Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Column Orders *LINK*

Posts

Column Orders *LINK*

#1

Column Orders *LINK*

John Hoffman

>I was researching period furniture and came across Adam's A&M column on Classical Column Orders. Adam came up with a spread sheet but I am confused on how to use the numbers to figure out how wide vs the height of an item.

Has anyone (or Adam) tell me if you are using say the Tuscan, how is the number "11" used?

Thanks

John


http://www.popularwoodworking.com/blog3/Classical+Column+Orders.aspx

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#2

Re: Column Orders

Peter Evans

>John, from my read - for a column of height 11', the diameter of the shaft (the middle round part of the column) will be 1' at its maximum diameter, ie at the bottom of the shaft.

Cheers

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#3

Re: Column Orders

John Hoffman

>Ok, have you looked into the spread sheet Adam did showing additional calculations? Can you shed some light on that?

Thanks

John

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#4

Re: Column Orders

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Do more research. The illustration is incorectly labled. the part labled 'shaft' includes the base and capital while the part labled 'capital' looks to be a frieze and the part labled 'base' is some sort of plinth. Also a doric collumn has no base. If you want some formulas on proportions look for translations of Andrea Palladio's writings.

Robin

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#5

Re: Column Orders

Adam Cherubini

>Robin,

You're correct. My mistake. The labels should read from top to bottom, Entablature, Column, Pedestal. Within the column there's a Base and a Capital, typically half a module high each. I don't use these. I'm sorry I have been using the wrong terms.

Otherwise the divisions and numbers are correct (at least as far as Thomas Chippendale is concerned). If you move one of those lines, the numbers would change (and become less helpful).

Adam

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#6

Re: Column Orders

Adam Cherubini

>When the item is a leg for example, the masculine Tuscan form would have the max width of the leg 1/11 of its height. So for a 30" high dining table, a Tuscan leg would be a stout 2-3/4" thick.

In the excel spread sheet, you can just take the values given for the Shaft diameter and multiple them by the height of your leg or table or whatever and you'll get the max width of that leg. They are percentages of height.

Here's the thing: Chippendale used the shaft diameter to determine everything. And I think that makes sense when you are actually building columns. But I look at it the other way round. I start with height, then see what percentage of the overall height the thickness or pedestal or entablature is. That's what's on the spread sheet. If you follow my thinking, it is a little time saver. I've recorded the key dimensions of the different orders and done a little arithmetic for you. And in the resulting percentages you can see the gender relationships a bit clearer.

Adam

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#7

Re: Column Orders

Tony - Memphis

>There is also a good article by Mack Headley on this subject. It was in FWW many years ago. You probably find it on their site and I think it was in one of their book series. I've been kind of fascinated with the whole proportion thing, but I also wonder how much there is too it. Who used it and who didn't? How strictly was it applied or interpreted? Interesting stuff.

Tony - who's proportions are all wrong!

Re: Column Orders *LINK*

#8

Re: Column Orders

John Hoffman

>Adam, thank you. That was exactly what I was looking for.

Can you shed light here or in A&M et al, which order was used on what form of piece, federal, queen ann, etc?

If not here I look forward to reading it somewhere.

Thanks

John