Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Posts

How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#1

How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Dave Mount

>A while back some folks here helped me find resources on how to make snowshoes. Well, this past weekend the neighbor lad and I cut down a 7" ash tree with a clear, straight bole, took a 12 foot log from it and split it up. The bad news was that this particular tree had a minor case of spiral grain, which gave about 60 degrees of rotation over the length of the log. That made shaping the strips a little interesting, but we ended up with 6 13/16" by 13/16" by 12-foot long 60 degree spirals. Although it was a pain to shave following a spiral, I'm not really worried about it as we can bend it back out when we apply the strip to the form; in fact, by each holding an end and twisting, we could straighten it without heating just with hand pressure. Kind of comical to cut down a tree and then yield nothing but 6 skinny strips of wood (and a huge pile of shavings). I buried them in a snowbank for safekeeping until we bend them.

Anyway, to the point. I need to figure out how to heat these pieces for bending. My steambox is only 4 feet long; I could make a bigger one, but I don't really have a way to generate the kind of steam that I think would be needed to heat an 11' plus long box. My thought is to use a hot water bath instead. The cross section of the pieces is relatively small to begin with, and the only part of the piece that has to take a severe bend is the toe, which is shaved down to only 5/16" thick. I made some wooden pitchforks a while back and was able to bend 1.25" rounds by just ladling boiling water over them for a few minutes.

My current thinking is to piece together a 12-foot section of 4" PVC pipe (might have to use something better than sewer and drain), cap one end, and fill it with boiling water (would take about 7.5 gallons). I thought I might surround the pipe with hay bales and loose hay (these I have) to help slow heat loss.

Any thoughts, suggestions?

Best,

Dave

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#2

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>Sounds like a plan Dave. One option is to use sawdust to insulate.

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#3

Re: Sawdust!?!? - Where would I get that? (JK)

Dave Mount

>

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#4

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

George Makowski

>Dave, What you suggest makes sense. But, given that snowshoes are traditional technology and were produced for a long time without the ability to steam all 11' of the outside frame at once, there has to be another way. That other way is somewhere in the written material on making snowshoes. I wish I could tell you where to look. I think in those terms you are on the right track in heating only sections with boiling water.

Let us know how you finally do it and post some pictures.

Though I live in the South now, I have always wanted to make a pair of snowshoes.

Good bending!

George in AL

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#5

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dave,

Dave wrote:

[I thought I might surround the pipe with hay bales and loose hay (these I have) to help slow heat loss.

Any thoughts, suggestions?]

I thought I might surround the pipe with hay bales and loose hay (these I have) to help slow heat loss.

Any thoughts, suggestions?

How bout wrapping the pipe with a blanket? Works for me on cold nights.

Marv

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#6

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

James Watriss

>I think I'd stick with steam for this project. I'll explain why.

While I like the idea of boiling water, and it might work, I think the steam idea will help minimize heat loss a little bit better. I think if you set it up so that there's a very small drip hole at one end, and have that end a few inches or more below the upper end, and attach the steam to the upper end, then the incoming steam will continue to bring in more heat.

The idea with steam bending is to add more heat, not more moisture... steam is used as a medium to transfer heat, to loosen the lignin. (I'm not trying to talk down here, I'm just puking out everything I know.) You can bend wood over a hot pipe, too. I think it'd be easier to keep pumping in more steam than to keep pumping in boiling water, and it's possible/probable that the incoming steam will actually be hotter than boiling water, allowing you to add even more heat energy.

As for not having anything to generate that much steam.. I don't really buy that. I bet you do, and it just hasn't occurred to you. You don't have to be fancy here, as long as the steam chamber is well sealed. A hotplate from goodwill or salvation army, and a well cleaned 1 gallon paint can could do the trick. Or a coleman stove. Or a blowtorch.

When I first learned steam bending we had a steam box made of plywood and used a wallpaper steamer to generate steam. You need heat, water, a water heating vessel, and a pipe. That's it. I've heard of people using old fry daddies, turkey friers, and other things. And the reality is, if you have a well insulated chamber, you don't need to generate buckets and buckets of steam. You just need enough replenishment steam to raise and keep the temperature up inside the pipe. PVC is only so big, and once your wood is inside, there's only so much space that you have to fill with steam. With a small enough drain hole, and a well insulated chamber, you can minimize steam loss at the other end of the pipe, minimize heat loss around the pipe's surface, and be able to get by with a smaller steam source than you think.

Another argument for steam. The boiling water trick will work, to a point. But only after there's been a heat exchange between the water and the wood, and the water, and the pipe. The water is going to be cooled down some as the wood heats up, and as the pipe is heated up. There's only so much heat going in, and once it's all bottled up, the only further heat exchange is going to occur as the whole unit cools. Steam allows you to keep adding heat into the equation, bring everything up to the desired temperature, AND KEEP IT THERE.

I think if you're looking for a good insulation material, there's a foil lined mylar bubble wrap at the home despot, right near the foil lined foam boards. Easy to wrap, no need to have to wrap it to contain, and it'd be easier to find a roll of that that will encase a 12 foot pipe.

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#7

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Not to quibble, but steam at atmospheric pressure is the same temp as boiling water. It takes pressure to raise steam temp above the boiling point of water.

However, I agree with using steam. It carries more latent heat than boiling water.

Bruce

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#8

a steam BTW

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>the steam powering the turbines in the big coal-fired power plants often is at 1000F and 2500 psi (after superheating).

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#9

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is how I bend pieces up to any length without having to build a steaming box. I seldom bend that long but I can.

I use sections of stove pipe of various lengths. So I place as many together as I need, usually just one or two, but I have done several sections so the pipe was 12 feet tall.

I place the section(s) of stove pipe into a large cast iron pot of boiling water on my stove, suspend the pieces on a wire at the top (the pieces have a small hole in the end for hanging) and cover with a tight fitting lid. The steam goes up the pipe, condenses and goes back down into the boiling water. It is done at one atmosphere, no pressure.

Works great, is flexible and has a small footprint. The heat of the stove heats the pipe, so there isn't a lot of condensation, which runs back down into the pot.

Stephen


img

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#10

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Holding method


img

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#11

Re: Elegantly simple!

Dave Mount

>

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#12

Re: Doh! A solution right in front of me. . .

Dave Mount

>Stephen's approach got me thinking and perhaps the answer is right in front of me. Maple season is almost upon us up here in northern MN and my father has a sugar bush and an evaporator that is basically a 6 foot by 16 foot steam table. All I need to do is come up with a cover to focus the steam a little. . .and I'll have the best smelling snowshoes around!

Thanks to everyone for the suggestions.

Best,

Dave

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#13

What a great solution, way to go, Stephen.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#14

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"But, given that snowshoes are traditional technology and were produced for a long time without the ability to steam all 11' of the outside frame at once..."

Why ever would we think that they couldn't make 11' steam boxes in the old days? Reading the early 20th century Popular Mechanics Shopnotes has humbled me considerably about what those old guys and gals could do.

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#15

Tasty, too!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#16

Re: What a great solution, way to go, Stephen.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Give the most lazy person the most complicated task and they will come up with the easiest solution.

Stephen

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#17

Re: What a great solution, way to go, Stephen.

John Stegall

>Stephen, I've been using that same statement for years. I never mind being called lazy.

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#18

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I once steam bent some 7' 1 x 2's in a piece of 4" PVC with a pair of tea pots on a double burner electric hot plate provideing the steam. It took a while for it to come up to temp each time I put a fresh board in, but it worked just fine. I used a wood disc to plug each end and cut some stickers to keep the wood off the bottom of the pipe. I don't remember what kind of tubing I used to conect the tea pots but I'm sure it was low tech and free as I was a student at the time.

Robin

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#19

Yep, I always claimed to be a lazy programmer. :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#20

Re: What type of PVC pipe?

Dave Mount

>Hi Robin--

Do you recall what grade of PVC you used (e.g., sewer and drain v. schedule 40)? I spent some time on the web yesterday trying to find info on whether sewer and drain would stand the temperature but didn't find anything. I was going to just boil a piece to see what happened to it, but if you've done it before. . .

Thanks.

Dave

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#21

Re: Yep, I always claimed to be a lazy programmer.

James Watriss

>"Most of you are familiar with the virtues of a programmer. There are three, of course: laziness, impatience, and hubris."

Larry Wall, creator of the PERL programming language.

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#22

Re: What type of PVC pipe? *LINK*

Brad in Ottawa

>When I researched steam bending I looked at using pipes before I built a small tray. (Not all of us are bending wood that is over 1' long!)

I seem to recall two things: the pipe can bend so it needs to be supported at intervals and that the wood inside should sit on dowels so that the steam can circulate around the wood.

The only information I can find from that research is on the LV site. The link below is to FREE information LV has on steam bending. Go to the links at the bottom of the page. In the booklet part 1 they state that regular ABS pipe can be used.

Hope this helps you!

Brad


LV Steam Bending Guide

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#23

My experience

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I bent some 6 foot laminations and used schedule 40 pvc, 4" diameter. With the first batch I supported it about a foot in from each end. The pipe sagged a couple inches. Second time around, I built a crude tray to hold the pipe, and that worked pretty well. Wooden plugs in each end with a weep hole at the bottom to drain water and prevent pressurization. The boiler was nothing more than a tea kettle found at a garage sale for $1 and a piece of radiator hose. My camp stove provides the BTU's.

Bruce

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#24

schedule 80 because it was free

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>It was schedule 80. Like the tubing the PVC was also free. I don't think that the extra wall thicknes was required because my steam box has a small hole on the bottom of one end for the condensation to drip out. Once it got going a little puff of steam would come out there as well so I know I wasn't buildong any kind of preasure that required the schedule 80. I am pretty sure that the material used for schedul 40 and schedule 80 is the same and only the wall thickness is different.

Robin

Re: How to heat 11-foot strips for bending?

#25

ROFLMAO

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>