Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Kicking a Dead Horse*

Posts

Kicking a Dead Horse*

#1

Kicking a Dead Horse*

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I hate to bring up the subject of Hide Glue fracture tests again but I got thinking about some of the responses to the other threads about the value of this test and you just don't encounter this joint in normal woodworking.

This got me thinking, well of course you do, consider a narrow pin half blind dovetailed drawer front. The orientation of end grain to side grain is greater than 50% in some cases.

Also mortise and tenon joints has a large percentage of end grain / side grain orientation. So these joint tests are important, if do nothing but to raise the thinking about the qualities of hide glue.

This one was sized but I did not allow it to dry. It was harder to break as the pieces were shorter and the failure of substrate looks like a little more than the last, too close to call without the statisticians.

Liquid hide glue is an excellent all purpose adhesive that every woodworker should try and use. If you want to go the extra effort and get a glue pot and some 192g ground hide glue (from Joel), then give it a try.

If you don't want to go to the bother initially then pick up a bottle of Patrick Edwards Old Brown Glue or Franklin/Titebond Liquid Hide Glue and use the best glue in history.

Stephen

(* no offense Todd)


img

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#2

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

ThomD

>I mentioned dovetails in one of my responses, though I am not entirely sure that it often happens that everything lets go, but loh, the endgrain holds and the joint does not need to be repaired. More perversely you might have some failure, but have far greater difficulty not ending up with blowouts and more stuff to repair. Another problem is that you may end up with greater difficulty getting a tight joint when assembling the drawers without clamps which is the classic assembly. There is a lot of rapidly cooling fluid to displace if one relies on a fair bit of endgrain glue. Not a problem with liquid.

Then the other side of the issue is yellow glue or white holds the endgrain just as well. So if you want it, you can have it.

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#3

Statistics

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I had a friend of mine look at a picture of the glue fracture. He had software that could analyze the wood to glue failure.

' My best estimates place glue failure at approximately 26.88%. There was a small enough standard error. Jake'

I am going to have him analyze a laminated plane iron to see what the percentage of the blade is steel veneer.

Stephen

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#4

Upside

wilbur

>The good thing about having a dead horse to kick is that you can make glue after you're done. :@)

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#5

I agree

ron in Kokomo

>Well glued hide glue joints will last a lot longer than we will, and will make it a heck of a lot easier for the person who eventually will fix. it.

I have bought hide glue from catalogs for years or just used Knox gelatin for small jobs. I use a quart size potpourri pot for my glue.

Works great!

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#6

Re: I agree

ThomD

>It only makes it easier if the guy doing the work is a hide glue expert. Does anyone put anything in the piece to warn the potential conservator. I don't but other than that I'm probably fooling myself it will get treated right. Modern day conservators mostly look for hide glue based on age, so a new piece with hide glue will be from left field.

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#7

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

Paul Kierstead

>As a matter of pickiness, the squeeze out that you left in place probably improved the strength (possibly by quite a bit, but can't prove it). On the flipside, you didn't glue them flush and that probably improved the wood strength (and made the for more glue failure), since I would reason that it is easier to pull up up the wood fibres right at the end rather then in a little (if you follow me).

Re: Kicking a Dead Horse*

#8

That's where I'm from

ron in Kokomo

>You said

Modern day conservators mostly look for hide glue based on age, so a new piece with hide glue will be from left field.

I spend a lot of time out there :)