth cut ready to glue, or sand for finishing.

Re: Hand Plane help

#5

Strategy

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Will,

Think about your overall strategy. If you want a slightly sprung edge, do you do it on the machine jointer? Or do you just go for dead flat on the machine?

Case 1. If you're coming off the jointer with the exact edge you want, except it has ripples on it, then I would say get something larger than a block plane, but considerably shorter than a jointer. Just a useful plane, like a No. 4, 4-1/2, or 5, or equal in a woodie. This is because if you've already got the exact edge you want, including spring, the shorter plane will tend to follow the edge you've already created. It's just a smoothing operation. Whereas, if you were to come in behind with a long plane, then in effect you'd be starting over and doing the job a second time, and introducing a chance to mess it up.

Case 2. On the other hand, if you're coming off the jointer with a dead straight and square edge, but with ripples on it, then I would suggest getting a No. 6 or No. 7 (or equal in a woodie), because this will allow you to not only remove the ripples, but also put some spring in the joint (when you want it) with control. You could also spring the joint with a block plane, but with very little control. No. 7 would be the classic plane for the purpose, but I mention a No. 6 (or equal in a woodie) because it would be considerably less expensive and is a useful size all-around in the shop for a variety of jobs.

As in all things, budget matters in answering your question.

Wiley

Re: Hand Plane help

#6

Re: Hand Plane help

Will Abbott

>Thanks to all for your advice. I think I might try a #4 bench plane and see if that does any better.