Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

Posts

The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#1

The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Bevel Up (BU) planes are marketed by both Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley (Veritas). Both offer at least one smoother and one jack plane. They have become very popular in recent years owing to their versatility in varying cutting angles. They are capable of rapidly altering bevel angles from a low 37 degrees to high angles in the 62-65 degrees range. Since low cutting angles are ideal for planing end grain, such as on shooting boards, and high angles are generally required to tame interlinked grain, the BU plane is a valuable tool in the workshop. This is particularly so for those who seek to obtain the widest range of uses from a handplane.

In spite of their potential, BU planes have come in for some criticism for their apparent inability or, at the least, significant difficulty in grinding a camber to the bevel when compared with the relative ease of doing so with bevel down (BD) planes. It is accepted that, owing to the geometry involved, a BU requires considerably greater camber ground to a blade to achieve the same profile of a cambered shaving than achieved by a BD plane.

Much of the article is a how-to-do-it for those learning new skills. But the important message I am passing on is how to camber these blades in what I believe to be the most efficient manner.

I originally posted the concept and experimentation about 9 months ago on Knots. This is a rewrite of that material.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#2

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades

Chris Friesen

>Nicely done. I like the pre-cambered initial grinding for the jack. Should vastly speed up the later phases.

I recently picked up the LV BU jointer and tried cambering the blade somewhat. It worked nicely, I think I need to go with a bit more curvature.

I do have one minor correction. Because the blade projects out past the template the radius of the curve of the blade will not be the same as the curve of the template...it will be increased by the projection of the blade past the template.

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#3

Derek -When Are You Going to Write a Book??

Chicago Bob

>Derek,

You are missing your natural calling in life - when are you going to publish a book on hand tools? I certainly would buy - I really enjoy reading your write-ups!

Chicago Bob

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#4

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades

paul womack

>I bet you could use the 5 1/2" radius template to make a 8" radius camber, and the 8" radius template to make a 5 1/2" radius camber :-)

BugBear

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#5

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>BB

Ha! You and I have gone around and around on this one so often. Your thesis is that I use handskill rather than the template to create the shape (camber). I guess that there are only two ways to prove this ...

.. we repeat it together ... either you come to me, or I go to you .. :)

The loser buys the beer!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#6

Re: well...

paul womack

>My partner very much enjoyed our last trip to Aus (Adelaide, Alice Spring, Cairns, Sydney) and WOULD like to see the west...

BugBear

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades *LINK*

#7

Re: The Secret to Cambering BU Plane Blades

ThomD

>Whew! That's the long was around. This is one case where even for someone who doesn't do CAD it is far easier to model it in real space and produce templates off a laser printer that can be ink transfered to your blades, or eyeballed. I understand the math, but it's so easy to just draw this stuff and foolproof I stopped reaching for the calculator even.