Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Posts

Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#1

Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have stumbled through dozens of backed tenon saws in my search for rust. Why are there so many? Big beefy backs, small handles, little wear.

The backed saw, introduced to allow for thinner blades, were an improvement over unbacked earlier saws? We have so many examples in almost unused condition. Were they that practical? I have wondered?

In big miter boxes well maybe and these saws were not used all that much, not like a panel or cabinet saw. Were they used for dovetails? And the parallel back to aid in cutting a certain depth, what about the tapered blades backed blades offered by some manufacturies?

The bulk and mass of the backed saws does help with the cutting pressure, but that weight has to be lifted and they just tire me out lifting all that weight.

Maybe I am just getting old, but if the saw is that heavy, I need someone on the other end to help me. Alright I am poking fun at this saw, but I just gave away my last large backed tenon saw.

As you can tell I am not a fan of backed saws, my dovetail saws have no backs, my other saws don't either. I think that they look great, but their actual enhancement of the sawing process has not impressed me.

I suppose the back keeps you from kinking the blade, but good sawing techniques also eliminate that problem. Straight motion with the hand, wrist, arm and shoulder together with a good aim and proper timing keeps the kerf straight.

I wouldn't be surprised that backed saws were introduced to allow people with less training that can use the tool without damaging them, as the increase in production of furniture in the nineteenth century.

I have owned a number of large and small backed saws over the years and I just couldn't get comfortable with any of them. At one point the back always limited the depth of the cut. They were heavy and unwielding.

I hope others have had better results using these, but I can't see the advantages.

Stephen

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#2

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>"The bulk and mass of the backed saws does help with the cutting pressure, but that weight has to be lifted and they just tire me out lifting all that weight"

You should try a good dozuki ;-)

Allright, I haven't stirred the pot in a while...

I agree with you re: having to lift to start a cut, I find it tiring too.

And I think I'm with you regarding good sawing techniques. But to come back to the weight issue, I think that sharpness is more important than weight IMHO.

DC

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#3

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen wrote:

"I have stumbled through dozens of backed tenon saws in my search for rust. Why are there so many? Big beefy backs, small handles, little wear."

I am not sure why, maybe it's the craftsmen you hang out with? :-/ Seriously, the majority of backsaws I own (I primarily only own backsaws) are worn, and some were used a LOT. I find some saws that are not worn, but those are in the minority. The other thing is that you are in Utah, right? *gd&r*

Stephen wrote:

"As you can tell I am not a fan of backed saws, my dovetail saws have no backs, my other saws don't either."

I have noticed this, not just now, but you have mentioned this in various threads, and I don't see your infatuation to the backless saw quite honestly. To me it is like shaking hands with someone and getting a limph, curled up hand to shake. It just doesn't feel right to me, and in fact, it makes more sense where you have a Japanese saw which pulls, because you don't need the back for stiffness.

I think this is a preference of yours, in how you work, the back doesn't feel right to you. That is not to say that it is right or wrong, for you it is right because that is the way you feel. I do not feel as comfortable cutting joinery with a backless saw.

For me it's not as much the blade, as it is the connection between the handle and the back, possibly, to provide that assuring feeling of the cut. A backless saw just doesn't do that for me.

I've seen quite a few saws without backs on them, so I suspect you're not alone with your preference, solely. I do suspect you might be in the minority of craftsmen that use handsaws to cut joinery though. Hey, that's my suspicion and I'm sticking with it! *wink*

I am also a firm believer that if you feel fatigued at all, you might be standing or sawing improperly. I feel that if you line up your body in the proper way, for the arm/shoulder/pec/lat to cut properly, you should be able to saw for a long period of time with just a little practice. Stamina seems to come quickly for those determined.

I could be wrong about this, but I relate this to an incident I had while blacksmithing a year or two back...I was forging for about 8-10 hours and later that evening and the next couple days was I ever sore. I started to analyze my swing, and I noticed that I was not using the proper posture and it was causing me to pull my elbow out and swing the hammer outwards. This is bad, as it pulls/tears the muscles in the shoulder.

I believe, but haven't done a scientific study, that sawing is similar and that if you are in good stance you will have good stamina and be able to endure for much longer than if you had used improper stance. For one, being off balance is a terrible fatigue factor, IMO. This alone could cause similar muscle/nerve reaction over time if not done for in way the muscles are aligned.

I'm sure there are people out there thinking that I'm full of it, but if you look at all sports and/or crafts, equipment and tools are swung in specific fashions. Exactly why the tennis swing has so much in common with the golf swing for instance, and to the baseball swing, to bowling, etc...To me there are similar factors that apply to tools, as in swinging a hammer, sawing timbers, using an axe, a drawknife, a hand plane, rasping, etc...any duration of activity that is uncomfortable will cause some bad reaction in all of these. Hope that makes sense. Since we are all different we all need to find what works for us. Backless saws obviously work for you to cut joinery.

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#4

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Perhaps it is due to the ignorance of the masses. So the cause of the invasion of backed saws would be for the same reason so many plastic surgeons remain in business. I like back saws. I don't find a lot of them, but when I find one for $5-$8 I buy it. I have never spent an entire day cutting joinery though. I think if I was doing production hand work back in 1876 I would probably have learned to use an unbacked saw because I am naturally lazy and always looking for ways to make things easier. On the other hand, I probably would have had a big hairy beard and mustache and eaten bacon, eggs, sausage, biscuits & gravy, fried potatoes (the red ones of course) & onions, with a side of pancakes and pure maple syrup for breakfast every morning. I would have weighed about 4000 pounds and after rolling to work I would have looked at that puny saw with no back and said "Runt, go get me a real %$*^$#% saw!" And given the apprentice a kick in the pants as he scrambled to the nearest general store to get the latest Disston creation. Then all of the neighbors would have had to go buy the latest saw because I had one. You just can't let people get one up on you, you know; if he has one, by golly I need one too. Then we can set out on the porch saturday afternoon and talk about how schweeeeet our new saws are. Someday we might actually use them.

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#5

There's a place in Montr�al...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>That serves basically the breakfast you mention, with the addition of baked beans and ham... Binerie Mont-Royal, Mont-Royal near St-Denis. Jim should know that place...

If you stop there on Dec. 24, the lady keeps a bottle of cognac behind the counter, and will put some in your coffee if you want to :-)

DC

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#6

Re: There's a place in Montr�al...

PaulA

>Is that place comparable to Mont-Royal Hot Dog, a place whose breakfasts overwhelmed my capacity?

Paul

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#7

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Stephen,

Have you ever sharpened a backless saw to cut on the pull stroke? Would seem practical on a dovetail saw. Or mount the handle/tote on the opposite end of the blade?

Or.....put a tote on the toe end that would be made to hook your thumb in and pull the saw instead of pushing it. This would also aid in lifting the saw during the back stroke.

Marv

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#8

Re: There's a place in Montr�al...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Gotta admit that the place you mention doesn't ring a bell in my head, maybe Jim can chime in...

DC

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#9

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

David Cockey

>Back saws have been around a long time. The late 18th century Kenyon chest has several. They are used primarily for cutting joints, and also finish cuts of small pieces such as trim. If the depth of cut is an issue then the back saw is the wrong saw to use or the cut should be sawn in a different fashion. For a given size and sawing technique a back saw can always have a thinner blade without buckling than an unbacked saw with similar teeth. Chris Schwarz has written about back saws including a good article in the current issue of Woodworking in which he discusses the various types of saws and uses.

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#10

Of no added value ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>... But I could not resist sharing the image of Stephen and friend at either end of a two-man (or woman), double-handled rip saw (filed 15 ppi, of course) cutting ganged boards for dovetails.

It would be a social occasion, of course. Right friendly.

:)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#11

The Bear Lodge on US Hwy 14A

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>in the Big Horn mountains in Wyoming serves a breakfast like that, too. After 3 hours on motorcycle at 30 F, we were ready for something to eat. I've never seen so much food on three plates - a separate one each for the omelette, pancakes and sausage.

Bruce

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#12

Re: There's a place in Montr�al...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Yup!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#13

Decarie Hot Dog

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>I don't know Paul,

I enjoy Decarie Hot Dog for any meal when I am in town.....

Take care,

Jim

Re: Why are there so many backed tenon saws?

#14

Re: There's a place in Montr�al...

PaulA

>Here is a pointer to the restaurant.

http://restomontreal.ca/restaurants/index.php?section=viewresto&resto_id=1931&lang=en

Interesting stop for a visitor.

Paul