Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Reel mower (OT?)

Posts

Reel mower (OT?)

#1

Reel mower (OT?)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>It is a hand tool, after all. No motor. Megan and I plan on stimulating the economy sometime in May by ordering a reel mower from Lee Valley. I am debating between their 18" mower which only has 2 wheels but weighs only 24 lbs., or the 20" mower which has 4 wheels but weighs 30 lbs. I am wondering if you have one of these which one you purchased and how you like it. Or any other advice you might have about it. I plan on getting the sharpening kit and extra lapping compound when I get the mower. We have about a 1/2 acre lot with 200 trees and shrubs, and it just seems to me that mowing with one of these would be a pleasant affair. We split the mowing job between the two of us, and the girls might get to help this year also. Of course I wouldn't mind mowing the whole yard myself but Megan enjoys the yard work and wants the outdoor excersize as well. My neighbor of course has about the same size yard but does not want to plant much shrubbery on it so he can get longer straighter runs for his riding lawn mower ;)

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#2

Reel Mowers are Great

David Miller from Iowa

>Interesting -

I used to collect reel mowers - had over 50 at one time. Pared down to 8 primo ones now. I wrote an article on them for a magazine which I will email you if I can find it in the dark recesses of my C drive.

Never had the Lee Valley models so I can't comment on those.

Reel mowers are like planes - if you keep them sharp and use them correctly they work great. The number one bit of advice I can give is don't let the grass get too long. If you mow every week it will be fine, but if you vacation or it is rainy and you don't get out there for 11 days it is a killer. I used to mow every day a little after work - not the whole yard, maybe about 15 minutes to wind down every day it wasn't raining.

David

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#3

Re: Reel Mowers are Great

BobStrawn

>I would love the article as well, I am in the market for a reel mower!

I have been looking at the one by Scott, sadly the manufacturing of it has gone overseas recently.

Bob

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#4

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Mose, you might have asked some Amish cousins about this. Since your lawn is bigger than your shop, you want a Heavy-Duty Silent Reel. The Amish call them Yardman, the old name, but I think mine says something like agri-fab on it. They are much more robust than either of the Lee Valley offerings. You don't want to buy a block plane to surface long boards. Mascot Sharpening, 434 Newport Rd. Ronks, PA 17572 sells them and they could send a brochure or price list. I would recommend the 18". It might cost a bit more than the Lee Valley mowers (perhaps $180), but easily worth it.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#5

???

Todd Hughes

>Well if you enjoy mowing yards so much and don't know what to do on your vacation you can always come here and mow mine !...I have a hard time thinking of somthing I like to do less then mow grass, and will admit to only cutting mine maybe once or twice a year, whether it needs it or not.

... I bought a self propelled 9 HP mower last year ,worked good the one time I used it but left it out in the weather so maybe might have to get another one come summer

...I see lots of old push reel type mowers at auctions and unless Amish are there don't normaly go for much. I bought a Keen Kutter one years ago and tried it out for giggles and while kind of neato imagine it would get old pretty fast. You know I might still have it somwhere?

...Had an old antique motorised reel mower once made by REO. I sort of liked it because by the time you got it started , pulling the cord about 200 times, you were to tired to mow the yard !.....Todd

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#6

I'd rathers be woodworking

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I mowed with one of these as a kid at my grandparents. I don't recall the adults fighting over using it. Fortunately it was very tender grass, not the robust KY 31 we have here that would choke a reel mower. Heck it chokes a real mower.

At a half acre and an 18" width that's the equivalent of 15,000' linear feet of mowing. At an average speed of 1 mph (I recall a lot of backing up and pushing off again with these) that is 3 hours of pushing every ?? weeks. You don't let the grass get tall with this mower. Yup, I'd rather be woodworking.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#7

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

wilbur

>I bought a reel mower when we moved into our house 2 years ago. We have a small lot, so mowing time isn't too much of an issue. I wound up buying a Honda mulching mower last summer for a few reasons.

First, as has been mentioned, a reel mower really depends on you being able to mow the lawn on a regular basis. It doesn't do very well on very long grass. At the rate that the grass grows in my yard, I needed to mow the lawn about every 5 days, which I just wasn't able to keep up with, with the kids and all.

Second, the maximum height that my reel mower could be set to wasn't very high -- less than 3 inches. This is not great for the lawn, as it's better to keep the grass between 3-4 inches. The grass grows better and it crowds out the weeds.

Finally, my reel mower was an 18" model. Going to 20" made more of a difference than you might think.

If I were to get a reel mower again, I'd try to find one that can be set at 3 1/2" cutting height, and was 20" wide, but only if I was sure i could mow the lawn 2x/week, which doesn't look like a possibility for the foreseeable future.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#8

Does a Honda mower cut on the pull stroke?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#9

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>As time goes on, water shortage is going to become a major issue. It already is in many parts of the country. Lawns are a luxury that we can easily do without. Lawns are most often over-watered. We are probably the only country in the world that is so focused on green grass in our yards. As a country we need to refocus and come up with different ways of showing off all that wasted real estate around our homes. If we are determined to use the water, lets grow corn and use it for ethonal. If we did that maybe we can keep the cost of food from becoming unaffordable. Just my opinion.

Marv

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#10

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Moses,

I have had a reel mower for 15 years.....it confuses the heck out of the kids in my neighbourhood.....mine was made in Denmark...I lap sharpen it once a year and it gives me a cut lawn, not a motorized whipped lawn....

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#11

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

David Cockey

>I mowed may grandparents lawn when I was a teenager. If the power mower wasn't working I used the old push reel mower, and it was miserable. First problem I'm sure was the sharpness (or lack of) of the blades. Second problem was my grandfater insisted the grass had to be mowed early in the morning which meant it was wet with dew, particularly under the trees. The wet grass would keep clogging up the mower.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#12

Not if you lift the mower while pull stroking.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#13

Re: WE live in a desert of sorts...

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>... but not everyone does.

I was in Pennsylvania a couple of autumns ago, and was amazed, as a California boy, to see everything as green as it was in late September, early October. California, where we live, had been gold and lighter since mid May. They never seem to get dry there. Not like we do.

A water shortage means really different things in different parts of the world. Here, I water the tomatoes and the roses regularly.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#14

Re: Next you need a Scythe

ThomD

>I think reel mowers are like planes in the sense that you may find you need more than one.

I recomend the gardena if females are involved. I have four females on the property and that is all they want to use. It has lots of plastic parts, but it cuts with precision, and is so light that I normally just pivot and it floats to the next row, through the air. It's great if you have to cut around a lot of stuff and floats up hills. On the other hand one does notice the extra laps on straightaways.

The LV silent mower looks like it hits the same buttons.

http://www.leevalley.com/garden/page.aspx?c=1&p=51117&cat=2,2160,51170

In order to have greater speed over larger open areas, I later bought a 20" mower. I like it OK, it is really too hard for my wife to push. She is very athletic, but it just has too much resistance for all the starts and stops. I have a lot of weight to put behind it and can keep it moving. If there was a wide Gardena type mower it would probably suit us both.

The LV 20 incher is similar to the Scott 20 incher we have. It's lowest mowing height of just under 2" is too high. It isn't just a mater of how high the grass is when you finish but whether there is enough feed pressure to cut well. With the scott you can release the adjustment lever and let it fall to a lower more reasonable position. I don't really know what they were thinking. If one has a cloddy undersurface to the earth, the 20 inch mower's extra wheel do ride really nicely.

We also have a greens mower, and that's a whole other thing, a finishing plane if you like.

Between the two you mention, I would strongly recomend the 18", or the silent mower if you move in that direction. I haven't used the 18" but with the 1/2" cut not available on the 20 incher, and the difficulty of pushing the 20 incher...

One thing about push mowers - reel mowers come in power versions also so "reel" doesn't = "push" - is that they are really only good for cutting grass and clover, etc... A lot of junk that can start in a lawn is not amenable to their touch. This leads to Scythes, brace yourself. Actually they are more interesting and work better anyway.

As far as all the enviro hogwash is concerned, reel mowers create some problems in the sense that they aren't compatible with lassez fair attitudes to weeds and so forth. I actually don't use pesticides because I like to do sensible stuff like juice the dandelions, but the reality is that good no pesticide lawn practices are not made any easier with a reel mower. I start to look with distain on people who are just letting their weed grow in carpets because I can't just buzz saw through the weeds as I might with a power mower. However while people complement us on the size of our yard, it is still small enough that if one is healthy a reel mower is probably less trouble, you don't have to be on a CO2 or fitness kick to use one.

So far I haven't found a grass catcher that works with a reel mower, and that I like. They are all more of a pain than they are worth. In the old days the mowers came with serious, if heavy steel boxes that stayed put and stopped the mower topeling rearward. The new ones seem like afterthoughts.

I would buy the lap system, but it really is more like the burnisher for a scraper, than a sharpening system. It will refresh the reel until it dulls it completely. You will get past a few years though without needing to do anything too drastic. Better still, develop a deft hand with a file, and when that ends up distorting the reel you need a metal lathe with a tool post grinder.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#15

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

ThomD

>"cut lawn, not a motorized whipped lawn.... "

Greens profesionals the world over agree with you, but... I once had a power mower, came with a place I was renting. One day I cut the lawn with it, and noticed it was getting a little dull. I took the blade off and just ground it sharp, nothing fancy, though I leave the squared edge off and actually sharpen it. Ran the mover over areas I had previously mown and that looked OK, and the cut was 1-2 inches lower! Power mowers with sharp blades cut pretty well, though so far I have managed to avoid owning one. There is no doubt they are vastly easier to sharpen.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#16

Re: Al Gore on ebay

ThomD

>This is a passionate sell (it's funny I'm not taking sides in anything):

THIS IS YOUR CHANCE TO OWN THE ONLY LAWNMOWER UNOFFICIALLY ENDORSED BY AL GORE. EVER WONDER HOW THE GLOBAL WARMING DIVA AL GORE CIRCLES THE GLOBE IN THE BIGGEST JETS, ATTENDS AWARD CEREMONIES FOR HIS WORK ON GLOBAL WARMING IN MASSIVE SUV MOTORCADES AND DOES IT ALL COMPLETELY GUILT FREE. THE ANSWER IS CARBON OFFSETS MY FRIENDS. BY USING A MOWER SIMILAR TO THE ONE LISTED IN THIS AUCTION AL GORE IS ABLE TO GROOM HIS LAWN COMPLETELY CARBON FREE. THIS ALLOWS OUR NOBEL PEACE PRIZE RECIPIENT TO GENERATE HIS VERY OWN 100% LEGITIMATE CARBON OFFSET CERTIFICATES. HE IS THEN ABLE TO GIFT THESE CERTIFICATES TO HIMSELF TO "OFFSET" THE OTHER CARBON EMISSIONS HE PRODUCES WITH THE ENORMOUS PRIVATE JETS, SUV MOTORCADES, AND THE 2000 HORSPOWER DIESEL POWERED PRINTING PRESS THAT RUNS 24/7, 365 DAYS A YEAR PRINTING THE ABOVE MENTIONED CERTIFICATES. INCLUDED IN THIS AUCTION IS THE MOWER PICTURED AND A SAMPLE OF ONE OF THESE CERTIFICATES SO YOU TO CAN PRODUCE YOUR VERY OWN. ONCE PRINTED USE THESE CERTIFICATES TO OFFSET YOUR OWN CARBON FOOTPRINT OR SELL THEM FOR BIG $ TO DELUSIONAL HYPOCRITES LIKE OUR BUDDY AL. PLEASE BID WITH CONFIDENCE YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED WITH YOUR PURCHASE. THANKS FOR LOOKING.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#17

Thank you

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Thanks for all the advice. Thom, the Al Gore thing is amusing but I don't think it is very funny. For instance, "GREEN" building is the next big fad. All because there is a sucker born every second. Now we will probably have to pay twice as much for the exact same material from the same place so the customer can feel good about their environentally sound faked out practices while they are building a 5000 square foot house. And don't get me started on ethanol. I will avoid discussions on the subject here because I would probably be kicked off permanently ;)

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#18

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The Amish around here are allowed to have motors on their mowers but they can't have riding lawn mowers. So what they do is buy these ginormous mowers, 48" or 54" wide cuts with gigantic 16 or 20 horse motors on them and a deck on wheels pulled along behind the mower that you stand on to mow the yard. People amuse me.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#19

don't throw out the baby...

VTAndy4

>... with the bathwater, Moses. Browsing through the local home stores (here in "Green" Vermont), as far as I can tell, the current fad is to sheath and line homes in toxic, off-gassing stuff. The "green" products are few and far between. Yes, there are some companies whose "green" products are as you describe, and that is why one must be educated as a consumer. (i.e., ethanol). Many "green" products are just a return to the way things were before the chemical companies started running the show -- I mean, linseed oil + beeswax is a non-toxic finish but is nothing new under the sun. There are some new products that make either the process of renovation/building or living more comfortable or safer. It is nice to be able to choose an alternative. For instance, I'm insulating my shop's upstairs cathedral ceiling with a "green" insulation. While the fact that its made out of a recycled material is nice, the real deciding factor for me is that I HATE installing fiberglass insulation. With this new stuff, I can get away without wearing gloves or a mask, no itchiness, no worries. (And it goes up quickly and easily).

To each his own. Enjoy your 'reel' mower, for whatever reason you're buying it,

Andy

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#20

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Last summer I saw a couple of little kids operating a reel mower. One had a rope around his waist and was pulling and the other was pushing. I found an old advertisement for Mascot Sharpening, mentioned above. In 2005 18" Heavy Duty Silent Reels were $149 and 21" were $199. shipping was $14.

Warren

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#21

Re: Does a Honda mower cut on the pull stroke?

wilbur

>Well, on half the width of the mower the blade is cutting as it rotates towards the back of the mower, so I guess the answer is "yes" for half of my yard. :@)

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#22

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>The Cut aspect of the reel mower is controlled by the cutting bar, it allows the cut to be crisp...a spinning piece of metal without a cutting bar is not the same to me..

:-)

As a teen I worked at a local golf course, I used to follow the fairway cutters...that quality of cut is forever engrained on my mind, that and the early mornings.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#23

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>Moses before you go and BUY a mower you might want to TRY a mower. They are a lot of work. Also they don't like a lot of the weeds, and require you cut some of them twice.

I used to mow the Post Office lawn with two Hinsdale mowers built here in NH. I had a regular 18" two wheel and a 6" one wheel trimer. I wouldn't try one at home though.

The older ladies would stop and tell me about when they were young and mow'n with a 'Push Mow'a'. The younger women would stop and just watch like I had some alien tool.

Like David Miller I had a collection of them, not as big, but I had some nice mow'as. I gave 5 Hinsdale's, the two mentioned above and three others to a local Agro Museum on the State Fair Grounds.

I've had mowers with as few as three blades up to a Brookstone that had seven.

From what I've seen at the dump push mow'as are like exercise equipment. Their a great idea that's a lot of work that people get tried of using.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#24

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

ThomD

>Don't tell that to the chisels! They think they are cutting even without the bar.

All true, though when the going gets tough on the golf courses, they whip out the Flymo, which is just a standard rotary mower/hover craft. I spent some summers in the UK, and the typical mower there was a walk behind, self-propelled, motorised reel mower. They would be in full accordance with you also.

Re: Reel mower (OT?)

#25

Re: Next you need a Scythe

Paul Kierstead

>This leads to Scythes, brace yourself. Actually they are more interesting and work better anyway.

I've been using a scythe and reel mower to maintain my very small, very suburban lot for about 7 years now. I tend to dress in all black. The neighbors still give me strange looks. I will say that going out and swinging the scythe is hard work, but liberating after a day of desk work. 'tis a good conversation point with some people that come walk by as well.