Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Panther Head Saw

Posts

Panther Head Saw

#1

Panther Head Saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi folks,

Below is a picture of a very rare find. The saw doesn't belong to me. It is owned by a friend of mine in New Hampshire. He sent it to me to be reconditioned. He wants to sell it. I have reconditioned it while being mindful of retaining most of the aged look. I retained the dark surface that you find just below the rust. To my pleasent surprise, when removing the thick rust a nearly perfect etch came to life, including the detailed head of a panther. It is so bold, you can feel it when rubbing your fingers over it. The blade is 28" long with 5PPI rip profile and has a full nib.

The handle is in amazingly good condition, with no breaks or cracks or chips. It retains it's original finish.

According to those who try to keep track of this rare treasure, there are only about 35 of these saws known to still exist. This saw brings the count up to 36.

While doing some research, apparently these saws were made with different carvings on the handles. The drawing shown with the Woodrough patent has the same carving as is on this saw. Some of the handles were wheat carved.

As some of you might know, at least one of these saws has sold for as much as $5000.00, right up there with the No.1 Stanley plane.

Marv


img

Re: Panther Head Saw

#2

Re: Panther Head Saw

wayne anderson

>Nice job on the saw. Just the right amount of cleanup...for my taste anyway. Makes it look like it was well taken care of, not over-restored. -wayne

Re: Panther Head Saw

#3

Darrell in Oakville

Re: Panther Head Saw

Darrell in Oakville

>Marv,

You say there is a good etch on that saw?

I'm sure I am not alone when I ask "Pictures please?"

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: Panther Head Saw

#4

Nicker Nib, right?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Panther Head Saw

#5

Re: Panther Head Saw More pics-slide show *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Darrell

Go to the link below and you can see more pictures, including the etch. Hope this works. If it doesn't, email me.

Marv


Panther Saw slide show.

Re: Panther Head Saw

#6

Re: Panther Head Saw More pics-slide show

Neal in San Jose

>Now that's cool! Thanks so much, Marv. Good thing I'm not a good carver - I found a non-panther W & M with a good blade and crummy handle on eBay a while back, and I thought.....

Re: Panther Head Saw

#7

Re: Panther Head Saw

Andrew Lunn

>Awesome job, Marv! It's quite a responsibility restoring/conserving a saw like that, and I think you rose to the occasion wonderfully! It looks great, has great patina, and it cuts like a champ. Your friend will surely be very pleased.

Re: Panther Head Saw

#8

Re: Panther Head Saw

David Miller from Iowa

>Nice saw. Curious though, what is your reference for 36 known and $5,000 value?

I have seen probably 10 of these in my travels (I don't have one) and it seems like 36 known is a low number.

Ashley Kennedy of CATS (a Chicago splinter cell of MWTCA) came across one of these a few months ago and sold it on eBay for, I can't remember exactly, but it was something like $400 - wasn't as nice though.

Thanks, David

Re: Panther Head Saw

#9

Re: Panther Head Saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

I ran across the information regarding the number of existing saws and a mention of one saw that sold for $5000 while doing some googling. I'm sure all the various saws sold at prices all up and down the scale. Selling on eBay is often times a crap shoot. Most of the time, the right people are not searching eBay at the right time. The saw you see here, in my opinion is about as good as they get. I say "about" because there are no doubt some in better condition. I saw a real junker sell on eBay last year for nearly $800. The blade had been filed down to a point, no etch and the handle was cracked and broken.

Regarding the number of existing Panther Heads, I read about a member of the MWTCA did a survey in an attempt to locate as many as he could. He located about 35. There is no way to know for sure just how many there are laying around that are not accounted for and never will be. The 35 has to be a very rough estimate. Even though the number is probably higher, the saw remains one of the most saught after saws that we know of.

It was a pleasure to work on this saw and a rare opportunity.

Marv

Re: Panther Head Saw

#10

Re: Panther Head Saw

Todd Hughes

>I don't know where they come up with 36 either I have seen a good many of them at shows and on ebay and i know for a fact that 3 have been found with in 50 miles of me [none by me but Im waiting] and would not be in on that count. In my experance seeing them really sell as opposed to some guy putting a big price on them most go for under a $1,000..Few years ago I passed up a nice one priced at $400 at a large tool show...I believe the one that sold for $5,000 may have been the small panel saw that had belonged to a friend of mine and was sold at a tool auction after his death. I believe it's high price was due to it being in a rare size....Todd

Re: Panther Head Saw

#11

What would be a rare size? 28" maybe?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Panther Head Saw

#12

Kinda surprised at you Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I figured you do some wheat carving on it and paint it John Deere green...

Nice job on the restoration!

Re: Panther Head Saw

#13

Re: Kinda surprised at you Marv...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott....

Well, don't think I didn't give it some serious thought! But then I didn't want this thread to continue down off the page. I've learned that not everybody likes wheat carving and John Deere green on their old tools. Go figure......

Sometimes we need to do as little as possible on these old treasures but still attempt to improve it's appearance such as bringing out the etch by removing the rust and making it functional, however subjective this might be. My preference is a clean and functional tool. It's like bring it out of a coma.

Howz your weather down there in those beautiful redwoods?

Thanks for the compliment...

Marv

Re: Panther Head Saw

#14

8^)...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Weather's great, but it's going to cool down for the weekend. That's a good thing because I've got 3/4 of an acre to weed wack :^(

Re: Panther Head Saw

#15

What? No scythe?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Come on, Scott - this is the hand tool forum. At least you should lie about how you're going to knock down those weeds.

Tried a scythe once - have to admit I understand gas-powered weed frighteners, but with the cost of gas now and carbon footprint issues, maybe I should get the scythe out again.