Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Tote grain orientation . . .

Posts

Tote grain orientation . . .

#1

Tote grain orientation . . .

steve mackay

>Since its from scratch and can go either way I may as well learn somethin, right ? The infill for the aft will be two peices either way we go, sooooooooooooo . . . the grain inside will be lengthwise but should the grain of the tote be parallel with the bottom or perpendicular ? Perpendicular, to my simple mind, might offer more strength but Mr. Stanley's are always t'other way. I'm sure theres a cosmic reason. Thoughts either way ?


img

Re: Tote grain orientation . . .

#2

Saws handles too

David Miller from Iowa

>have the grain parallel to the direction of movement when in use. Good question as to why - maybe the "horns" of the tote or saw handle would chip off too easy the other way?

Re: Tote grain orientation . . .

#3

Re: Tote grain orientation . . .

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Steve,

If you make the tote grain perpendicular, you're gonna have short grain at the foot, where it's anchored to the shoe, and short grain in the horn (as David mentioned). It wouldn't last long. Horizontal grain will tend to break in the middle of the handle, which you see a lot on these planes, but at least you have a steel bolt down through there for support.

Wiley

Re: Tote grain orientation . . .

#4

Re: Tote grain orientation . . .

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I made a fore plane in 1978 with the grain in the handle running vertically, i.e. perpendicular to the stock. I was copying a plane made by Nathaniel Dominy in 1792, which also had this orientation. Since it is the only jack or fore or scrub type plane I have ever used, it has gotten a lot of wear. The tips of the handle where it flares at the top are somewhat vulnerable. I lost a small chip there once when I knocked it with another tool.