Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

Posts

Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#1

Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I moderately recently purchased one of your replacement irons for older Stanley block planes, and REALLY like it; I think I'm slowly going to switch over several planes.

I own and love a Stanley No. 52 spokeshave (set by guess, yes, but it's a lot lighter and more agile than the 151 style). Any chance that you'll be adding replacement spokeshave irons to your selection of O1 blades?

Hock sells them, but I've heard that Hock irons need flattening - and your irons come pretty doggone flat, saving time for actually working wood.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#2

I agree the 151 is a it more clumsy, but...

Alan DuBoff

>The adjustment is much nicer with the 2 thumb screws to adjust the blade. I find the other Stanleys more problematic to adjust.

Now that I have Boggs shaves, I will not be using the Stanleys as much. The Boggs shaves are really nice. I'll have to look at the replacement blades at LV, but I was looking at the Hock blades at the LN Hand Tool event in Oakland, but it was about $35 for the 151 replacement blade...so I figure I would just spend it on the Boggs.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#3

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

Rob Lee

>Hi Bill -

Be glad to have a look at them ...will let you know!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#4

Funny...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I haven't handled the Boggs shaves - afraid to touch them for fear they'll pick my pocket - but aren't they adjusted the same as the Stanley 51, by touch?

My biggest issue with the 151 is that I've been unable to turn tight inside corners, within the capacity of the sole, because the screws get in the way, trailing around the corner. Beyond that, though, I found they just feel better in my hands. Fortunately, hand tools come in diverse forms for all of us to find a personal favorite.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#5

Your right Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>All Boggs shaves are adjusted by touch. Somebody has develped this little device to mimic a 151-152 type adjustment for the Boggs shaves.

It would have the same drawbacks you stated about the 151.


img

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#6

Right tricky little doo-dad

Neal in San Jose

>Would it be possible to remove it from the spokeshave after the blade adjustment had been made? You'd leave it in place most of the time, but if it got in the way on a tight cabriole leg or whatever, you could take it off. That would be really slick.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#7

I believe so...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>It clamps on to the blade and the adjustment is made to the body of the shave. Once the blade is in place and clamped down, you could remove it (I think).

I haven't seen one of these in real life, they show up on Ebay every now and again and sell for around $40.00.

I figured it would be easy enough to make yer own.


img

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#8

Oh, great!

Neal in San Jose

>Another entry on the "to do" list. Looks like it would fun and easy to make.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#9

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Keeping in mind that a taste for the 51 is a minority taste - I think the same irons would work on a 51 and 151 (and 52, 152, etc.). Those of us, like me, who like the 51 could just grind off or otherwise remove the excess at the top of the iron if it got in the way.

For a bit last night, I was thinking, "I could just buy a replacement iron for a Lee Valley shave." That was until I checked the throat clearance - the 1/8" thick LV irons would leave negative chip clearance; they wouldn't fit through the mouth.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#10

Yes, they are except with 2 thumb screws

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

The Boggs is a bit different in that there are 2 thumb screws, and it just sits in your hand differently to adjust. The 51 only has a center screw to adjust the blade. I am not crazy about that.

I do like the way the 151 adjusts with the adjustable screws that do not require manual positioning.

The Boggs are the nicest shaves I've used, albeit not perfect, but do a nice job.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#11

Re: I believe so...

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi Scott,

Yes, it is indeed very easy, at least if you read DC's book volume III. He came up with the idea a while back and shows meticulously how to make it. Regularly someone sells the jig on ebay. If I'm right it is someone in Downunder.

It is easier though to watch the Boggs dvd on the chairmaker's toolkit. Brian demonstrates how easily his spokeshave is set in terms of seconds without any jig.

smartypants mode out again

Cheers ;-)

Marc

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#13

Re: Yes, they are except with 2 thumb screws

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I agree that the 51 is not easy to adjust. I live with that in exchange for its compactness.

some day, I want to make myself a spokeshave hangar that allows the shave to sit in full adjusted state at all times, so I can fuss only when I'm replacing a newly sharpened iron. And if Rob does decide to start making replacement irons, "newly sharpened" can be an infrequent state.

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

#14

Re: Rob Lee - replacement spokeshave irons?

Rob Lee

>Hi Bill -

We'll be doing both O1 and A2, but in a design that will fit both 51, and 151 shaves...

Blades will be .094" thick, as any thicker, and it may give problems withthe mouth.

Have re-designed the back edge a bit to dock the corners, and have a straight section at the blade back (parallel to the edge) to help with some honing fixtures...

Will let you know when we have 'em...

Cheers -

Rob