Can your marking knife ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>.... do this?
I spent the weekend cutting dovetails. Skinny dovetails, just a saw kerf wide. Lost count of how many. Made me appreciate a skinny bladed marking knife.
Regards from Perth
Derek ...... stirring a little :)
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#2Re: Can your marking knife ...
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Yes. And you make a great point about marking knives! Blue Spruce Tool Works' small knife is, I believe, 1/32" thick, which I find just right for pin entries like you're showing.
Wiley
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#3You can't post that and not tell us
Chuck Nickerson
>whose knife that is. It's just not fair.
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#4Re: Can your marking knife ...
John Pappas
>Perhaps a reason to do the pins first. (Also stirring a bit..) :)
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#5Re: You can't post that and not tell us *LINK*
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>.. Sorry Chuck. I guess I was a bit deranged after two solid days of marking and cutting dovetails.
There is often talk of dovetails being the zenith for the hobby woodworker. Nonsense of course since they are not a difficult joint. But they have been glamourized. And the glamour goes especially to those "skinny" ones. What I was wondering was just how many of you actually cut dovetails like that? There is a downside to this design in that the tails are quite fragile.
This a a carcass for a cabinet for the workshop. So I am using 3/4" thick pine (and dressing it up with jarrah framed glass insert doors). I cut these dovetails 1:5 and am using a large number together. Plus the sliding dovetailed dividers will reinforce the construction. So it should be strong. But I really should have made the pins wider.
The marking knife? It is one of my own designs. Jarrah and Olive here. There is a link below to a tutorial I wrote on rolling your own.
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#6Re: Can your marking knife ...
paul womack
>Here's a less known design from Robert Wearing.

It's just a piece of machine hacksaw blade, with ground out recesses to allow access for honing. Sharpening is only on one side, and both ends are sharpened on the same side.
Thus, being double ended, one end does the left hand tail, the other the right.
You can make the middle part (that you hold) more comfortable with anything from a few turns of tape (easy) to cocobolo scale held nby brass rivets (fancy)
BugBear
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#7Thanks Paul *LINK*
Andrew F in Australia
>I use a similar knife to this one, but just ground to a point.
It also doubles as a veneer knife. It won't fit into the saw kerf however.
An expensive equivalent:
My veneer knife (bevel one side only) is in the attached picture - fits right up with the best of haute couture in the local gaol. Ignore the book - had a 2 yr old (at the time) and the spine was ripped off that one.
Cheers,
Andrew
Gaol cell chic.
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#8Re: Thanks Paul
Paul M.
>Hi Andrew,
I have a similar marking knife (only not nearly as pretty). I've found that the very looooonnnngggg bevel is rather dangerous during use. I like to hold marking knives close to the cutting edge, and I've found that the long bevel results in cuts to the top of my middle finger during use. I don't use that marking knife much anymore since I seem to be too stupid to learn how to hold it higher up on the handle.
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#9Yep!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>Both of my Blue Spruce knifes can 8^)
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#10These can
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Just because they are made out of a saw blade. The upper and lower have bevels on one side, the center one is beveled on both sides and is very sharp. The leather sheath protects me from that nasty sharp blade, in the photograph on edge, but the same shape as the other knives.
Stephen
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#11I wouldn't know, I use a pencil
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#12Whoa, the Vagaries of a pencil line
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#13I think it can... *LINK*
Alan DuBoff
>Derek,
I think my marking knife can do that. I would imagine the Blue Spruce marking knives can do it also, but I don't have one, I did check Chris Schwarz's out at the LN Hand Tool Event. In fact, I commented to Chris that I hadn't known that Dave made a thin blade, that is what has always prevented me from buying many of the marking knives on the market today.
I use a Stanley 10-049, they cost about $8-$10 at most hardware stores (like OSH or Home Depot) and you can buy replacement blades for about $2. The blade is about 1/32" thick and 1 3/4" long, so not sure it can fit inside that thin pin of yours or not, but it does the trick for most I've done.;-)
I have rounded the tip over, as Cosman shows on an older Stanley utility blade he uses. BTW, cuts leather pretty good also! :-)
Stanley 10-049 Pocket Knife
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#14Re: Can your marking knife ...
Charles
>No, it can't. That's why I cut dovetails pins first - I don't have to get a marking implement in a ridiculously small space.
While in the long run the US space program is obviously more successful I can't help but chuckle to remember that we spent a million or so (in 1960s dollars) to develop a ballpoint pen that would work in zero gravity.
The Russians just used pencils.
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#15I believe I can be more precise with a pencil
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>But we've had this discussion before :-)
DC
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#16Re: Can your marking knife ...
ThomD
>Thanks for explaining. I thought that with the tails done, Derek had finished and the joint was just a little loose...
Re: Can your marking knife ...
#17Re: I think it can...
tstock
>Yup. Blue Spruce with custom extended blade...or just use a piece of hacksaw blade after a little work on the grinder.



