Any chert is a potential hone.
David Barnett - SW Florida
>All cherts are cryptocrystalline silicates, whether novaculite, agate, jasper, calcedony, or flints. The property that makes a chert suitable for honing is its degree of silification and its fracturing profile: how its sharp silicates are presented for metal removal while resisting too-rapid deformation and wear.
Novaculite strikes this balance nicely. However, all novaculite is not the same. When you find chalky limestone-like novaculite displaying the more sedimentary side of chert formation, it will likely wear away more quickly, releasing silicates with far less struggle that the more dense and more translucent varieties. Such friability can be a good thing, of course, but is more suited to early honing steps.
I have translucent novaculite stones in light through black, which cut and polish somewhat slowly but steadily and evenly for simpler, less-doped steels. I've also added several other cherts to my arsenal; a slab of crysoprase (calcedony) for a super-high polish on my gravers, and a few nice benchstones I sawed from large blocks of brick-colored (red) jasper that cut like a finer grit translucent novaculite, more slowly but finer that anything else I've tried. Again, works great on carbon-steel gravers and narrow chisels, but I don't bother to use it for plane irons.
My favorite, though, is a 3/8" slab of petrified palm peppered with little holes. Cuts surprisingly fast and the swarf runs through the holes. It's amazing how much steel this removes. It turns black immediately. Apparently its a common find in Louisiana and the Mississippi Delta. I think I paid eight dollars for probably sixty square inches.
Try the rock shows. Take a piece or two of carbon steel and see if it makes a mark (ask first, of course). There are likely some real bargains out there.
While Arkansas stones are very nice, aesthetically pleasing and traditional, I consider diamond to trump chert for nearly any honing application. It's far faster, cheaper, more predictable and repeatable, and beyond 50,000 mesh (at 100,000 and 200,000 mesh), it will likely exceed your steel's ability to become any sharper.