Re: hide glue joint test *LINK*
BobStrawn
>When I don't do destructive testing, it does itself. Sometimes even when I do destructive testing, the finished product still has flaws.
Until I find a bottle of PVA with a date of manufacture on it, I will continue to trust Hide Glue more. PVA has a six month shelf life, so for the home user who buys it at the Borg or Online, there is no certainty that the glue is still worth using.
Hide glue takes more planning, I have to mix it ahead of time, and have it ready in the pot, but I can trust that it is full strength when I use it.
PVA also makes the most glue resistant surface that I know of.
So if I use a nice wood, and put a lot of work into it, I would love to use PVA, it is strong, weather resistant and lasting. But since I cannot trust that it is fresh, and using it will ruin a piece if it is old, I cannot reasonably trust PVA for gluing without some serious testing.
Hide glue cures up to full strength fast enough for me to hold parts in place while they set. I can glue up an entire project without a wait, test it, and even steam it apart adjust and reglue in the same evening. It cleans up with water. So while hide glue takes more planning, hide glue takes less follow up. Unless I know the date of manufacture, pva is about as dependable as Schr�dinger's Cat. I will test some the day before and then use it for stuff that needs to be weather resistant, but that takes more planning than even hide glue.
In my own research, Tightbond 2 once it drys cannot be glued to by any glue I have used. That is why I now thin it with water and use it as a paint on working surfaces. A little wax on the Tightbond finish, and you have the perfect surface for doing your glue work on. I have even treated some wooden clamps this way.
When repairing broken joints, often the wood beneath the crack is also stressed so if you just glue it, it will break very near the original crack and now you have glue on glue issues.
Yet another reason to love hide glue, it is repairable!
Bob Smalser did the article linked to below on repairable glue joints.
So on Bob's advice I shelled out for some 2-part resorcinol. It has a 1 year minimum shelf life, and the manufacture date on the top of the can, so this is, for me, a much better option. Apart from the chemical issues and the dark purple color, and the mixing requirements... Stephen, how much alum do I add to make hide glue waterproof, and how waterproof is it?
Bob
Are your glue joints repairable?