Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

Posts

Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#1

Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi All!

Yet again, Lee Valley has a stunning catalog cover. Which I have a question about.....The cover photo shows an array of better than a dozen 'fish decoys', carved by Don Preston. For those who didn't receive the LV catalog, the link below shows a likeness of it.

My question: What is a fish decoy? And how are they used? When I saw the cover photo, I thought they were what we always called 'fishing lures'. But I don't see the treble hook on the bottom of these.

Wiley...who never caught anything on a lure (except for purple worms)


Don Preston's Fish Decoys

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#2

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo

danielarrowsmith

>Used in the north for fishing through the ice for muskie, sturgeon usually with a pitchfork weighted with lead, at least that was the way in the 30's and 40's. lure attracted them when thay were looking to feed

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#3

Re: Spearing decoys *LINK*

Dave Mount

>Daniel has it right, they're used for spearing through the ice, a small but signficant activity up here in the frozen country. Generally done from a darkhouse, small hut or outhouse-sized shack that covers a rectangular hole in the ice. Being dark inside, one can see pretty well down into the water. The decoys are jigged to attract fish, generally northern pike or muskies. The decoys are built so they travel in a circle when jigged up and down off a short stick. When a pike comes in to check it out, they are speared with a 3 or 5 tined, barbed spear. The spears are vaguely like pitchforks except they are barbed and the whole instrument is coplanar (all tines in the one plane with the shaft. They are also weighted to help them travel with authority down through the water, actually as much dropped onto the fish as thrown. This is not a "catch and release" sport.

Spearing decoys are generally homemade and are highly collectible, a kind of folk art similar to duck decoys.

There you go, more than you wanted to know. I gave you a linky below in case you still thirst for more. Page shows a view down an ice hole with a decoy and pike in view.

Best,

Dave


Ice spearing info

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#4

Actually.....

McKay Sleight

>The decoys are use to keep fish away from the ski boat. I use them all of the time as fish are not allowed anywhere near my ski boat.

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#5

Thank you Sir !

steve mackay

>

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#6

for catch and release fishing in CA

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Its not quite 4/1/08 but here goes anyway. Catch and release fishing, as practiced with conventional fishing lures, even with barbless hooks, is still considered cruel by PITA and many living in CA. Therefore, socially responsible fisherpersons now fish with hookless lures, called fish decoys. These fisher- persons are former bankers and the like and rolling in money so these decoys have become like Japanese saws, with each fisherperson sparing no expense to obtain decoys more impressive than their fisherperson partner.

A fish is counted as caught when the fisherperson feels a fish hit the decoy. However, this fishing leads to gross exaggerations of the size of the fish thus claimed as "caught". Bass Pro Shops now offer a small camera with LED lighting that can be trolled ahead of the fish decoy and it records the size of the "caught" fish. It is expected that a camera will become required in PITA sanctioned fishing contests as well as many fisherperson clubs.

I have not seen anyone fishing with decoys in TN. So, there you have it.

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#7

As a native Californian and longtime resident

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have to agree that catch and release is pretty stupid - I have no idea how many fish die after being released. I appreciate John McPhee's line that he's a "catch and eat" fisherman.

I guess these fish decoys are a watery version of camera hunters - a way of "hunting" without hurting. And, as Bill T. points out, a whole new opportunity for creative lying.

Fishing in the SF Bay Area, where I grew up, was so bad 40 years ago that I didn't stay motivated long. Maybe if I'd ever caught something. Astronomy got more interesting quickly, because at least you could see your goal. And soon after, of course, the opposite sex became even more interesting, though my catching skills weren't much better there.

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#8

So if I've got this right

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"...the fisherman sits in a dark house on a frozen lake or river..." (from Dave's link).

So, not just dark but cold too - and probably unheated, since most heat sources emit light as a byproduct and there's darn few GFCI outlets on the average frozen lake for radiant heaters.

The willingness of human beings to suffer for fun is boundless.

Bill, who lives in a state where people regularly spend entire weekends on a cliff face, sleeping like bats in rain and snow, in order to say "I climbed the North Face of [mountain]."

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#9

But you could see what you didn't want to catch

Wayne Carson "TX"

>

Re: Lee Valley's April 2008 Cover Photo *LINK*

#10

Re: As a native Californian and longtime resident

ThomD

>Right, forty years ago, the heyday of big trophy striped bass fishing in SF bay area. :)

John Betts has experimented with hooks that have an eye on either end so that they don't penetrate, and some fish can be caugh with flies made of yarn that tangle on their teeth.

Sure catch and release fishing is cruel, but where would be without that?

Mortality rates for C&R trout fishing have been calculated, and are fairly high say 15%. But C&R doesn't mean low impact, it's how it's done that counts. I have fished places where the fish were caught so regularly that they rolled on their sides to let you take the hook out. The first time I saw that I was surprised to say the least. There are some fish being caught dozens of times a season, possibly a week. Not much of a life.

C&R fishing makes lots of commercial sense, like cut and replant forestry. The motivation is money. Lee Wulff said it when he originally was pushing C&R for Trout and Salmon: "A trout is too valuable to catch only once". He may have meant something a little less material, but these days, it is the backbone of an industry that has grown by leaps and bounds, literally.

I attached a picture of four flies I tie for trout fishing. The smallest hooks are pretty small and cause less damage.


img