Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Posts

Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#1

Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is a bureau made in Utah in the 1860's, of pine and painted and grained to look like mahogany.

All of the drawer fronts were treated like this one. Note how really tight the joints are, there is not a space for a hair, they are so tight. Well maybe it is the wedges, which appear to be original.

Stephen


img

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#2

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The inside of the drawer front, didn't quite stop at the score line. But then again it is not on the money side. The drawer sides are very thin on this example, probably an English Craftsman.

Stephen


img

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#3

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>And I have never seen the back of a drawer done with half blind dovetails, this bureau had all the drawers treated in this unique manner.

Stephen


img

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#4

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Dean J in MN

>You're not suggesting these overcuts are grouped in the "not pretty" class are you?

Every 18th C. drawer I've ever seen (granted not an all-inclusive sample size) have these same overcuts.

-Dean

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#5

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Are you saying a wedge is driven into each pin? Do you think that was the way it was originally made or fixed when the pin shrank?

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#6

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dean,

I appologize, I was attempting to be funny and obviously it failed. No, I have seen overcut on drawer fronts on a break front secretary made by Thomas Chippendale in the collection of the National Park Service.

I was speaking of the wedged front dovetails (not that there is anything wrong with that). I overcut my blind dovetails All the time, the scribe line is for the chisel not the saw.

Stephen

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#7

Re: question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

All were originally wedged, except the top and bottom pins. There is original paint residue over the tops of the wedges. Other joints in the piece were tight.

There was some shrinkage and that telegraphed through the finish especially on the bone escutcheon plate, painted over didn't shrink and the surrounded wood did.

But all of the drawer joints were original and in tact. The repairs, replacing the worn off wood was done to the drawers as necessary, but they were all still solid. I did remove the nails holding the loose drawer bottoms, reposition and renail the drawers to make them tight.

Stephen

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#8

German wedged dovetails

Jim in VA

>The Winterthur museum in Delware has several chests made with wedged dovetails. I was told it was a German tradition and these chests, made in Penna., were made by German immigrants. I suspect that other cultures made use of wedged dovetails too.

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#9

Looks like an imposture, painted wrong color???:-/

Alan DuBoff

>Even given the fact that the painting could be a bad imposture, I like the contrast with the wedges, albeit it seems like a lot of (detail) work, that is what craftsmanship is all about, right? *grin*

I must add the painting looks excellent on the front of the drawer, they got the brush marks under control nicely, and in fact did an excellent job at the grain and/or pattern, which resembles a book matched paint job. This was common for artisans to excercise both their dominant and weak sides of their painting skills...so I've heard...

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#10

Re: Looks like an imposture, painted wrong color??

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is what the piece looked like when I finished. I did very little other than to bring back the original finish, less than 1% inpainting, some knobs are new.

Stephen


img

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#11

I figured :-/ it was bookmatched paint!

Alan DuBoff

>Whoa, that is one swell piece...wedgies and all...man-o-man, that is one sweet orignal paint job, in the book matched flavor yet...oh my...

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

#12

Re: Dovetails, some are not pretty and some are

chet

>Stephen,

For what its worth. I was in Beaufort, SC, last month and the LOML and I wondered into an antique store. While admiring the design and proportion of the pieces--and the construction, of course--there was a three draw bow front dresser that had the exact type of dovetail. At first I thought it was maker's fix to a lose tail but realized that all the pins had them and concluded that it was a design feature. The one wedge that had not aged quite as much as the others made the joint a wee bit more interesting. The info on the piece said it was from CT and was a companion piece to a tall chest on chest. The other piece did not have the same wedging of the dovetails and I assumed a different cabinet maker from the same shop produced that piece.