Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

The Judging...

Posts

The Judging...

#1

The Judging...

Rob Lee

>... is underway!

Glad I'm not one of them...there're a lot of excellent entries!

Will post a few pictures later in the day...(forgot my camera cable!).

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The Judging...

#2

A few entries... *LINK*

Rob Lee

>... set up in our cleared out boardroom ...


Entries

Re: The Judging...

#3

The Judges.. *LINK*

Rob Lee

>From Left To Right...

Ellis Walentine (host - not judge!)

Brian Ebbinghaus

Chris Schwarz

Clarence Blanchard

(missing Wiley Horne)


Ellis and Judges

Re: The Judging...

#4

Re: A few entries...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Is the Sen's game on?

;-)

Re: The Judging...

#5

Re: The Judges..

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hmmm....nice hats.....but notice each one has a different hand position...hmmmmmmm

:-)

Re: The Judging...

#6

Re: The Judges..

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA------WebKitFormBoundar

>Facial hair appears to be a (the?) criteria for being a judge! My LOML says it seems to be a primary criteria for being a woodworker, so making it one for being a judge fits right in.

Cheers!

Jim (Who has a beard...)

Re: The Judging...

#7

Nice Hats!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: The Judging...

#8

Re: A few entries...

Pedder Broockmann

>Can't see any wood for testcuttings or -shavings????

Re: The Judging...

#9

Re: The Judging...

Alan DuBoff

>Rob,

I like the Yewish American Princess...very tasty! I just like the looks of that plane...I hope it works as well as it looks, not that it would matter to me...*LOL*

If that plane somehow gets sent back to me by accident, don't worry, I'll get it back to it's rightful owner...ahhhh...yeah...eventually... *wink*

Re: The Judging...

#10

Re: A few entries...

Rob Lee

>Hi -

There's a bench in there - and let me tell ya...the floor's a mess today...!!

Cheers -

Rob

(at the office, while Chris and Ellis continue to work....!)

Re: The Judging...

#11

What????!!! (in the right place)

Rob Lee

>We have to send all of these back???

;)

Re: The Judging...

#12

Rob's true, underlying wishes come to the surface

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>So - your secret desire was to add more stash to your already awe-inspiring collection of tools. Glad you made the promise in public to return them.

Re: The Judging...

#13

Re: Weird light in boardroom?

Edward in Vancouver

>Rob, what's that wierd light coming in through your board-room windows? I've never seen anything like it here in Vancouver......

Re: The Judging...

#14

Ok, just send ALL of them to me, then!

Alan DuBoff

>And I'll get *ALL* of them back to their rightful owners!

(eventually;-)

Re: The Judging...

#15

That should just be expected...

Alan DuBoff

>Everyone here should be expected to always be in the acquisition mode, no matter. If not for ourself, for others we know that will need tools!

This is exactly why a small '46 9A South Bend lathe followed me home last night, from a friend who got it from the Levi Strauss factory a couple weeks ago...(even boasts a tag to prove it;-) Looks like I'll be spinning my own split-nuts soon...*wink*

Re: The Judging...

#16

Oh that's just disgusting!!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You are a vacuum source in the universe, Alan. Dang! That's great.

Re: The Judging...

#17

Re: Weird light in boardroom?

Rob Lee

>Yeah - Tell me 'bout it...

It's reflection from the snowbanks......

:)

Re: The Judging...

#18

OT: Is that like a vortex? :-/ *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Here's a pic of it on my bench, I'll put a link to the gallery. This just fits on my bench like an old pair of 501s...:-)

Unfortunately the Levi Strauss tag is all blurred, I'll have to get another pic when it's light out.

I'm marking this OT as it's not a woodworking tool, but it makes them!*wink*


img

1946 South Bend 9A Workshop Lathe

Re: The Judging...

#19

Re: The Judging...

James Watriss

>So, for those of us who didn't manage to make even the extended deadline... What are the odds that this contest will run again?

Re: The Judging...

#20

No, it's as in "you suck"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Pretty little thing. I note with increased envy that you got one with the gearbox on it. My son's (was my revered uncle's) requires changing the backgears by hand, if I recall correctly.

Re: The Judging...

#21

Ellis Walentine

The thought has crossed our minds

Ellis Walentine

>This contest was great and grueling, requiring quite a bit of physical, logistical and mental gymnastics on everyone's part -- the judges, the contestants, the Lee Valley staff and moi.

This said, it was also an extremely rewarding and inspiring experience, to see the level of participation and the overall quality of the entries and to spend a weekend immersed in tool world with such an erudite bunch of folks. I'd be glad to do it again, maybe even make an annual event out of it. I think that now that we've established a benchmark, it might inspire a lot of people to think more in terms of toolmaking. We'll advise you of future plans once the results of this one are sorted out and we've had a chance to review the whole effort.

I would like to extend my profuse thanks to the Lee Valley folks -- to Rob Lee for conspiring with me to hatch this contest and for making the resources available and to his wife Lucie Robitaille and her assistant Kate Litva for attending to all the myriad details of shipping, receiving and planning the event -- and to judges Brian Ebbinghaus, Chris Schwarz and Clarence Blanchard for their keen insights and dedication to the task of judging this wild array of tools. Thanks also to Doug Orr for hanging out with us and casting his own inimitable light on the occasion.

I hope we are ready to roll out the results by early next week. Stay tuned.

Ellis Walentine, Host