Why are there so many backed tenon saws?
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>I have stumbled through dozens of backed tenon saws in my search for rust. Why are there so many? Big beefy backs, small handles, little wear.
The backed saw, introduced to allow for thinner blades, were an improvement over unbacked earlier saws? We have so many examples in almost unused condition. Were they that practical? I have wondered?
In big miter boxes well maybe and these saws were not used all that much, not like a panel or cabinet saw. Were they used for dovetails? And the parallel back to aid in cutting a certain depth, what about the tapered blades backed blades offered by some manufacturies?
The bulk and mass of the backed saws does help with the cutting pressure, but that weight has to be lifted and they just tire me out lifting all that weight.
Maybe I am just getting old, but if the saw is that heavy, I need someone on the other end to help me. Alright I am poking fun at this saw, but I just gave away my last large backed tenon saw.
As you can tell I am not a fan of backed saws, my dovetail saws have no backs, my other saws don't either. I think that they look great, but their actual enhancement of the sawing process has not impressed me.
I suppose the back keeps you from kinking the blade, but good sawing techniques also eliminate that problem. Straight motion with the hand, wrist, arm and shoulder together with a good aim and proper timing keeps the kerf straight.
I wouldn't be surprised that backed saws were introduced to allow people with less training that can use the tool without damaging them, as the increase in production of furniture in the nineteenth century.
I have owned a number of large and small backed saws over the years and I just couldn't get comfortable with any of them. At one point the back always limited the depth of the cut. They were heavy and unwielding.
I hope others have had better results using these, but I can't see the advantages.
Stephen



