Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

hide glue joint test

Posts

hide glue joint test

#1

hide glue joint test

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Thought I would share this pic with everyone as this is one of the things that hide glue excels at but it never seems to make it into any of the write ups about hide glue. This is a destruction test of a end grain to face grain butt joint. the end grain was a piece of port orford cedar and the face grain board was a piece of monterey cypress(Cupressus macrocarpa). The glue is 192g and the joint dried about 12 hours. one thing I do when glueing end grain is to paint the ends and let it sit for a couple of minuites and then clean the gelled glue off and re apply the glue and assymble the joint. by "pre sealing" the end grain with glue I am able to get strong end grain joints like the one shown where the fibers on the face grain board failed before the glue.

If any one is not very impressed with this then you should try to repeat this test with yellow glue.

Robin


img

Re: hide glue joint test

#2

Re: hide glue joint test

Darylee

>Are you using tradtional hide glue and a melt pot as our ancestors did, or a commercially available glue?

Re: hide glue joint test

#3

192g hot hide glue

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>

Re: hide glue joint test

#4

Re: hide glue joint test

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Robin,

Great post! I've never seen this property of hide glue brought out before (but there's a lot I haven't seen). Perhaps this works because hide glue can mechanically key itself into the end grain pores and voids better than yellow glue? Or is it more chemical adhesion of the glue to the end grain wood? (Maybe Stephen's book will go into this.)

This property of hide glue would make it work well with Krenov-type wall cabinets, where the sides have to be butt-joined to the bottom somehow. Krenov used dowels up through the bottom and into the sides, but that is pretty much a cross-grain gluing situation, where your technique would do well.

Wiley

Re: hide glue joint test

#5

WOW, who would of thunk...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Do you think liquid hide glue would perform as well?

Thanks for sharing this!

Re: hide glue joint test

#6

Works well on miters too!

Paul in NJ

>Hot hide glue worked well on the miter joint of the ogee bracket feet I glued last week. The strength of the joint surprised me. In some ways, hide glue reminds me of the West System epoxy glue I use on occasion.

Paul Dzioba

Re: hide glue joint test

#7

And if you didn't want that to happen...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>You could just warm the joint up to 145 degrees F. and it would just come apart. Do that with yellow glue or white glue or that poxy glue or that primate glue!

Great Post Robin!

Stephen

Re: hide glue joint test

#8

Re: hide glue joint test

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I'll let Stephen address the "why" question in his book as I am sure it will include 27 8x10 color glossy photographs with the circles and the arrows...

Possibly the most applicable aspect of this property of hide glue is in chair making where you are glueing a round tenon in a round hole. whether the mortise is in a chair leg or a chair seat, there are only two small areas of side grain contact and two small areas of end grain with the remaining grain being some angle of transition. I think it is fair to say that half the area of contact would be end grain or such a steep angle that it would qualify as end grain and form a week bond with yellow glue. To make matters worse the two areas of good side grain contact are 180* oposite with the weekest area of contact being perpendicular. this makes the joint strong in only one direction.

I think this same logic can also be used on how hide glue will provide a stronger bond in a standard square mortice and tennon joint as well, particularly if the clearence between the bottom of the mortice and the end of the tennon is close enogh to provide for a good bond.

I have always done routine destructive tests will all the glues I have ever used. I always encourage others to do the same as it is the only sure way to find out how good your joinery and glueing techniqes are.

Robin

Re: hide glue joint test

#9

hide not best for M&T: data

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>According to a widely quoted study by Hill and Eckelman and reported in Furniture Design (1973) the relative strengths of a rectangular M&T joint with various adhesives are as follows:

Phenol Resorcinol 1.00

Animal(hide) 1.05

Urea Formaldehyde 1.24

PVA (yellow) 1.32

I think the reason that PVA makes a stronger joint in this application is that it is a tougher plastic than the other materials. And it is not as bad a gap filler as some would believe. With a M&T gap of 0.008" (fairly sloppy) joint strength suffered only a 10% loss of strength (same article).

There are personal reasons that some prefer hide glue for this or that application, but loads of hard data says that better joint strength is not a valid reason. If something worked better than PVA adhesive for assembling furniture one would see the people that make 99.9999% of this furniture using it.

Again, these discussions are only important for new comers that have not settled on a choice, be it sharpening, tool metal or adhesives. If the goal is to make stuff that works, then the best guidance for "best" place to start is to do what professionals do. I see glue pots in re-creation (not recreation) shops, not shops and factories making product.

All these adhesives work fine for M&T or edges so long as th elumber is dry and the joint fits. The choice among them is driven by personal approaches to woodworking, not technical superiority. It needs to be made clear that new comers don't need to fret over finding a glue pot to be successful in making furniture unless they want to emulate that style of making furniture, and visa versa.

Re: hide glue joint test

#10

Re: hide glue joint test *LINK*

BobStrawn

>When I don't do destructive testing, it does itself. Sometimes even when I do destructive testing, the finished product still has flaws.

Until I find a bottle of PVA with a date of manufacture on it, I will continue to trust Hide Glue more. PVA has a six month shelf life, so for the home user who buys it at the Borg or Online, there is no certainty that the glue is still worth using.

Hide glue takes more planning, I have to mix it ahead of time, and have it ready in the pot, but I can trust that it is full strength when I use it.

PVA also makes the most glue resistant surface that I know of.

So if I use a nice wood, and put a lot of work into it, I would love to use PVA, it is strong, weather resistant and lasting. But since I cannot trust that it is fresh, and using it will ruin a piece if it is old, I cannot reasonably trust PVA for gluing without some serious testing.

Hide glue cures up to full strength fast enough for me to hold parts in place while they set. I can glue up an entire project without a wait, test it, and even steam it apart adjust and reglue in the same evening. It cleans up with water. So while hide glue takes more planning, hide glue takes less follow up. Unless I know the date of manufacture, pva is about as dependable as Schr�dinger's Cat. I will test some the day before and then use it for stuff that needs to be weather resistant, but that takes more planning than even hide glue.

In my own research, Tightbond 2 once it drys cannot be glued to by any glue I have used. That is why I now thin it with water and use it as a paint on working surfaces. A little wax on the Tightbond finish, and you have the perfect surface for doing your glue work on. I have even treated some wooden clamps this way.

When repairing broken joints, often the wood beneath the crack is also stressed so if you just glue it, it will break very near the original crack and now you have glue on glue issues.

Yet another reason to love hide glue, it is repairable!

Bob Smalser did the article linked to below on repairable glue joints.

So on Bob's advice I shelled out for some 2-part resorcinol. It has a 1 year minimum shelf life, and the manufacture date on the top of the can, so this is, for me, a much better option. Apart from the chemical issues and the dark purple color, and the mixing requirements... Stephen, how much alum do I add to make hide glue waterproof, and how waterproof is it?

Bob


Are your glue joints repairable?

Re: hide glue joint test

#11

Re: hide not best for M&T: data

Paul Kierstead

> If something worked better than PVA adhesive for assembling furniture one would see the people that make 99.9999% of this furniture using it.

If your use of "better" refers exclusively to joint strength, this is simply not true. People choose their adhesives for a wide variety of reasons, of which joint strength is clearly not the only one. For example, a great number of people veneer with contact cement, even though it is very demonstrably inferior (strength wise and lifetime) to urea formaldehyde (as is PVA for that application). Epoxy is demonstrably better (joint wise) to numerous glues in a wide range of applications, yet is relatively rarely used. Even if hide glue was much stronger then PVA, there is a very wide range of reasons it would be used, the primary one being that it much more of a skill within itself then using PVA.

The "best" adhesive is the one that best suits the worker, process and application. PVA often fills the first two extremely well and -- for woodworking -- does a good enough job of the last to be acceptable in the vast majority (please not I am not saying all) of applications.

Re: hide glue joint test

#12

Re: hide not best for M&T: data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Here in Pennsylvania, professionals use hide glue for mortise and tenon work. If you meet a woodworker and he tells you he uses yellow glue for tenons, you don't need to look at his stuff or ask further because you know what kind of woodworker he is. Everyone that I know in the reproduction trade uses hide glue.

Re: hide glue joint test

#13

Alice's Restaurant 1969

Wayne Carson "TX"

>

Re: hide glue joint test

#14

Re: hide glue joint test

Wayne Carson "TX"

>I did an ice box and covered MDF with QSWO on both sides. I used Hide glue and what was nice is when it gelled because I was slow (which I was) I was able to heat it with the wifes iron and finish hammering it. It was a pleasure working with it and I can't see me using anything else for the purpose. I think that each has it purpose and the trick is knowing which will work best for the job at hand. One should learn the propertys of each so he can make the right choice.

2 cents worth

Re: hide glue joint test

#15

Re: Any glue will work

ThomD

>It is often said that glue doesn't hold well on endgrain. Which is true in the sense that if:

- you take two pieces of wood and glue their end grain together it will not provide a bond that is strong enough to make the wood break anywhere else than the joint.

- But, repeat that test with the sidegrain and the joint is either the strongest part of the board or nearly so, in most situations.

- Glue the endgrain to the sidegrain, and while it will not break inside the endgrain piece, there is just as much change of it breking outside the glue joint on the sidegrain piece, as when sidegrain is glue up.

So really the side to end joint is no less storng than the much vaunted side to side joint, and it is full strength unlike the end to end joint.

It just so happens that in cabinetmaking we don't have too many situation that require endgrain to sidegrain, only, joints. Very comon in wooden composites when working with balsacore, for instance. When destructive testing dovetail joint the sidegrain will rip out if it was glued, but the joint is pulled by the time that happens.

With M&T there are two issues, lets say all the sidegrain gives up over 20 years and the joint opens, would it be good or bad for a repair if the endgrain pulled out the blind cover and left a big hole there. It sure isn't going to be enough by itself to save the joint.

Second question. Do you want your end that tight to the bottom of the joint in a crossgrain joint?

Liquid hide glue is weaker than regular because the formaldahyde used to keep it fluid degrades it. Most glues with the correct wetting properties will glue endgrain, including frozen water.

Re: hide glue joint test

#16

Re: hide glue joint test, data?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Robin,

In which direction did you wrack the pieces to get the fracture? Did you push with your hand or did you use a mallet?

Stephen

Re: hide glue joint test

#17

Re: hide glue joint test, data?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I placed the sample on the ground with the open side of the angle facing down.I then used my foot in more of a stomp vs a gradual application of force. The direction of fiber tear originated from the side closer to the center rater than the side closest to the end. If you are interested I can send you the samples.

Robin

Re: hide glue joint test

#18

Re: hide glue joint test, data?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Robin,

Thanks, if you could just send me a photograph, I would appreciate it and give you credit if I use it.

I am going to try and replicate the experiment with liquid hide glue, got a sample under clamp as we speak.

I will use your similar technique, if I understand how you did it. It would be an inverted V standing on the ground correct? Then you stomped.

I looked at the photograph and it look like it broke toward the edge.

Stephen

Re: hide glue joint test

#19

I don't agree

Dean Lapinel

>"Liquid hide glue is weaker than regular because the formaldahyde used to keep it fluid degrades it."

The additive in liquid hide glue doesn't degrade the strength. That's common knowledge as far as I know and... FWW tests seem to indicate the same.

The down side to an additive is that the properties of the glue will fail if the shelf life is too long. I add 3% urea to my 192 and it tests well as compared to full strength. This is a smaller percentage than what franklin uses but it still doesn't matter. My 3% gives me perhaps a minute longer which is all I need. I think Franklin uses 10-12% additive (not certain) so the "open" time is longer but it still works perfectly -IF fresh.

It's a shame that it's become an urban myth that liquid hide is inferior.

Re: hide glue joint test

#20

Re: I don't agree but agree

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Even if the addition of additives reduces the strength by 10%, fresh liquid hide glue still has 2700 psi holding strength.

"Liquid hide glue is weaker than regular because the formaldahyde used to keep it fluid degrades it. Most glues with the correct wetting properties will glue endgrain, including frozen water."

They actually other things like urea, salts and acids to allow hot hide glue to remain liquid at room temperature. They do continue to effect the protein bonds within the collagen so it will degrade over time. Freezing or cooling the liquid hide glue will prolong its usable shelf life.

Formaldahide is actually used to make hide glue waterproof. Your comment about proper wetting is absolutely essential for a proper adhesive bond with hide glue.

Re: hide glue joint test

#21

Hmm

Dean Lapinel

>Every expert in the country I have spoken to wouldn't agree to this "the addition of additives reduces the strength". With all due respect, writing a book may or may not make you an expert.

Please refer me to data that suggests this concept.

Re: hide glue joint test

#22

Re: Hmm

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Relax Dean,

It takes a fair amount of additive to start diminishing the strength of either hot hide glue or liquid hide glue, and that seldom happens. It is not until you add over 10% other things (in addition to the anti gelling agents) that the strength diminishes. And it diminishes over a curve.

Anti gelling agents are in the 8 to 20% range by volumn and they do through their action as gel suppressants, degrade liquid hide glue over time, simple chemical breakdown of the protein bonds. It reduces viscosity, gel point and the overall strength.

Bone flour is added to hide glue to help with gap filling on production furniture during the late nineteenth century. That is why some of the old glue is much creamier in color rather than translucent.

The most current reference is:

Handbook of Adhesive Technology by A. Pizzi, K.L. Mittal (ed.) - Marcel Dekker, Inc. NY 1994

There are several others but they are costly books, check out a good local university library. If you would like I will send you a bibliography so you can look at the original source materials.

Stephen

Re: hide glue joint test

#23

Re: Hmm

Paul Kierstead

>I don't like to take this stance, generally (it is, essentially, being an asshole), but when you make such a statement, particularly the bit thrown in about "writing a book", you have to name your experts and provide their qualifications. Otherwise your statement is as worthless as what you are suggesting Stephen's are.

Re: hide glue joint test

#25

You are correct Paul

Dean Lapinel

>Actually any statement has no value unless one does their own research...that includes mine.

Fair statement though and one I considered when I posted Paul. The problem is that I did most of my hide glue research long ago.

I can tell you that the good folks at Milligan & Higgins will likely tell you the same thing if you talk to their tech experts as I did. There was a lot of old material in Piano makers forums on hide glue. There is the fine gentleman in the Southeast known as Mr. Hide Glue because of his outstanding knowledge. There's also the somewhat believable FWW issue that tested the strength of Franklins, hot hide and other glues in M&T joints. The charts of "strength" listed Hot hide and Franklin as equal- so to speak.

My knowledge base is deeper than that though because of the extended time and my nature of research. Unfortunately, my study is personal so I don't collect data and names for the sake of argument.

I prefer to think of things as logical or not logical. What I think is logical is that the additives extend the set time but don't weaken the adhesion. I have never found anything other than anecdotal references to the contrary. The manner of adhesion is a large factor.

You are right though. I shouldn't have made a comment about the book as- it might look personal. I really meant what I also say about myself. On the internet no one is an expert and credentials mean nothing. �Knowing� is something that can be best accomplished by the curious that need to fulfill their curiosity. Recognizing these types may be done by an insightful person on the computer but is easiest in person.

Am I an expert? Not even close in my opinion. I still have too much to learn and that, that I do know is not static. In other words I know a lot but I know enough to know that I don�t know enough :)

Besides all of this I am certain that Stephen Shepard knows I have a great respect for him.