Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

How long would it take you to make the following:

Posts

How long would it take you to make the following:

#1

How long would it take you to make the following:

Joel

>A drawer:

1' long, 9"wide, 2" deep.

Blind dovetails in the front.

Through dovetails in the back.

a solid bottom let into a groove in the sides.

with a knob or pull

Now - I would be interested in two estimates - a normal one using modern tools and another one for those of you who work by hand where you mill up the stock from rough thicknessed material.

THe drawer is considered done when it is ready for final sanding and finish application should be finished but that's not included.

Are we talking an hour? a day? I'm interested in what you folks come up with.

--------------------

Joel

Tools for working Wood

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#2

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

"RJ" Whelan

>Rough cut and thickness with TS and planer

Cut drawer grooves on router table

Cut DT's by hand

Fit drawer to opening

Plane and scrape by hand

Minor sanding if needed

About 90-120 minutes

Multiple drawers (4 or 5) would probably cut the per drawer time by 15-20%.

rj

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#3

24 Hours

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>And that would be the time it takes for hide glue to dry. Given that most of that time is spent doing other things and given I have boards from the sawmill and don't need to slab out the boards from timbers, I can give you an idea of what it takes to make a drawer.

Preparation of the drawfront which is thicker, including ripping to width and cutting to length and planing flat probably 20 minutes. That includes plowing the groove.

Preparation of the drawer sides and back, same as above, don't need to take too much time as these don't show, so 20 minutes. Plow both sides, back is somewhat narrower and has no groove.

Preparation of the drawer bottom is another matter. If I am resawing down then it takes some time. I can get thinner boards from my sawmill, so with a good scrub plane about 30 minutes for the bottom. I usually make my drawer bottoms in two pieces oriented with the grain running from side to side with a butt joint. I glue the bottom up, in the groove when I glue up the drawer, it is the only clamp I use on dovetail drawers. They are self clamping. All glue joints are toothed to increase adhesion.

The blind dovetails on the front about twenty minutes, this includes marking out, sawing and chopping both sides.

The through dovetails, probably about 15 minutes to completion. I gang saw the tails first so I can cut down on time here.

Five minutes to fit everything up and 20 minutes to glue up, wipe of squeeze out and clean up the brush and rags.

Now I didn't include the time to prepare the glue, I used liquid hide glue. But these processes can be combined, especially if you are doing multiple drawers, the time can be somewhat reduced by doing all parts at the same time.

So how much time is that, well let me do the math, but just under 2 hours. But then there are breaks, distractions but I think the total working time is around that time.

This is in a perfect world when all your tools are where you expect them to be, the wood behaves, your clamps, if you use them, are in place, your tools are sharp and you hold your mouth just right, it can go quickly.

But it still takes 24 hours for the glue to dry, so if it takes longer to make the drawer, it will be ready tomorrow.

Stephen

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#4

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I would say three or maybe three and a half hours for walnut with poplar secondary. And maybe two and a half for all pine. All hand work. You can forget "ready for final sanding". Sanding is not needed on a well planed drawer.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#5

Well, thank you Stephen...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Your estimate tells me that I'm not that slow after all :-)

DC

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#6

Re: What are the quality requirements?

Dave Mount

>Depends on whether it's a drawer for a shop cabinet or I'm trying to put out my best work. When I'm building a piece of household furniture, I fuss over dovetail layout and make extra effort to have dovetails with no gaps, even in the back of the drawer. I'm not defending the practice, it's just what I do, and it takes extra time. If the only requirement is a box that won't fall apart when used, very different story -- dovetail layout by eye, don't sweat overcutting baselines, etc.

Why do you ask?

Best,

Dave

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#7

1.5-2 hours sounds about right.

Ed Snow

>more drawers is faster

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#8

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

ThomD

>It's hard to get the prep in there. That can be highly variable. Doesn't some recent research imply that cabinetmakers, ye old, had access to quite a lot of stock prepared sizes from their suppliers? My problem is the reverse I can end up taking stuff out of anything from a raw tree; to a piece that only grudgingly yields it with a loy of work, but leaes me more useful stock; to, rarely, a propery dimensioned piece. If I made drawers on a regular basis I guess I would have to come up with a supply of material that closely matched my regular needs.

The rest of it might take an hour. FK says he quotes 20 minutes for machine stock prep, hand cut joints, and hand fitted drawer.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#9

Re: What are the quality requirements?

Joel

>In 1811 a Union London cabinetmaker would have been paid 1 shilling for making the drawer. THat also include materials costs and potentially bench rental (still trying to get a handle at that) They were paid piecework at a top line summer wage (longer day) he would make around 30 shillings for a week's work. I'm not sure how long the work week was probably 50-60 hours. Which translates to 1-2 hours of work - all by hand. From the responses I have read it seems that by machine it would take today about the same amount of time, by hand double. Of course I bet Frank Klausz - who quotes 20 minutes for a machine made drawer with hand dovetails would be at the same speed as 1811 for all hand work.

THe difference seems to be practice and of course doing it every day for a living.

--------------------

Joel

Tools for working Wood

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#10

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

Joel

>yes - the wood for the sides would only need a little cleanup.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#11

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

paul womack

>Well, there's the time to make the bench, find good chisels second hand, renovate the chisels, decide the handles ain't good enough, get a lathe, learn to make london pattern handles, find a dovetail saw, decide it's blunt, wait to find a s/h saw sharpening vice, saw set, learn to sharpen other saws, sharpen the DT saw, buy some old planes, learn to ...

Years, basically, and all of them enjoyable.

BugBear

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#12

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

Dean J in MN

>Yes -- Ye old cabinetmakers had access to stock in useful thickness from the sawyers. Secondary woods in 1/2" for example. That would save me a lot of time, I have easy access to only 4/4+ pine from my suppliers. Yes I can have them thickness the lumber, but I find it acceptable to put on my sawyer hat and resaw 4/4 to get what I need.

The 2 hour range seems about right for me as well. Maybe less on the smaller drawer, depends on how much 1/2" stock I had sitting around.

-Dean

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#13

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

>Joel, there's a link to an article I wrote a while back on the topic at the bottom.

The time allowances suggested are based on long established numbers from British workshops. In other words they are the sort of hours per drawer that businesses charge to customers, and they've been in use forr many decades. Certainly I base my prices for drawer making on these numbers, and I've found it's accurate and pretty consistent over the last thirty years.

I originally got the figures from the publication A Guide to Estimating for Cabinet Makers produced by an organisation called CoSIRA (Council for Small Industries in Rural Areas.) The document in my possession was printed at least as far back as the early 1970's as that's when I was given it. I think it had been around for a decade or two prior to that.

I suspect some people might be surprised at the number of hours allocated to making drawers, but what is often forgotten is that tools have to be sharpened and a lot of other 'peripheral' tasks are important if you want to work efficiently.

Certainly I can knock out a through corner dovetail at the back of a drawer box in five minutes-- I demonstrate it to unbelieving learners from time to time, but I couldn't work at that pace eight or ten hours a day, day after day.

So, for traditional high quality drawers that include slips and all the other paraphenalia that goes into a top quality drawer, I'll continue charging about 6-1/2 per drawer for a stack of drawers all much the same, and 8 hours for a single example of a drawer. Slainte.


Drawer making Article

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#14

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

joel

>Richard,

thanks for posting. Your estimates are for a more complicated drawer than I speced but I do have pricing for more complicated stuff. I need to read your article thoroughly.

In 1811 the union price for what I speced out was 1 shilling. and that's at the top end of the wage scale. And of course this implies a professional rate doing it day in and out. usually not one single drawer at a time of course. Now at my guesstimate of a 50-60 hour work week that works out to about 1 1/2 - 2 hours and it's interesting to see how if anything, even with power tools the times have no changed much, or even expanded.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#15

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

GolfSteve in Calgary

>For a quality drawer with slips, solid wood bottom, piston fit into the opening takes me about 12 hours to make a single drawer. Considering I only make one or two drawers a year I don't think that's too bad.

For a non-piston fit drawer with grooves instead of slips it takes me about 6 hours to make a single drawer from rough stock.

Half-lip drawers take a bit more time.



I don't pretend that I could make a living wage doing this.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#16

with power tools

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Using power tools for stock preparation I imagine that I could shave about an hour off the time required to make a drawer. Stock preparation by hand takes me about 15-30 minutes per board depending on how twisted it is and how much I have to scrub off to get the desired thickness.

I've never cut a dovetail using power tools so I have no idea how much time could be shaved off a drawer. I imagine that once the jigs are set up you could fire drawers out pretty quickly.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#18

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

Sgian Dubh

>Joel, those time allowances exclude stock preparation, which is charged separately at 1.25ft� per hour (British measure) which is the same as 15 bd ft per hour using fixed plant, ie, surface planers, thickness planers, rip saws and so on.

I can see that the example I gave involves more work, but of course it includes slips. Drawers without slips are considered middling to low quality here in the UK. The reason for the low ranking is that drawer sides with grooves worked in the side require fatter less aesthetically attractive drawer box material.

The charge doesn't differentiate between, for eaxmple, large drawers with muntins, and smaller drawers that don't need them. Like everything else in estimating charges compromises are made. For example, in the majority of cases all other joints in a carcase or frame, with the exception of dovetails come in at a flat rate of two hours per joint, with discounts for multiples of the same or similar joints.

In the end, some joints take longer than two hours and some take less, but in a piece with a variety of joints things tend to even out, so the two hours per joint is a good average that covers most circumstances.

A while back I had an article published on estimating for furniture makers in Woodwork out of Califruitcake. It was issue 102, December 2006. I'm still getting emails from woodworkers all over the blasted place saying how useful they found it. I think it's surprising that there seems to be whole armies of professional woodworkers that really hadn't worked out any satisfactory method to estimate and charge for their work. I keep hearing about nonsense estimating systems like material costs X 3 which really estimates nothing at all. After all, I can buy wood for a project costing �1000 and I can buy the same volume of cheaper wood for �800. That material costs X 3 equals a �600 difference in the charge for the same amount of work-- just ludicrous.

If there is such a thing as a useful materials costs x a random figure, the only one I've found is anywhere near close to giving a useful number is materials costs X 10, and even that's pretty hopeless. Slainte.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#19

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

joel

>Stock preparation for my case would be minimal and included in my estimate. The reason being is that you would have drawer material already sawn out and much flatter than we would get now - so all it would take is a couple of passes. The shilling also includes finding material and a pre-made knob. It does not include finishing.

The particular estimate is also without slips. it's for a tiny drawer. the same table I am quoting from also had payments for drawers of huge sizes with every permutation of slips, beading, etc that can imagine. I plan to work up a blog entry in a few weeks and I was curious what modern woodworkers both pro and am would consider a reasonable time. I'll post the whole chart.

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#20

Re: What are the quality requirements?

ThomD

>Very interesting Joel.

"THe difference seems to be practice and of course doing it every day for a living."

According to him the difference was one piece of furniture with a lot of drawers. It was a substantial workout but less than one might gloomilly imagine.

Is the store still in NYC?

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#21

Re: What are the quality requirements?

joel

>We are in brooklyn now bigger space. See my blog or website for directions and info about the new space.

joel

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

Only six? You drink slow.

Jack Guzman from Maine

>

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#23

About 2 hours from rough stock to ready to finish

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Joel,

I notice that many have replied and I'll have a look later at what else is written, but I'd say about 2 hours go to whoa, including packing up.

It would be about the same using either handtools or machine tools to make one of these, maybe handtools a trifle longer - it's either setup time for the machines or getting tools out and set up.

If it was 10 off items, then the machinery would be a no-brainer.

Approx 30" stock preparation and 1-1.5hrs joinery time.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#24

Excludes fitting to carcase opening

Andrew F in Australia

>This is the fiddly bit.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: How long would it take you to make the following:

#25

Re: How long would it take you to make the followi

Sgian Dubh

>Joel, I'll be interested to see it to compare with the estimating system I use. I'm pretty sure that my method is based on, and adapted from methods that have been in use in one form or another for perhaps a couple of hundred years. By that I mean the method has been adapted and adjusted in small increments as time went on and equipment changed.

There hasn't really been mention of what goes into what I described as a 'high quality' drawer, but there are certain tasks done in very good work that's omitted from lesser drawers. For example, in that eight hour charge for a single drawer I mentioned there's preparing the already squared oversize stock for each part of the drawer.

The front, sides and back have to be cut to length and width. These parts aren't truly rectangular pieces. The sides are slightly tapered individually for their specific location from front to back to go about 7/8 of the way home in the carcase. The front is both too long and too wide to go in. The bottom edge is square to the faces, but the top edge and the two ends are slightly bevelled so that this too will only jam in about 3/4 of the way.

Some people make the back a hair tight in the length knowing this means the finished drawer will have the width reduced by planing the outside face of the sides. I do the opposite and make the drawer back about 0.2 mm narrower than the space at the back.

All these jobs take time. It's easier to make a drawer where all the parts simply slip into place before construction. In the method I briefly alluded to the assembled drawer still needs significant work. The top edge of the sides and front need shooting in to fit. The drawer front is too wide to go in so this has to be planed off too.

On the other hand making one of these very tight tolerance drawers is often a waste of time; a change in seasons means they're either a bit sloppy or too darned tight to open and close, ha, ha. Slainte.