Re: this strength debate deserves a timely death
ThomD
>I love all glue. I agree that yellow glue is difficult to reglue and probably requires some clever technique I don't know, or some recutting of the joint. The problem with the reversability issue is who gets to reverse it. In the modern world the depressing reality is amazing stuff gets tossed the moment there is a new look, and the vast majority of stuff that might wear out is not likely to end up in the hands of a competant restorer. And if it does, and even if he is expert in hide glue there are a lot of ways of formulating it some are pretty tough to reverse. Having said that can anyone hook a guy up with some 251g glue?
The only time I have made a joint that later came appart was a mortise in a table leg, and it was glued with hide glue. Obviously my goof. I either got the dimensions wrong, which I doubt, or the glue had cooled a little too much. Still it proves it can happen, if one goofs.
The worst problem I have had with yellow glue is probably a table I have that was imaculately glued, and subsequently very slight level differences can be found between a few boards where they meet. The top was made of carefully matched, but random origin, boards. I guess they have a different expansion rate. I am probably the only person who has notices it but a picky client might also. I also sealed the endgrain with epoxy on this table, which was designed to reduce this kind of problem. Creep is becoming a problem in musical instruments. It seems to take a while to show up while the problem I had with my table top was quick to form. The top is fine there is just this little edge.
I like white glue, vs. yellow. It has less initial tack, and one can rub it out easily for rubbed joints. There is a formulation offered by LMII, that happens to be white, and is very creep resistant.