Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Plane info needed

Posts

Plane info needed

#1

Plane info needed

Stuart Hough

>I have a line on a Stanley 4 1/2. I need to know if slight pitting on the sole will cause problems in use. Does pitting typically cause scrathes on the planed surface? If so I'll pass on this one. Thanx in advance for the advice.

Re: Plane info needed

#2

Re: Plane info needed

Bob Hackett

>Slight pitting shouldn`t cause any problems.Just be sure to get all the rust/residue out of the pits.

I have 2 planes that work just fine with heavy pitting.I just lapped the soles and put them to work.

MB

Re: Plane info needed

#3

If it's slight pitting...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>It won't be a prodlem as Bob stated. It may cause problems around the mouth of the plane. Check the around mouth carefully.

Re: Plane info needed

#4

Re: Plane info needed

Tony - Memphis

>My #4 came from the factory (many many years ago) with inclusion/vapor bubbles/whatever holes in the sole and they don't seem to be a problem. Mine also has several pretty deep scratches that don't effect it. And don't forget the C models with grooves in them.

Tony

Re: Plane info needed

#5

Agree

David Miller from Iowa

>With Bob, Scott and Tony. On my soap box again - we all tend to obsess over the merits of super flat soles and razor sharp cutters, but for regular work (not curly, exotic grain) a $5 plane decently tuned is just fine. I used to give my young boys crappy planes to "play" with - I was over at my (now 24 year old) son's house and he was effectively planing a door using a rusty Stanley 220 plane I threw his way in 1997 instead throwing in the garbage. I had honed the cutter edge for 30 seconds just so he would stay away from my good planes. He was trimming up a fir door and doing nicely with that same edge - a little tearout, but it worked. Maybe he will get a better plane at Christmas. Amazing what kids save.

Re: Plane info needed

#6

It's interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Some people pay extra for corrugated plane soles, which are essentially really long pits machined in on purpose, and then folks worry about pitting...

The key is the surface that touches the wood, and, regardless of pitting or not, getting a smooth surface touching the wood is a matter of some sandpaper, a flat surface, and a few minutes. I agree with Scott Burr that you want to knock down any rust that will encourage further deterioriation, but even a coating of wax will help with that; or oil; or one of those compounds that combines with the rust to form a non-rusting ferrous (or ferric, not sure) coating.