Braces, augers and a question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>For the past few years I have been using a couple of Fray Spofford braces along with a set of Irwin augers that I picked up in new condition.
Recently I had the urge to try out a decent ratchet brace, and bought a couple of Yankees (10� and 8�) from George Langford (georgesbasement.com). And while I was at it, George put together a full set of Russell Jennings augers for me specifically for hardwood. I have never been happy with the Irwins here.
I have been in the process of sorting out my collection of auger bits and coming across a few interesting pieces I had nearly forgotten.
Such as these gimlets ..
and expanding bits, and �
I came across a set of augers I had bought some years ago on the advice of another. I put them aside as I was not that enthusiastic. By the time I was ready to use them, and a little more knowledgeable, I realized that they were probably not a good purchase as they lacked spurs. They are all in otherwise good condition, mostly by Matherson.
I had another look at them this evening. Now I believe that they were deliberately made without spurs as they are finished to well in that area (the RJ augers have a flat in that area as they transition. The Mathersons continue with a smooth curve).
So my thoughts turn to what they were designed to do. In the recesses of my memory I vaguely recall talk of �ship�s augers� and augers for end grain. What is a ship�s auger, why would one want to cut off spurs for end grain (if one indeed does so), and what is the purpose of these spurless augers (if anything other than a potential source of steel for boat anchors)?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#2Re: Braces, augers and a question
Neal in San Jose
>I don't know if the lack of a spur would make any difference in end grain, but I was told once that a spur-less auger would suffer less damage when it encountered a nail. Since there is no spur, you can't knock it off! I don't have any spur-less augers to try that with, so why don't you drill a hole thru a nail and report? LOL!
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#3Re: Braces, augers and a question
Chuck Nickerson
>Excellent question. I have accumulated 1000+ auger bits (don't ask) and there seem to be several different styles. I was planning to start a thread soliciting opinions about when each style is optimal.
If the edges of the bit cut, this style might be easier to steer. If the lead screw is smaller (shorter and narrower), it might give a hole with a flatter bottom. I've got two that are sharp (dozens dull), so it's time to experiment.
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#4Re: Braces, augers and a question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I have used this type of bit in doing heavy timber framing. A lot of older large augers have this style. The advantage of having a spur is that you get a very clean and crisp entrance hole, not necessary in rough work. Otherwise the performance is about the same.
Ship's augers we usually think of as long augers, in excess of 12" or so. End grain is hard to bore in because the lead screw cannot get a good grip on the end grain and so cannot help pull the auger in.
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#5Re: Braces, augers and a question
Ron In Sterling CT
>Derek: I have a copy of a 1951 Irwin Auger Bit Company brochure on "How to select, use, and care for BITS". They list four different boring heads for auger bits. They show a picture of their "5-Head" bit which is without spurs. Their definition is as follows: "Recommended for use in construction and repair work by railroads, shipyards and bridge builders. They do not show any other examples later on in their offerings in the catalogs. Hope this helps. Ron
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#6Re: Braces, augers and a question
ThomD
>Spurs are like the points on crosscut saws they define the tool track by cutting across the sidegrain fibers. All that the auger needs to do is split out the waste.
Spurs just create drag in endgrain, where one wants a square cut like a rip saw. I was trying to drill a big hole in endgrain once, with 3/8" drill. None of my fancy drills would work they just didn't have the penetration. A spade bit, that is essentialy a rotary scraper, cut like the endgrain rock maple was butter, though the bit did tend to drift.
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#7Re: Braces, augers and a question
Peter Evans
>Derek, Salaman's Dictionary has a lot of info on auger bits (also look under Bits for info on bits other than auger). These are Scotch pattern, and designed (as others have said) for rough work and hardwoods.
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#8Re: Braces, augers and a question
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>R Jennings got his patent two weeks before Gedge and his pattern took off, too bad, the Gedge/Cook pattern is a wonderful bit. Russell Jennings pattern included the projecting spurs or nickers to score the wood for a smooth entry hole. But it does limit the angle whereas the Cook/Gedge can be used at extreme angles.
Other manufacturers made twist augers and the non projecting spur was fairly common I have quite a few and they are not just for rough work. If you stop befor exiting and reverse the bit you get a clean hole. Properly sharpened augers don't need projecting spurs. And having them in small sizes means it is more than for rought work.
Those bits you pictured on the bottom are for softwood as they have coarse threads, (So you should just send them to me thanks, I will swap you for hardwood bits).
Most augers were supplied with four different points, coarse (for softwoods) medium and fine for hardwoods and some manufactories supplied them with non threaded pivot spurs.
Ships augers are just a size label. These twist bits do not cut endgrain well they are made to use cross grain, the gimblets will work better for that, but you want gouge, spoon or nose augers for endgrain.
And center bits are good for shallow holes but they wander.
The park where I work opened today and we are having a Mountain Man Rendezvous so I am 'camping' tonight. And I know this may sound strange but I am sitting behind my 1857 Cabinet & Chair shop on my laptop with a broadband card, something is not right.
Stephen
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#9Re: Braces, augers and a question
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Derek,
Just want to congratulate you on those two Yankee braces from George's basement! They're really in beautiful shape. Has anyone mentioned to you that those things are addictive? I think you'll find they're great screwdrivers, due to the light ratchet action (the ratchet won't back out the screw you're trying to start).
Good show!
Wiley
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#10Re: Braces, augers and a question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>...those two Yankee braces from George's basement! ...I think you'll find they're great screwdrivers...
Hi Wiley
Yes, I agree (as have so many galoots discovered). I have a 5" Stanley #73 (the throw actually measures 3 1/2") that I have tended to go-to for this purpose and for countersinking. That is what inspired my brace/driver in the WC tool comp.
I am really thrilled with the condition of these Yankees (and augers). Technically the 8" is a Yankee by North Bros.for the Bell System, and the 10" is a Stanley (2101A-10) - same design and construction - also made for the Bell System. The 10" had not been used or had minimal use.
Regards from Perth
Derek
(building cabinets for the new workshop this weekend)
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#11Re: Braces, augers and a question
Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.
>Not to put too fine a point on this, but, although ship augers are usually quite a bit longer than normal auger bits, I think the distinguishing aspect of ship augers is that they are L'Hommedieu pattern bits. L'Hommidieu patented a method of making augers before Irwin or Jennings. His first patent was issued in 1809 and last in 1854.
These bits have an open center and look like they were manufactured by wrapping the steel around a rod then pulling the rod out. A 1905 T B Rayl catalogeu that I have shows ship augers offered in sizes from 9" long to 34" long, and I have seen ship pattern augers with a T handle up to about 60". They were also offered with or without a lead screw.
Jim
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#12Re: Braces, augers and a question
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Wiley,
I saw two Yankees hang'n on the wall to the left of your bench in the picture you posted. I agree, they can be addictive. Best brace ever made. It's all about the ball bearings. Millers Falls made one similar (no.870) with ball bearings in the sweep handle and the pad handle. I think the Yankees even have the bearings in the chuck. I used to collect all kinds of braces. Four Yankees ended up in the crowd. Thankfully, all Stanley changed on the brace after buying out North Bros. was the model number and I think they dropped the red Yankee lettering on the pad handle? Anytime I see a yankee brace among someone's cache of tools, it's a good indication that, that guy knows good tools. They show up on eBay from time to time and always sell for a good price, especially when an 8" sweep one shows up.
Marv
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#13MF, Yankee, and Fray
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Marv,
Wow, I've never even seen a Millers Falls 870 series brace, only the 770 series. They're excellent, of course.
The Yankee braces have definitely taken off on ebay. Derek did well to buy from Dr. George, I suspect. They were already hot, and then after Chris Schwarz's article on them, they went to the moon. But as you say, it's a great brace and it only hurts once when you buy the right thing.
Here's one for you, since you collected braces. Some time ago I bought a mystery brace on Ebay. It's a John Fray, Bridgeport CT ratcheting brace. 6 inch sweep (3-inch throw). The thing is old as Methusaleh, and the model number has been worn off--it's all I can do to make out the Fray markings. It's inconceivable this ancient brace has a universal chuck, but for some reason it will get a good grip on whatever I put in there, like small drills or 1/4" hex-shank drivers. But what is it? The seller on ebay was never able to find a model number on the brace either, but he had a Fray catalog and said it looked to him like a Model 62.
The magic of the ratcheting Fray is that it is a 6" sweep that gets a grip. I have a couple of MF 734's w/ 6" sweep, but the 6" sweep was the only MF730 series brace that _did not_ have universal chuck. Anything without a tapered shank wiggles in it. Also, both my examples have wobbly heads--my theory is that the smaller braces were subject to abuse because people would press them into service to turn large augers and overtorque them. So the MF 6" sweeps have both a wiggle and a wobble.
Anyway, I've been on this vision quest to find another Fray 6" sweep like my other one, but so far no luck. What model could that brace be? Who's got a Fray catalog?
One other thing....Larry Williams once recommended Spofford chuck + gimlet bits as a great brace/bit combination. Fray Spofford's aren't hard to find, but I looked forever to try to find gimlet bits--no luck--and was bitten with envy to see Derek's. Good find, Derek!
Wiley
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#14Thanks and a bit more
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Wiley
My apologies for the gimlet pictures - I had no idea :)
Actually, I have a couple of spares and you are very welcome to them. They are literally a couple, so not enough to consider a set, but perhaps a way of finding out what the Fray+Gimlet combination is like. Please send me your address and they shall fly home to you.
To all, my thanks for all the welcome information. I have learned a thing or two.
Here are a couple more interesting pieces, Center Bits. These are a recent addition and I have yet to clean them up. Any opinion is always welcomed. These run from 1/8" through to 1 3/8".
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#15Re: Thanks and a bit more
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Derek,
I don't have a nice set like you have there but I do have quite a number of them. I like em for rough work and the best thing about them is, they are easy to sharpen. They are not meant for boring deep holes, too difficult to clear the hole as you drill.
Marv
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#16Re: MF, Yankee, and Fray *LINK*
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Wiley,
below is a link to a website that shows a #66 6" sweep that might be like yours.
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#17Re: MF, Yankee, and Fray
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Thanks a lot, Marv! I visit Sandy's site all the time, and it never occurred to me to run that down! My brace is a dead ringer for #103, in all metal-profiling and knurling details--except that the ratchet on mine is more closed, it's 'half-closed' like the Model 66.
Think I'll write Sandy and see if he has a Fray catalog he wouldn't mind searching through for me.
Thanks again, Wiley
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#18Thank you, Derek! I will write.
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>
Re: Braces, augers and a question
#19The geometry of center bits is simple
Chuck Nickerson
>enough that I'm hoping to make my own. It's on my project list for July 2008. By then I should have some metal experience from heat treating H&Rs.



