Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hide Glue joint test

Posts

Hide Glue joint test

#1

Hide Glue joint test

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This was inspired by Robin's post below on hot hide glue. I tried to replicate the test but didn't properly size the end grain as Robin did. I currently have one in clamp that is properly sized.

It looks like about 70% failure of substrate. The wood is Eastern White Pine.

Stephen


img

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#2

Yellow and CA glue test

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The turners use cyanoacrylate adhesive (CA) for attaching things to face plates and often with one end grain orientation. I expected CA to provide an excellent bond in this application. Left is "thick" CA. There was 100% adhesive failure. Right is "thin" CA catalyzed and there was only about 10% wood failure. Middle is several year old Titebond. (I was told by an adhesive chemist that it stays good so long as it doesn't get thick from water loss . That's regular Titebond, not the crosslinkable stuff).

There was almost complete wood failure with Titebond. The areas were there are not large splinters do have small pieces of wood adhering to them. I would estimate 80% wood failure.

The wood is air dried hemlock. The test block was about 3 " high. I could not bread any of the joints with my bare hands. Each was bashed with a mallet to break the joint.

I was shown a demo with 2 part 3M urethane joining two pieces end to end and I could not break the joint.


img

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#3

Re: Yellow and CA glue test

Dan Donaldson

>I just wonder how much difference a lot of this actually makes. Different glues have different characteristics any of which might be "best" for a given application. There is strong, stronger, strongest, and strong enough ;-) In many applications, I could make a part out of plastic or tool steel. The steel part would obviously be stronger, but if the plastic part is plenty strong enough for the application, then why would I want to use steel? The plastic is corrosion resistant and lighter, which may be just as important to me, not to mention a lot easier to make. As long as any adhesive is strong enough for the application, it doesn't matter if another is "stronger". I like hide glue because it is reversible, has a good open time, and generally does not interfere with finishes. As long as the project never comes apart when I don't want it to, it doesn't matter to me if epoxy or anything else is technically "stronger".

I am also not hung up on hide glue. The super glues work very well for some applications, and I also sometimes use Titebond or epoxy, depending on what I am after.

I guess my point is that it really doesn't matter for most applications and it is fine to use whatever you like best. Past a certain point, the question is more academic than practical.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#4

Re: Garbage in garbage out.

ThomD

>Hide glue is mainly to make the joint reversible so that it can be more easily repaired and for stuff like hammer veneering where it's unique properties come into play. Also it is claimed that the glue transmits sound better being harder than creepy glues like yellow, and generally easier to use than epoxy.

Most destructive tests only really replicate Chris Farley type furniture failures. I get pretty tired of the tests in magazines that are purely destructive, or test failure modes not found in nature (normally because the pieces is braced so that a failure of the type tested can't occur. Like two pieces of wood connected with dovetail or M&T that take a load like a car stand. Low peal load cycles to failure, and glue creep failure being two that are more in the realm of reality, and hard glues do survive those kinds of loads better.

Endgrain bonding is probably meaningless unless tested in shear. Not dissing current tests since they test a proposition that came up in the earlier part of the thread.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#6

Pragmatists

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>What I would like to see is a joint made with yellow glue and then neatly disassembled and cleaned of glue. I would also like to see strength data on a mortise and tenon joint that was glued with yellow glue, taken apart, and reglued with yellow glue. It is my understanding that yellow glue needs fresh surfaces for optimum bonding. Lets hear it from the yellow glue pragmatists.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#7

Re: Yellow and CA glue test

Paul Kierstead

>As long as any adhesive is strong enough for the application

Or, as is quite possibly the case in this test, no glue is strong enough (depending on the application, of course), because the joint will make the wood fail quite easily even if the glue holds. It is like the old adage that the glue is stronger then the wood, implying that the joint is good, but of course ignoring that regardless of the glue the joined wood will probably fail before unjoined wood (i.e. one piece); mind you, there are cases where a join makes it stronger (probably by allowing a grain direction change). All coming back to it is all up to the application, I guess :)

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#8

this strength debate deserves a timely death

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are valid reasons to prefer one adhesive over another. I think it can be safely concluded that joint strength is rarely a deciding factor.

Personally, I am too lazy to maintain a glue pot and learn to use it. But, so novices don't get confused, don't try to criticize my adhesive choice on the basis of joints not being strong enough. This argument is not supported by data or experience.

There are plenty of valid hide glue advantages to claim, such as reversibility or period authenticity, or less (no?) need for clamping. If we focus on the valid advantages, and not get distracted by alarming but irrelevant joint strength tests, by-standers can make informed choices of what adhesives they choose to use and not fret that their joints are not strong enough.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#9

Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death

Dean J in MN

>I agree Bill -- Strength tests are only a small part of the story. And possibly an unimportant one. There is no doubt any of the current crop of glues are strong enough to hold a joint. Beyond that it becomes an academic exercise.

But for the novices, as you state, please don't overlook the interesting properties of hide glue. Reversibility/repair may not be important to you now, but it may in the future. Aside from the reversibility issue, I'm won over by the great versatility of hide glue. With one bag of 251g hide glue I can have a glue which will make a fast rub joint (and require no clamping), a glue which gives me enough open time to get a dovetailed case together, or anything between. I'm not sure how "period" adding urea is, but for a one man shop I have no choice. I can't call "all-hands" to help me get a case together with non-modified glue. Once you get over the learning curve with hide glue you'll probably be smitten with it. I'd say that learning curve isn't as steep as some suggest.

Cheers!

-Dean

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#10

Re: Could not agree more, on all points

ThomD

>Blush. I guess I should write more at 5 in the morning local time, or maybe it's just April fools!

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#11

Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death

ThomD

>I love all glue. I agree that yellow glue is difficult to reglue and probably requires some clever technique I don't know, or some recutting of the joint. The problem with the reversability issue is who gets to reverse it. In the modern world the depressing reality is amazing stuff gets tossed the moment there is a new look, and the vast majority of stuff that might wear out is not likely to end up in the hands of a competant restorer. And if it does, and even if he is expert in hide glue there are a lot of ways of formulating it some are pretty tough to reverse. Having said that can anyone hook a guy up with some 251g glue?

The only time I have made a joint that later came appart was a mortise in a table leg, and it was glued with hide glue. Obviously my goof. I either got the dimensions wrong, which I doubt, or the glue had cooled a little too much. Still it proves it can happen, if one goofs.

The worst problem I have had with yellow glue is probably a table I have that was imaculately glued, and subsequently very slight level differences can be found between a few boards where they meet. The top was made of carefully matched, but random origin, boards. I guess they have a different expansion rate. I am probably the only person who has notices it but a picky client might also. I also sealed the endgrain with epoxy on this table, which was designed to reduce this kind of problem. Creep is becoming a problem in musical instruments. It seems to take a while to show up while the problem I had with my table top was quick to form. The top is fine there is just this little edge.

I like white glue, vs. yellow. It has less initial tack, and one can rub it out easily for rubbed joints. There is a formulation offered by LMII, that happens to be white, and is very creep resistant.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#12

Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have to agree that the fracture tests don't make much sense, the glue is stronger than the wood in most cases. But they are fun to do and look at, so no harm.

You wrote:

"I'm not sure how "period" adding urea is, but for a one man shop I have no choice."

I have a recipe from 1857 for making liquid hide glue, it called for adding nitric acid to the hot hide glue. Reported shelf life of 2 years. There are other recipes from around this time period with other anti gelling agents to make hide glue liquid at room temperature.

Stephen

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#13

Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death

ThomD

>I don't know the history of hide glue, but I do know a little of the history of dyes, and I can say with confidence that adding UREA would be right up their alley, and I can even imagine how they might have first thought to try it. :)

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#14

same "additive" was "discoverd" for plating baths

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#15

Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have learned a great deal from various strength tests over the years. I have learned that the temperture is not as critical as some articles would have people believe. I have had glue that I thought was a bit too cool to bond well still make a strong joint. and on the other extreme I have had glue get up over 180 for short periods and it was still good. I did finaly push a batch too far just to see how long at high temps it takes to degrade. It is painfully obvious than the vast majority of articles which mention anything about hide glue are written by writers who have rarely if ever used the stuf. I think many just rehash what others have written. The recent article in FWW was a welcome bit of real first hand info. In use the glue is very forgiving. keep in mind that the egyptions used the stuff without electric glue pots or thermometers. I think as hot hide glue fell out of favor many wood workers heard stories from the old guys and those stories have been pased down as fact in the absence of first hand info.

While most strenghth tests are not all that relivant they can give some ball park info that is usefull, such as the almost universaly poor showing of the moisture cure urethanes in a recent article. What I wanted to try and illustrate is that hot hide glue can be used to size the end grain and then the end grain part of the joint can add strenth. I would bet my glue pot that none of the tests that included hide glue used this techniqe. so in a way the results are not really a fair comparative example of the strength possible with hot hide glue.

Thom asked about where to locate some 251g glue. If you are just starting out you may wish to start with 192g. it will give you all the strength you are likely to need and will give a bit more working time before it gells. I have a tendancy to over thin the 251 in an attempt to gain a bit more time and this can starve a joint if I am not carefull. I prefer 192g, but would like to hear from Stephen about which works best when modifying to use at room temp. As far as suppliers go all the ones who are sponsers for the site who sell hide glue are likely buying from the same source, Mulligan and Higgins. M&H is the only manufacturer in the US so shop by price and vendor prefrence as the glue will likely be the same.

Robin

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#16

Re: sources.

ThomD

>I've used it off and on for years. I have been told that I need to buy a 50 pound bag, and all the stuff sold in stores is crap, though i forget why. FWW had an article on the last supplier so somehow that fact doesn't seem to be determinative. Maybe they just insist on having a consistant single batch so they never have to relearn it.

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#17

Re: sources.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Two types available are ground hide glue and pearl glue. The former is made from animal hides (etc.) and makes the best glue.

Pearl glue is made from bones. And while it is a good glue, it is not as strong as hide glue. Pearl glue is a little harder than hide glue when dried because of the ratio of condrin and glutin of the collagen.

(Pearl) Bone glue has more of an odor than hide glue.

Glue from M&H is of the first quality and Joel sells the stuff in different gram strengths. As for quality from batch to batch, there is some variation but if it is marked 192g then it is within the range of 178 to 206 grams Bloom (actually double grams Bloom).

The numbers given for gram strength of glue is given in mid range, so a batch can vary by the above numbers. That might be the advantage of buying a large quantity, then again maybe not.

Stephen

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#18

Joel sells 251 gram strength in 1 and 5 lb bags  *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>


Hot hide glue

Re: Hide Glue joint test

#19

That horse might be beaten, but it's strong!;-)

Alan DuBoff

>