Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

1811 Drawer Revisited

Posts

1811 Drawer Revisited

#1

1811 Drawer Revisited

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I timed myself making a drawer to Joel's specifications this morning. I got 1 hour, 57 minutes. This was somewhat less time than I had suggested last week, but the drawer, at 2 X 9 X 12, is really shallow. Not much planing and not much dovetailing. I guess I could make more than two dozen in a week.

A lot of people wondered how many drawers they were making at a time. My time would have been faster if I had made a quantity. I think that in 1811 they got paid the same amount per piece whether they were making two or two dozen. I think they just made more money when they were doing a large number; sometimes they got lucky. This does go against our old 20th century labor notions.

I often do a sample of something for one of my customers and then a few months later do 50 or 100 of them. For the sample I usually charge about 1 1/2 times the quantity price, even though it might take four times as long. It is just easier to make money when you are doing volume.

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#2

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

joel

>Thanks for taking the time to make a drawer. And I would agree that if you only did drawers, or did a dresser full of them you would be faster. The specification calls for 4" or shallower. WAs this by hand all with power and hand tools?

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#3

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I just do hand work, Joel. I do have an electric glue pot. I let the glue heat up while dovetailing and grooving and I made the bottom while the glue set. I was then able to plane the sides flush. I would normally wait a little longer to plane the sides.

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#4

Classical drawer fitting - maybe 1-1.5 hrs longer

Andrew F in Australia

>HI Warren,

The time sounds right.

The hassle in fitting a drawer to the opening is:

1) Planing the drawer front to exactly match the drawer opening, with about a 1 degree splay on the drawer so that it jams about 2/3 of the way in. The drawer opening is rarely square.

2) Planing the drawer sides to fit exactly in the opening.

3) Planing the drawer back to have the same profile as the drawer front, but about 1/2mm / 1/64" smaller in width so that the drawer does not jam.

4) Gluing the drawer up so that it fits into the opening. (once again, rarely square.)

5) Final fitting of the drawer so that it is a neat fit.

This takes about the same time as making the drawer.

It all depends whether the tradesman in Joel's reference were making a drawer to fit a carcase they'd built, or were just making drawers and nothing else as piece work.

CHeers,

ANdrew

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#5

Re: Classical drawer fitting - maybe 1-1.5 hrs lon

Joel

>My guess is that the pricing is for one of a series of drawers made to fit a specific carcass.

Here is a scan of part of the first drawer table. the table covers a wide range of sizes in increasing complexity and is followed by 3 pages of notes and correction multipliers. Then come tables for drawers in curved and elliptical work. The case I originally asked about is the simplest on the upper left.


img

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#6

The real question

wilbur

>How long would it take to make the same drawer with power tools? My bet is that it's not much different.

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#7

Re: Classical drawer fitting - maybe 1-1.5 hrs lon

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Andrew, there are lots of schemes for fitting drawers. I have used several over the years, but certainly never took an hour. I never suspected that workers in 1811 took an hour. I would be surprised if Joel found that workers were paid a shilling to fit a drawer. "Classical drawer fitting" sounds like a 20th century idea.

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#8

Drawer fitting

Andrew F in Australia

>hi Warren,

I'm trained according to the accepted trade practise. An apprenticeship is 4 years.

I'll go hunting on the internet for a link to show how it was/is done in higher end work. It's the same as above.

As Richard Jones said in the previous discussion, getting drawers fitting properly is fine, but a swing upwards in humidity makes the drawer bind badly.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#10

thanks Joel, appreciate the info.

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#12

Re: Drawer fitting

Joel

>I'm not sure draw fitting in the early 19th century was considered a big deal. It certainly isn't in the book I don't think. Also drawers were made of pre-sawn, air dried, highly stable, specific drawer stock for furniture which at the time was largely kept in unheated rooms in the same country that the furniture was made in. So my guess is at least some of the modern criteria for fitting drawers wasn't needed until the 1870's or thereabouts.

Re: 1811 Drawer Revisited

#13

Re: Classical drawer fitting

Adam Cherubini

>Andrew,

Here in the US, some of the words you use, evoke different notions. "Classical" and "apprentice" sound like 18th century traditions. Classical music is typically 18th c music here (and some 19th c). We think of Mozart as classical, perhaps because they made a Hollywood movie about him.

18th c drawers are not fit particularly well. I see the top of the sides rounded over and often relieved from the drawer front. I don't think they wanted the sides to compete with the fit up of the front when closed. I also don't think they put the sorts of things we put in drawers. And they may not have even used them the way we use them.

So I think "classical" drawer making or fitting is fundamentally unlike 18th c, even early 19th c anglo-american drawer making. The Philadelphia Museum of Art, in addition to recently publishing an 18th c price book, recently unearthed evidence of a professional drawer maker living and working in the city. I think the opening dimensions were given and he supplied the drawers to fit.

What I do, btw, is fit the drawer front (this is for a flush front drawer) to the carcass. Then, when chopping the pins, I put my chisel in the scribe line. This causes an undercut here and proud pins. The result is a tight-ish drawer front, and eased drawer sides.

The other thing I do is when I cut the front, I push it all the way back to see if the carcass is straight or not and where and how I screwed up.

Lastly, I've been through the exercise Joel is undertaking before. Bottom line: Joel's right. These guys were fast, faster than us, and there is much we don't understand about how they worked so quickly.

Adam