Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Workbench top questions

Posts

Workbench top questions

#1

Workbench top questions

Tom Ryan

>I'm going to make a small workbench, mostly for hand tool usage, like sawing, chopping dovetails and mortises, and planing. I'd like to make the top out of sheet goods, both to minimize my time and to gain the stability of sheet goods. I'll make the top about 1.5 inches thick.

My first thought was to use 2 layers of Baltic Birch plywood. It's strong, stable, and nice to work with. But I've read several places that plywood is rather bouncy. (This makes sense to me, since I once built a clavichord with a thin birch plywood soundboard.)

My second thought was to use 2 layers of MDF. This is supposed to bounce less. It's cheap and stable, but I don't really like the stuff, and I worry about strength and sagging.

My third thought was to laminate different sheet goods, such as .5" BB ply, then .5" MDF, then another .5" BB. Has anybody tried something like this? To what extent will the MDF dampen the bouncy feel?

Then I thought about putting sound-deadening sheetrock in the middle of a sandwich of sheet goods. Any experience or opinions?

Thanks in advance for any advice you can give me on this!

Re: Workbench top questions

#2

Re: Workbench top questions

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

>Tom,

I built the top of my bench with three layers of MDF sandwiched between top and bottom layers of plywood (all 3/4" thick) and topped it with a sacrificial layer of 1/4" tempered hardboard. It is plenty heavy and stiff, but over twice as thick as what you're planning. It is also very stable. I'd think about making your top a little thicker if you want stiffness from relatively thin man-made materials, maybe 1/2" ply skins over a 3/4" MDF core. You could also go with a torsion box if stiffness is a prime concern. The outfeed table for my table saw is 1/4" ply skin over a grid made of 1/2" ply: it's extremely stiff, and quite light-weight, too.

Cheers!

Jim

------WebKitFormBoundarylYTZotKEr+GnGLDI

Re: Workbench top questions

#3

check this bench out (used MDF) *LINK*

VTAndy4

>I hope it's OK to link to another forum (if not, mods, please remove this post, my apologies)...

This bench was built by a goblin north of the border; every time I look at it, it brings a smile to my face.

-Andy


Farfadet's bench

Re: Workbench top questions

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: check this bench out (used MDF)

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That is very cool. Nice dovetailing too.I wonder if my wife would mind one like that in the living room if I put a lamp on it when not in use.---Jack

Re: Workbench top questions

#5

Re: check this bench out (used MDF)

Walt Turpening NE Tenn.

>For handtool work mass is very important. The bench needs to be stable and not move as you work. So make or buy a typical maple bench top and a heavy base. I made an oak and mulberry top on an oak base in typical long narrow style and then built a tall (36" high) 20" square top bench for more mallet and gouge carving.

The tall one has a 2" thick maple and cherry glued up top on a 4x4 base and 100 pounds of lead shot (trap shooting days) hung on the cross brace near the bottom. Total weight of about 200 pounds. It generally stays put no matter how wild I get.

Re: Workbench top questions

#6

and a few magazines...potted plant or two...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Workbench top questions

#7

Solid core door?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My bench uses a used solid core door, seriously lacking in prettiness, but sound. The heavier door in the barn is being saved for the next benchtop - after I finish ripping up this one in some workholding experiments, when the round tuit inventory's a little higher.

It's pretty solid, though I will confess I haven't cut any 1/2" mortises in Australian hardwoods on it to test ultimate stiffness.

Re: Workbench top questions

#8

Re: Solid core door and glue-beams

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

When driving on 101 south, just before you get to Santa Rose there's a company on the right that you can see from the highway that makes "glue-beams". I've been wondering if one could buy a six or seven ft. remnant from them. Maybe they sell their cut-off ends. Talk about a great bench top. Do you know anything about that company?

Marv

Re: Workbench top questions

#9

Re: Solid core door?

Bart Leetch

>I used 1" plywood for the bottom sheet then glued & screwed 3/4" high density chip board like used for under-layment on top of a sub floor then 1/4" tempered Masonite as a replaceable top all banded by donated poplar on top of a M&T poplar base. The front & back legs are joined with a Dado with 3/4" plywood inset into the Dado with a strip of wood as a spacer between it & the pegboard on the outside end of the bench.


img

Re: Workbench top questions

#10

Re:The real solution

ThomD

>"(This makes sense to me, since I once built a clavichord with a thin birch plywood soundboard.)"

My Dad did something like that, he made a clavichord back in the late 70s. Unfortunately birch plywood is only a good soundboard if stability not musicality are the issue. It's heavy and weak. It's a panel product for aircraft. I have thought of using it as a core in a bench that was heavily vennered in something like maple. Say tow layers of birch with a 1/2" per side of maple. But stability is less of an issue that it seems. I have never had a shop in a perfect museum like condition of moisture control. I;m probably at the outer limits of what you can have and make useful furniture in. Solid wood isn't a problem.

Solid wood could also be pushed a lot like this: laminate 3/4" planks using marine epoxy, seal the ends with epoxy. The core should be split vertically at the edgesand reglued. That way you have a core area that is completely isolated. While I know it would work and have done aspects of it myself, as pointed out, solid wood is normally not a problem. The cost of solid wood and working the large pieces is sometimes more of a good thing than people want.

Here is a strategy that works with the baltic birch, and I have used it for years: Assemble a hollow beam with bukheads. 2 layers of the stuff may not be stiff enough, but a hunk 4 inches thick is very solid. What you do is while at home depot, etc.. get them to rip two top and bottom pieces, say two 12'x8'; two 3.5'x8' pieces, and a enough strips 3.5 inches wide to make 10 bulkheads. When assmebled this will give a beam 4.25" x 12" x 8', or whatever size you decide.

You need to consider where stuff like mortising will occur, it needs to be over the rear frame normally, and is not a large area. I make that area solid with several closely placed bulkheads, or just a solid mass of ply. The beauty here is that a 4 inch structure is 4 times stronger and 8 times stiffer (than 2 inches of laminated birch), and if properly made in hollow form is every bit as solid, and much lighter, cheaper, easier to makem and more likely to be straight and stay straight.