Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

I just want to cry!

Posts

I just want to cry!

#1

I just want to cry!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>So I'm at the tail end of my tool cabinet project. All the plywood pieces are cut to size, the hardwood edge banding was applied, and the dados cut for the shelves and such. I was pretty damn pleased with myself. So now it's time to do a dry fit. And what do I find? That the dados cut into the upper and lower shelves are not matching up with each other! :>(

Somehow even though I was careful with the measurements and checked twice, I cut one set to the wrong side of the line!! Needless to say, I am pretty pissed off with myself now. Normally I'd just remake the pieces. But I already cut (13) 1/4" wide stopped dados in the other side of one piece. Trashing it now would mean hours more work getting it back to where I am now.

The one ray of sunshine in the whole mess is that these stopped dados will be hidden by the drawers. So applying a patch and re-cutting the dados seems my best bet. Hell, I think I can make it look like I INTENDED it to be this way. Or at least I can fool myself if I repeat it to myself enough!

So here's my thinking; I was going to rout out around each dado and inlay a nice new piece of wood. The patch would them be planed flat, a new dado laid out (and double, no TRIPLE CHECKED!!) and cut. The inlay would be wide enough, as well as deep enough to safely contain the new dado.

But I'm a little concerned about wood movement and grain orientation. The work pieces that feature the incorrect dados are plywood. I was planning on using hardwood as a patch (specifically cherry). I'm reasonably sure that the plywood will not move as much as the cherry. And as far as grain direction, the plywood doesn't really have any (right?). Consequently I plan on making it so that the hardwood patch's grain would be running perpendicular to the grain in the plywood's veneer, or parallel to the dado (which would make cutting it easier). Does anyone see a problem with this?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: I just want to cry!

#2

Re: I just want to cry!

ThomD

>You have a potential problem there for sure, particularly if your shop moisture varies much. Or you just developed a brand new locking dado joint. If I hear you to say that you will need to insert 13 shelf width patches of hardwood, all yo need to do is add up that cumulative width, look up the transverse moisture number and estimate what part of that you will experience in your environment. Think of the margin for sticking drawers, except here it sounds like you can't have any gap at all.

My advice to everyone is that if you make a mistake make it right. Obviously there are some projects that aren't worth it; of course there are some that can be fixed without detracting from the end result either aesthetically or structurally; some mistakes may lead to brilliant new objects. Where none of that is true and you harbour any reservations about how pleased you will be with the result, then do whatever you need to and get it right. Sounds like this is a hard faught project. You may need the redo, and you won't long remember the cost in time or money. A badly made piece of shop furniture is the gift that just keeps giving and just keeps reminding you that your standards are slack, or your estimate of what you deserve is low.

Re: I just want to cry!

#3

Re: I just want to cry!

wilbur

>Hi Dominic,

First you say:

"Normally I'd just remake the pieces. But I already cut (13) 1/4" wide stopped dados in the other side of one piece. Trashing it now would mean hours more work getting it back to where I am now."

Then you come up with a plan:

"So here's my thinking; I was going to rout out around each dado and inlay a nice new piece of wood. The patch would them be planed flat, a new dado laid out (and double, no TRIPLE CHECKED!!) and cut. The inlay would be wide enough, as well as deep enough to safely contain the new dado."

Which by my count is the same amount of work as remaking the pieces, except that you are adding the time to rout, inlay, and level 13 pieces of wood up front.

Did I miss something here?

Actually, if I understand out correctly, you only have to redo one of your dadoed boards -- just figure out which one to keep and redo the matching piece.

Re: I just want to cry!

#4

I mess up all the time...

Alan DuBoff

>But try not to let it hold me up, figure out a fix, do the best I can and move on with the project.

Yeah, it won't be perfect, and that is why woodworking is so fascinating for me, it's often about having the skill to recover from such mistakes and be able to finish the project in the end.

Better to craft with fault, than not to have crafted at all...I often say that to myself and it's true.

Sound like a great project, please post pics when you have it done.

Re: I just want to cry!

#5

I agree, Wilbur.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: I just want to cry!

#6

Re: I just want to cry!

Rob Lee

>Cheer up Dom...

... it's not as if it's two walls in your basement (either side of a doorway)...

DAMHIKT

Re: I just want to cry!

#7

Hi Wilbur

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I should have been clearer when I said that. I didn't just mess up one set of dados on one board. I messed them up on each board. So,...I just didn't screw up once. I screwed up TWICE. While I don't mess up as much as I used to back when I first started wood working, when I do,....it's a LUU-LU! :>)

They are offset from each other by 1/2" in each direction. If I just remake one board and match the dados to the other I will end up with drawer cubbies that are not the same size. While I could live with that, it would also make the piece appear lopsided since the drawer cubbies are centered across the front.

Re: I just want to cry!

#8

Re: I just want to cry!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Tom,

You wrote:

"If I hear you to say that you will need to insert 13 shelf width patches of hardwood"

Boy, I must have done a real crappy job of describing this problem! Sorry about the confucion.

The are one (2) 1/2" wide x 1/4" deep dados in question on two boards. The other side of one board features the (13) dados, and they match up PERFECTLY to the mating board. When I cut them I had those (2) boards back to back on my bench and I cut the dados all at once. I should have done this with the other boards, but NOOOOOO! I had to be all exact and rely on my plans!

Thanks for the input.

Re: I just want to cry!

#9

Re: I just want to cry!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Rob,

Thanks. I guess I just feel like a dolt because I deviated from the dimensions on the drawings I detailed! That'll teach me to turn off my brain.

You wrote:

" it's not as if it's two walls in your basement (either side of a doorway)... "

Whoa, whoa, WHOA! Now you've gotten me curious! Care to elaborate on this? :>) Come on, we won't tell anyone! :>)

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: I just want to cry!

#10

Re: I just want to cry!

Rob Lee

>....ah, well....

I ended up with the bottom of the doorframe a few inches out either side.... One of those squaring up errors.... it's why I now always bridge door openings with a removable frame...

I suspect I squared each panel to the adjacent wall, and then made sure they were vertical.... and this took 'em out of the same plane...

Turns out you can't really see it... until you look at the floor tiles. It's a 4' opening in the wall, so there's no actual door, thankfully...

I never found it until after all the drywall and painting had been done..

Cheers -

Rob

Re: I just want to cry!

#11

My latest screw up

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Dom, we all do it. It's heart-wrenching when it occurs. Then begins the re-build or the fix ... I do it so often that I think that this is just part of woodworking :)

Yesterday I was making some of the LAJ hotdog totes I recently wrote up. I planned to make about 20 for the guys who had asked me for them. The hotdogs are a lamination of three layers. Well I did a "stress test" on them this morning (put them on the plane and over-tighten the set screw) and half of them failed (fell apart).

It turned out that the centre piece on each of the failures had previously been lacquered .. and so the glue would not stick well on that side. To cap it, I had about 10 more glued up waiting to be turned. I had to toss them away. A day's work.

Began again....

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I just want to cry!

#12

Disagree slightly

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>As long as the Cherry inserts have grain running along the dadoes, I don't think you'll have a cross-grain problem. The Cherry will hardly change in length with the seasons, and the ply will hardly change either direction with the seasons.

As I understand, this is not on the drawers side, right? If it were and the kerf were off by only 1/8" over a 13" drawer width, you could simply apply drawer fronts that compensate.

I once made a plywood bookcase carcase for magazines for the workshop and cut some biscuits in the wrong orientation, so two shelves were off by 1/4" over their 30" length. You can see the slight slope. But I did not correct it, and every time I look at that thing it reminds me to draw X's on the appropriate side of the line.

Best, Ted

Re: I just want to cry!

#13

"Design Opportunity."

James Watriss

>This kind of thing happens, Dom. It's a test of character, really. Very few things are ever 100% perfect. There's always something, and more often than not, but no one but you will ever know once the finished project is done.

I have a long history of such things, but the one that comes to mind happened when I was building my tool chest at school. I was cutting the carcase sides to length, and I was almost done with the second one. It had maybe an inch to go on the table saw when it came away from the fence just enough to catch the back of the blade. It caught, rode up, spun 1/4 turn on the top of the blade while gathering speed, and walloped me in the stomach. I had a bruise for a week, and a bruised ego for months. Stupid kickbacks...

Originally, there was supposed to be a continuous grain pattern running all the way around the chest. The gouge happened right in the middle of what was to be the outside surface of the chest. It's now the inside of the chest. It's pretty straight grained mahogany, with a dark finish, so the grain shift isn't really obvious. Since the side with the huge arc gouged into it is now on the inside of the carcase, it's hidden completely by the drawers. Once in a while I'll show it to someone. It's pretty ugly, about 1/4" wide cut, and 1/4" deep, and sweeps for a fair piece.

But noone would ever know if I didn't show them.

It happens, Dom. Sometimes it's your fault, sometimes it's just out of nowhere. And it's a story about your chest that you'll remember for a while, and eventually it'll fade as you continue to learn from your mistakes. This is part of learning.

I think that somewhere along the way there's a shift in how I view the things I build. There's always the initial shining moment of inspiration, but I've learned that, like most things, the reality is almost always not quite the way I imagined it. Even if the dimensions are all as drawn, in the flesh, so to speak, there's a difference. There's always some intangible aspect of the tangible item that just isn't what I'd imagined... sometimes for worse, sometimes it's a pleasant surprise.

Like friends that I'd once thought would be with me forever, or the girlfriend I always thought I wanted. Or old tools I picked up, intended to be beaters, that turned out to be diamonds in the rough. Starting a furniture shop has been like that, too. I figured it would be a romantic dream... me making shavings and dust, and enough work at least to get by, and somehow, the little details would take care of themselves. It's amazing how many little details there are. It's not the dream I'd hoped for. It's worse in some ways, and much better in others. I think that this is one of the Zen aspects of woodworking for me... you chase the vision, but you come to know the reality, as it forms. Strive to make the world you want, and live enough in the moment to appreciate every unintended or unexpected part of it.

And really, the biggest shift in the work comes in the end when you lay a finish down. By the time all the little repairs are done, scraping and sanding is finished, and everything else, I'm so damned tired of looking at whatever it is. Drawers always need to be faired somehow, and dings and dents to be scraped or patched or hidden. And it's just not exciting work, no matter what anyone tells you. And as soon as the first drop of oil or varnish hits the wood, the colors change, the details pop, the grain comes alive, and the thing I was so ready to burn has disappeared completely, replaced by something that looks completely different.

Really, I kinda like some of the pieces I've made that weren't perfect. They tell a story about where I was, what level I'd attained, and they're something to look at later, to provide a touchstone for where you were at the time. Sometimes they're full of stupid mistakes, sometimes they're illustrations of a technique you were still learning at the time. And they're great for spontaneous reminiscing sometimes. I have a dresser that taught me very conclusively that for the end product, proportions are everything. All the pretty dovetails in the world won't keep something from looking dumpy if you proportioned it that way. And, of course, there were other stupid mistakes as well, and I ended up changing a few things along the way.

Of course, sometimes it really is just something stupid. Two weeks ago I had the lid off of a frame and panel chest I'd just built for my girlfriend for her birthday, and our two year anniversary. I carved a heart with our initials in the underside of the lid while it was off, and wouldn't you know it? I hadn't checked the orientation of the lid. I carved the heart upside-down. There really was nothing for it, I had to make a new lid. It goes that way sometimes. You walk out, shut off the lights, and come back the next day to make another go at it. And hopefully, you remember not to lock your keys in the shop like I also did that night.

The alternative is to have work that's always pristine and perfect, shows no growth, and looks somehow sterile after a while.

I can very much understand and relate to the frustration. Rejoice in your humanity, and take the time as you correct your errors to figure out just what went wrong, how to learn from it, and take everything you can from the experience. In the end, the finished project will bear little if any sign of your error, so there's no reason to wprry overmuch. It's a mistake. They happen. And we learn. It's not a bad thing.

"From failure we learn. Success, not so much."

Re: I just want to cry!

#14

Well said James

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>James,

Thanks for your response! I appreciate the time you took to impart these tidbits of wisdom to myself and the rest of the community here.

Needles to say, after a couple of days off from woodworking I have a much better frame of mind. I'm now ready to tackle this problem and overcome it.

It reminds me of a saying we used to toss around when I was first starting out as an Engineer. "If it was easy then EVERYBODY would do it!"

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: I just want to cry!

#15

It's hard to believe you're not Krenov or Maloof

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>who's been around for 80 years. I SO look forward to reading your thoughts.

Bruce

Re: I just want to cry!

#16

Re: It's hard to believe you're not Krenov or Malo

James Watriss

>I'm flattered. :)

I'm speechless for once... I'm really not sure what to say.

I bounced around aimlessly for a number of years after high school, and when I was earning my English degree, the professors all said to write what you know, write what you're passionate about... and it would be years before I'd find something I enjoy doing, enjoy talking about... something that's cool enough to want to get out of bed for.

It's nice to have people around who share the interest and the passion. That, and people who actually enjoy the ongoing quest for a thoughtful way to do something that's almost, but not quite, unlike anything else there is to do in life.

Guess this means I'm finally on the right track.

Re: I just want to cry!

#17

Re: I mess up all the time...

ThomD

>You can have it all. If you practice mistakes you end up getting excellent at them, which is something. I used to carry a ball retriever around and got about as much fun out of retrieving balls as I did playing the game. There was a reason for that...

Of course even golf is about fixing your mistakes, but some mistakes aren't fixable, you just have to know when to take your medecine or not.