Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Sharpening Stone ID?

Posts

Sharpening Stone ID?

#1

Sharpening Stone ID?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Just picked up a new (to me) sharpening stone mounted in a softwood block. It is a natural stone but I have never seen anything quite this color.

It is very hard and was fairly flat when I got it. I flattened out the top and here is a pic of the stone without any lubricant, so it is dry from the flattening process.

Any ideas as to where it might have come from?

Stephen


img

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#2

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is a pic with lubricant on the stone.

Stephen


img

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#3

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

John Veerkamp

>Stephen,

I picked up a similar looking stone, sans box, 40 yrs ago in a rock shop in Arkansas somewhere between Harrison and Ft Smith. It is some type of Arkansas stone like Arkansas Black but not as hard.

John

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#4

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Really hard to tell from the pics Stephen since it's still so stained up from the old oils. It does look to be a soft stone tho, where from is anybodies guess. Arkansas or New Hampshire more then likely, but then again it could of come from Nova Scotia. From what I understand many a grinding wheel came from Nova Scotia.

I think it's still gunked up a bit so I'd either boil it clean or use some sandpaper on a flat surface and and rub it 'til all the old gunk gone. Afterwards you should be able to get a better idea of it's texture.

Have you put any steel to it yet?

T.O.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#5

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Todd,

Interesting that you should mention that part of the country, this came from New York State, an old collection. I have smoothed out the surface and it is hard enough, I doubt that the color is oil staining.

I can not remove the stone from its wooden base, so no chance of boiling it. I think the color is natural. Most of the oil was superficial and was scraped and sanded off.

It is hard and puts a mirror finish on my tools. I have had a couple of surgical Arkansas stones that were harder, one black and the other translucent white. But this one is right up there.

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#6

Re: Sharpening Stone cleaning and flattening query

John Aniano in NJ

>Todd, Stephen, et. al.,

You mentioned cleaning the natural stone - try this method: Clean off as much gunk as possible first, Stephen, it looks as though you already did this step. Then, run it through ~3 full dishwasher cycles. I put the stone to be cleaned on the top rack with the cups, etc. It is remarkable how well a dishwasher cleans sharpening stones. Of course, if the stone is glued to a wooden tray or holder, you shouldn't try this method until the stone is freed up.

Since we are on this topic, what are good methods for flattening stones like these? I use a diamond sharpening plate, one of the ~1/4" thick ones, 600 grit, but it takes a while and I wonder what this is doing to the diamond abrasive and/or the steel plate...

John

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#7

Re: Sharpening Stone cleaning and flattening query

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>John,

I tried 400 grit but it wouldn't cut it, so I went to 150 grit sandpaper on a flat cast iron table. Once I got the surface flat I switched to 400 and removed all the swirls.

The stone seems to work fine producing a mirror finish on irons and chisels.

If I can remove the stone from the wooden base, I will try to wash it, but I don't have a dishwasher, but I am looking for a new wife.

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#8

Re: Sharpening Stone cleaning and flattening query

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>John, often when I flatten an Arkansas stone it cuts a lot faster for quite a while. One might think this is great, but it really acts like a coarser stone all around, and doesn't polish as well. I think the grit has made scratches in the stone which make it altogether coarser. The same thing happens when you get a new stone; it cuts fast because the milling marks are doing the cutting and the stone doesn't polish as well until they are worn down.

I think that if you use diamonds to flatten a stone like this, you make deep scratches which take a long time to smooth up.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#9

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>If you already knew, why did you ask? I can do without manufactured quizzes.

Pam

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#10

Pam you are just rude

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I did not know what it was that is why I asked.

Quite being a wet blanket.

At least I am not just saying 'cool nm'

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#11

Re: Sharpening Stone cleaning and flattening query

Tony Zaffuto

>John and Stephen,

First, to those who use a dishwasher for cleaning stones, be careful to try to clean as much oil and gunk from the stones BEFORE the dishwasher! Maybe even use some oven cleaner first! Yes the dishwasher does a beautiful job on the stones, but at a cost. First is the stink and second is the residue that is left in the dishwasher for days to come. I also heard of a guy who tried to clean the residue by cycling some acetone or similar stuff in the machine and blowing out all of the seals.

Second, I have a soft spot for old stones. I have one that looks and acts very similar to the one Stephen has. It was one of my favorites for a bit, cut quickly and left dang near a mirror polish. My guess is that it is a natural Arkansas soft stone or Washita. I have been told the Washitas were a "off white" to "light tan" in color with a few veins or streaks. I agree with Warren's advice to not overclean stones. My best results occur with a wiping of the stone after use with a shop rag.

I try to search out stones in boxes but the ones you find (at least where I look) are manufactured stones. I've come across many old oil stones, and usually pick them up cause they're cheap--a couple of bucks or so! And I've gotten some real gems over the past years.

T.Z.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#12

Re: Pam you are just rude

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Apparently you did know before posting. When Todd mentioned New Hampshire, you said, and I quote:

Interesting that you should mention that part of the country, this came from New York State, an old collection.

Why didn't you mention it's origin? And that it's old?

As to rude, I suppose that's true if that's what you think. Who am I to say I'm not as perceived? I'm usually intentionally rude to middle-aged little boys; however, in this case I wasn't trying, simply stating a preference for adult conversation. And how about a typical non-apology: I'm sorry if something I said offended you.

Pam

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#13

Stone "hardness" question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I think all these natural sharpening stones are some variant of quartz and hence their hardness as defined by what they will scratch (Mohs scale) or by how difficult it is to penetrate them (Rockwell) is essentially the same. What property of these stones is being called "hardness"? How does this "hardness" affect the use of the stone or what the stone is used for?

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#14

Re: Stone "hardness" question

Dean J in MN

>I had an interesting chat with a geologist, quite by accident, at Williamsburg the last time I was there. She knew an amazing amount about chert and the novaculite we all love as whetstones. She was excited to find a group of non-geologists who even had an interest in a stone! The hardness we speak of in novaculite is the specific gravity as I understand it. Harder being "better" for whetstones. But the softer stones wear faster, exposing new quartz.

What was more interesting was her excitement about a turkey stone which had garnet as its abrasive. Turns out garnet only fractures at very specific angles, leading the crystal to remain "sharp" with wear, unlike quartz. Maybe those old timers liked those turkey stones for a reason.

If you know any geologists -- take an novaculite stone to them and they will tell you all sorts of amazing things about them!

-Dean

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#15

Re: Stone "hardness" question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>You wrote:

'The hardness we speak of in novaculite is the specific gravity as I understand it. Harder being "better" for whetstones. But the softer stones wear faster, exposing new quartz.'

Novaculite is a type of hard argillaceous slate from clay, not quartz, if I am not mistaken.

I don't know about Washita stones.

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#16

Any chert is a potential hone.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>All cherts are cryptocrystalline silicates, whether novaculite, agate, jasper, calcedony, or flints. The property that makes a chert suitable for honing is its degree of silification and its fracturing profile: how its sharp silicates are presented for metal removal while resisting too-rapid deformation and wear.

Novaculite strikes this balance nicely. However, all novaculite is not the same. When you find chalky limestone-like novaculite displaying the more sedimentary side of chert formation, it will likely wear away more quickly, releasing silicates with far less struggle that the more dense and more translucent varieties. Such friability can be a good thing, of course, but is more suited to early honing steps.

I have translucent novaculite stones in light through black, which cut and polish somewhat slowly but steadily and evenly for simpler, less-doped steels. I've also added several other cherts to my arsenal; a slab of crysoprase (calcedony) for a super-high polish on my gravers, and a few nice benchstones I sawed from large blocks of brick-colored (red) jasper that cut like a finer grit translucent novaculite, more slowly but finer that anything else I've tried. Again, works great on carbon-steel gravers and narrow chisels, but I don't bother to use it for plane irons.

My favorite, though, is a 3/8" slab of petrified palm peppered with little holes. Cuts surprisingly fast and the swarf runs through the holes. It's amazing how much steel this removes. It turns black immediately. Apparently its a common find in Louisiana and the Mississippi Delta. I think I paid eight dollars for probably sixty square inches.

Try the rock shows. Take a piece or two of carbon steel and see if it makes a mark (ask first, of course). There are likely some real bargains out there.

While Arkansas stones are very nice, aesthetically pleasing and traditional, I consider diamond to trump chert for nearly any honing application. It's far faster, cheaper, more predictable and repeatable, and beyond 50,000 mesh (at 100,000 and 200,000 mesh), it will likely exceed your steel's ability to become any sharper.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#17

Re: Any chert is a potential hone.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>David,

You wrote:

'My favorite, though, is a 3/8" slab of petrified palm peppered with little holes.'

Have you ever put a geiger counter next to that petrified material?

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#18

Re: Stone "hardness" question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I thought I would add a couple of notes. The stones may be all the same actual hardness. What is different is that the "finer" stones have a tighter matrix and thus a higher density. The "softer" stones do wear faster, but not so much as to be really exposing fresh grit. In thirty some years of hard use, my washita stone has lost almost 1/4inch of thickness, so it may last only 50 more years. My soft Arkansas has been flattened one time and is down almost 1/32 in that time. I don't think I'm exposing fresh grit at a great rate. The harder stones ought to last for centuries.

I think these stones defy comparison with the other stones and other systems. After years of daily use, my ideas of how they work are more intuitive than analytical. It is not a simple matter of measuring grit size.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#19

Re: Pam you are just rude

ThomD

>"Who am I to say I'm not as perceived?"

Good point, leave it to me:

I've met you, you're nice, and you have skills.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#20

Re: Any chert is a potential hone.

ThomD

>With where I live that's probably a good question for any of my stones.

Re: Sharpening Stone ID?

#21

Thanks, Thom, right back at you.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>