We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm looking to get my first spokeshave. Right now I can see me using it mostly for convex shapes/outside curves, but in the future ,who knows. Since I'm from Canada, my only real option is Lee Valley. Here's the problem. They have 3 different styles, flat, round and concave. I know they're made for specific functions, but if I were to get just one, which one would be the most versatile? In other words, which one should I buy?
There's no such thing as just one spokeshave.They're like peanuts.You can't just have one. I'd recommend you get the LV hardware kit(LV#05P33.30)and make your own. It's an inexpensive way to start and you'll learn alot more about the tool in the process.Once you get started you're going to want another.On ebay,Stanley 151s are pretty common.You might want to try one of those also.---Jack
>If you don't have a real specific use in mind, then I think a flat soled shave is your first choice. About the only thing it won't do is an inside curve, and it can even do large radius inside curves if you set it a little rank. The round bottom (convex) shave will do the inside curves, but using it on straight surfaces you miss the larger area of registration. By that I mean it does not naturally register the cutting edge to the work, you have to do that by feel/experience, while the flat shave gives you good feedback on when it is in the cutting position. The concave shave is handy when doing round work, but it's more a luxury than necessity. It's perfectly workable to use the flat shave set finely to work down to pretty small facets around the work, then use a properly shaped scraper or just sandpaper to take care of the rest if the work demands it.
I got the LV set of three at a good price when they first introduced the concave shave, and I love them.
>I think you need to know a little bit about what you are going to be doing before you can chosse just one. And like Jack said one is really not enough. I started with a Stanley 151 which is great for flat edges or roughing out a not too curved surface but its not so great for doing spindles and such because of the steeper blade angle. For that type of work I use an old Stanley #85 Razor Edge spokeshave which you can find on e-bay or form old tool dealers. They have avery low blade angle and are great for chair work and such.
As far as Lee Valley being your only choice I think many of the companies down here will gladly ship to you in Canada. And I wouldn't assume that new is necessarily the best way to go. I think if you were to try a Razor edge spookeshave you might forget about one of these new ones they are amazing to use. Also check out Dave's shaves I have one and it is very nice shave as well. He also sells kits last I knew.
>...it would be one of my Bailey 53s, with a flat sole and an adjustable mouth. Over the years I have found this tool to be a little tricky to use -- kinda like dancing -- but very versatile. The adjustable front sole can be raised up with a flick of the thumb on the adjustment knob for a heavier cut or a change to a concave radius. After a while you figure out how to do it in real time if you're working on a piece with constantly changing curves, as I tended to find myself doing in the good old days when I did architectural woodworking and custom furniture for a living.
You can find them at flea markets and tool dealers for not a lot of money. I never paid more than $25 for one.
>I have the three LV's and I have never been as successful using the curved varieties as the flat one. However, there is high angle and low angle flat vvariety. The low angle is nice for end grain but I have had it pull big splinters when using on straight grain. For legs and the like the typical Stanley is best in my hands. A Spoke shave is something that can be bought used with good success. Someone here will know the proper Stanley number for it and there are probably dozens on Ebay.
I own several metal spokeshaves, though I will NOT argue that my collection is comprehensive. My hands-down favorite is a No. 52 Stanley (like the 51, a flat sole but with straight handles). You adjust the blade by guess, which takes a little finicking at first, but if you store it intelligently, you don't have to change it once you've set it. It's more compact than the 151, which has adjusting nuts like the LV shaves, and thus can get into tighter inside curves; and it handles better - sports car in the Miata (or Frogeye Sprite) style rather than sports coupe.
Commoner, and pretty much the same, is the Stanley 51, which has curved rather than straight handles. I've linked to a current auction up in the Great White North (ha! Ontario, the Riviera of Canada). Currently I'd buy one of those if I couldn't easily find a 52, though I'd then watch for a 52.
I paid, if I recall correctly, US$1 for my 52 10-15 years ago, and $5 for a 51 more recently (as someone said, like peanuts). I gave away my Record 151. I have yet to use my 53, but keep it because people tell me it's a good tool, and I'm waiting for time to experiment.
All this is on the verge of convincing me not to order the LV shaves that have been on my list recently...
A usage tip: My impulse on picking up my first spokeshave years ago was to grip the handles like motorcycle hand grips and push. From a Fine Woodworking article (back when it was better than now), I learned another grip that works better, at least for me, on high angle metal shaves: lightly grip the body of the shave on each side of the blade between thumb (in back) and index finger (in front...but that's kind of obvious). Use the handles as convenient places to rest the remaining fingers. Do your pushing with thumb, controlling angle of attack with thumb and index finger. Easier to show than to explain, but I find it makes for great sensitivity in use.
One thing is obvious from all these responses,there is no one spokeshave.I think they're alot like screwdrivers. You really need more than one to handle different shaving jobs.I agree with Pam. You really need more info.Good luck and have fun with it.---Jack(always glad to add to the confusion)
>I'll throw in my two cents since I am only a step ahead of you. To qualify my input, I use my spokeshave to make cabriole legs and a few other curved legs. I bought a nice used 151 (flat sole) from Ebay (before Lee Valley started making theirs). That's all I have needed so far. Again, I mostly use it for cabriole legs and the like. The Lee Valley shave looks really nice. I'm sure you will enjoy it. Not sure what you have in mind, but there is something very satisfying to me about shaving a nice cabriole leg. Enjoy your new toy! Seems like Lee Valley even offers a kit that allows you to make your own handles. No need for a lathe - find a nice chunk of special wood and shape it with your new shave!
>Or it may just be that there are lots of different spokeshave possibilities, but many of them will get the job done. Woodworkers, like many folks in the developed world who use tools (in which category I include those who sew, knit, cook, garden, fix cars, play music, etc.), can easily slip into the "what's the perfect tool?" game. Ultimately, you'll learn to use what you get. Maybe, within a range starting above dreadful, you should just get one and start the learning. I like Snap-On automotive tools, but can't afford them (slowly building up a collection from garage sales). But guess what? My cars seem to run just as well when I use Craftsman wrenches to maintain them; and the occasional SK, Thorsen, and even "Master Mechanic" tool that has crept in over the years to fill a gap seems to work.
I am reminded that Huddie Ledbetter (Leadbelly), perhaps the finest of the 12-string-guitar blues artists, played a Stella guitar, widely considered in my youth in the 1960's to be a mediocre guitar (and 12-strings, with all that string tension, test a guitar's sturdiness like mad). And Ornette Coleman started out making very interesting jazz playing a plastic saxophone. Don't know if he still plays it; haven't kept up.
Another subject: yes, buy a flat sole spokeshave as your first one (maybe your only one - you don't HAVE to own lots of them, in spite of what people are saying here). I made the mistake of buying a round sole (curved front to back) as my first shave, and almost swore off them before buying a flat sole shave. The curved sole requires incredible finesse to use properly. As to the concave shave - cutting edge curves as if to wrap around a dowel - it's a specialized tool, useful for what it does, but not your best first choice.
>I can understand and relate to the confusion, and you're lucky noone has brought up drawknives yet.
To me, spokeshaves are a really odd tool, somewhere in between a plane and a carving gouge. There are a lot of different sizes and shapes, and it's hard to know what you really need. Bill made a good point about buying something cheaper and used until you know what you need.
Chuck makes a pretty good point about buying used, that it can be a crapshoot. If you've bought used planes before, I think you'll be fine. If you know how to sharpen tools, you'll figure it out. The old Stanleys are fine. Lee Valley is OK. I think I prefer the L-N Boggs shave over the Veritas. It's a little trickier to learn how to adjust it... the key is to adjust it in use, so you can lock it down when it's cutting how you want it to... but that's just my personal preference.
If you're buying one for a specific task, it's pretty easy to figure out what you need. If you're buying one because you think you ought to have one, well, it's a tough question to answer. Different people have different reactions. But it's a fair amount of coin to fork over for something without a defined purpose.
Really, you can make a convex surface with a lot of different tools. I was taught to do a lot of the work on cabriole legs with a plain, 1" chisel, and it honestly works just fine, and gave me a really good feel for how wood cuts, or doesn't cut, and what it feels like when it's not going to be cooperative. Since then I've learned a lot about drawknives, and I like them, too. But when it comes to using, or buying a spokeshave, much like carving tools, it really helps to know in advance what you're going to be using it for.
A bevel up shave, like the veritas, or like one that you'd make from a kit, is similar in usage to a drawknife, with a depth limiter, and they're a lot of fun to make and use. But they can be quirky, and if you run them the wrong way on the grain, they can really make a hell of a mess. I made my first one from the article in the Charlesworth book, V. 1, and I think the article is pretty comprehensive. If you have time to kill, and you're looking for a pretty straightforward tool to build for yourself, I'd recommend giving it a try.
A flat bottom, bevel down shave is a decent, all around tool. It can substitute in some cases for a bullnose plane, it'll help chamfer long, straight edges, and it'll handle a lot of other odd spots that you can't really get to in other ways. And it'll work enough like a plane that it won't feel completely alien. From there, you'll be able to figure out if spokeshaves are something you really want to sink your teeth into.
It's easy to get confused, there's a lot of different versions of the same thing. I've seen a few different kinds of wooden versions, round bottom, round bodied, different handle shapes and sizes... There's even a bunch of Stanley spokeshaves with two blades... one flat soled, and one with a concave grind on the blade... that can be a whiz to use, or a bear to tune up.
I think spokeshaves are pretty useful in normal cabinet shops, and for some kinds of furniture. But they really do shine when you're doing something like building a chair or a stool. Shaping, carving, deviating from the plain, predictable flat surface. Like I said, they're akin to carving tools. But there are a lot of carving tools, too, and some of them are very specialized, and highly useless if you're doing anything other than what they're designed to do.
If you really need a spokeshave of a specific shape or configuration, the work will tell you. In the meantime, I think a simple flat bottomed shave will take care of most day to day stuff that you'll run into.
>but buying new tools is a gamble, too - but with bigger coin. All of us have the experience of buying something that we thought we'd use often that sits. One of mine cost me $200, and I rarely use it (it's got a power cord, so I won't mention it here).
Buying used in person is better, but not all of us have the time or inclination to haunt garage sales (I do, but recognize that everyone's preferences vary). Asking/thinking about what to look for and ask about (a standard eBay buyer's question for hand tools should be, "Are there any cracks?") is important, and, yes, you don't always know about that up front. But how to learn if you don't start?
>It's sure easy to say "get the LV flat." That's what I did first, then proceeded to buy a few more, All of them worked, got my jobs done; but then I saw the Boggs dvd and learned some tricks and basics about spokeshaves, drawknives, and horses. I was just trying to save Warren some time and money, Kees.
>I would be real happy if my "mistaken buys" were only $200.00. I've got one of them still in its original box. Bought to do a "run" of antique windows...but this is too off topic.
>I have 6 shaves. The workhorse is a Stanley (Record) 151. 90% of the time I use it in a draw knife style by pulling it towards me, I seem to find better control. It is set for a fairly moderate cut to hog off quickly to a general shape.
Then I either pickup the Stanley 53 as Ellis discussed, set for light whisper thin shavings, or an L-N Boggs flat shave ( a Christmas present from my wonderful wife) set the same. If I am working long hours shaping chair parts the Boggs design (longer wood handles) are more comfortable in my old hands. The 53 isfine but look for cracks at the sides of the mouth as that indicates it has been abused and will break sooner than later.
The other three are a round bottom Kunz (required much tuning) only used on tight convex curves, a Kunz concave (poor but kept as a it was a gift not from my wife), and a Veritas Boggs concave shave used when I am rounding spindles, etc.
Get a Flat bottomed one first sharpen and tune it. Practice to develop the touch and feel to know how you best like to hold the tool. A 151 looks like it was designed to be pushed but works very well pulling. If you are using a shaving horse it will be used in the pull mode.
>If you want a metal spoke shave go and buy an assortment of old Stanleys, shouldn't cost you more then $5 - $15 each for good ones. These are very simple tools and not much can go wrong with them. Check to see if the casting isn't broke, mouth isn't chipped and blade isn't sharpened up. That is about it.. Doesn't require you to be some tool genius...most would fall under the "DUH!" catorgory of knowledge.
....I would pick up an old antique wooden body shave as well. Check that the blade tangs are tight , blade not sharpened up and no damage to the body.
When I started out using spoke shaves never occured to me that I needed to buy a new one because for some reason I couldn't figure out how to buy and use an old one. I just paid a couple bucks for one, sharpened the blade and then went to work using it. Being a slow head I never knew I couldn't do this or that I would have problems.....Todd